Edwards v. Bibb County Board of CommissionersEdwards v. Bibb County Board of Commissioners
- Reporters:
- , ,
- Before:
- Sayre
This is an appeal from the circuit court of Bibb to reverse a judgment dismissing a common-law writ of certiorari by which appellants sought to quash the proceedings of the court of county commissioners in the matter of an election to establish a stock law district. Only two or three points made in the brief for appellants need be specially noted.
The proceedings in the commissioners’ court were had under the provisions of chapter 139 of the Code. Section 5881 of the chapter confers upon the courts of county commissioners, or courts of like jurisdiction, in their respective counties, full and complete authority to direct and supervise the holding of elections for establishing stock law districts, and to declare the results of such elections. In relation to such matters *556the court possesses original and unlimited jurisdiction, except where otherwise provided by law, to be exercised in conformity Avith the provisions of the Code. Section 3312. Section 5882 provides that a proceeding to establish a stock laAV district shall be commenced by filing a petition with the court of county commissioners. There is no prescription of notice of any kind to be given by the court, but the statute requires that upon the filing of the petition the court shall proceed to inquire and ascertain Avhether or not the petition is signed by a majority of the bona fide freeholders residing in and owning a freehold estate in the precinct to be affected outside of any incorporated city or town. If so, and other provisions of the statute to which Ave need not refer having been complied with, an election is ordered. Appellants contend that the statute is void for the reason that it authorizes the court to order an election affecting their property rights Avithout due process; that is, without personal notice to them, or some general public monition emanating from the court, by which they will be presumed to have been affected.
Windsor v. McVeigh, 93 U. S. 274, L. Ed. 914, Betancourt v. Eberlin, 71 Ala. 461, and other cases of similar character, to which appellants attach some importance, are not at all in point. The proceedings in those cases affected the very substance of property rights, were necessarily judicial in their nature, and involved therefore the necessity for mesne process of some sort to bring into court the parties whose substantial rights were to be litigated.
*558
Appellant relies on Commissioners’ Court v. Holland, 177 Ala. 60, 58 South. 270, and the cases therein cited-When the cases cited to Commissioners’ Cout v. Holland, came up for decision, the court of county commissioners was esteemed as an inferior tribunal of a strictly limited jurisdiction in respect of roads and stock law-districts, and to its orders and sentences in such matters it was necessary that its records should show affirmatively the facts upon which its authority depended. It was to prevent the-frequent miscarriages resulting from this status of the court’s jurisdiction that the statute was amended (section 3312, supra), to make it a court of original and unlimited jurisdiction in re-, lation to the establishment of roads and stock law districts. Uniformly it has been held under the statute in its present form that, where the record affirmatively shows that the court acquired jurisdiction of the subject-matter by the filing of a proper petition, as the record by its recital of facts found does show in this case, errors’ and- irregularities ■ intervening in the subsequent *560proceedings’ will not furnish ground for quashing the proceeding on common-law certiorari. — Benedict v. Commissioners’ Court, 177 Ala. 52, 58 South. 306; Cook v. Commissioners’ Court, 178 Ala. 394, 59 South. 483; Stephens v. Commissioners’ Court, 180 Ala. 531, 61 South. 917; Wright v. Commissioners’ Court, 180 Ala. 534, 61 South. 918. See, also, Kirby v. Commissioners’ Court, 186 Ala. 611, 65 South. 163. And it will be observed of Commissioners’ Court v. Holland, that the proceeding under review in that case was had under the local act of December 9, 1887, (Acts 1886-87, p. 739), the effect of which was to confer, jurisdiction only upon the filing of a petition by the 10 freeholders after notices had been previously posted as the act required. In other words, section 3312, supra, did not apply, for the reason that it had been otherwise provided by the prior local act.
The judgment of the circuit court is affirmed.
Anderson, C. J., and MoOrerran and Gardner, JJ., concur.