Edward B. Benjamin v. Western Boat Building CorporationEdward B. Benjamin v. Western Boat Building Corporation
- Reporters:
- , ,
- Before:
- Koelsch
This is an appeal from an order granting summary judgment in favor of the defendant. The trial court ruled that all claims were barred by the statutes of limitation. We hold that those counts sounding in contract and breach of warranty are time barred but a material issue of fact remains on the fraud count.
Edward Benjamin (plaintiff) entered into a contract with Western Boat Building Corporation (defendant) for the construction of a steel yacht. The
In 1969, a marine surveyor discovered that corrosion had eaten through the hull of the vessel from the inside out. The vessel was then partially stripped and dismantled, at which time plaintiff learned of corrosion in sealed areas that were ordinarily inaccessible.
Plaintiff brought an action on these facts for breach of contract, breach of warranty and fraud. The district court issued on order granting summary judgment for the defendant based on its conclusion that there was “no genuine issue as to any material fact under
Under Washington law which governs the relevant periods of limitation, Dam v. General Electric Company, 265 F.2d 612 (9th Cir. 1958), plaintiff’s claim for breach of contract and breach of warranty are time-barred. Plaintiff urges this court to rule that contract and warranty actions commence at the time of discovery of the breach. However, the Washington Supreme Court has held to the contrary, Taylor v. Puget Sound Power & Light Co., 64 Wash.2d 534, 392 P.2d 802 (1964), Nelson v. Sponberg, 51 Wash.2d 371, 318 P.2d 951 (1957), and its decisions are dispositive.
The fraud count alleged that defendant wilfully concealed the fact that the vessel was constructed with poor quality steel and not in accordance with plans and specifications. The State of Washington provides a three year statute of limitations period in actions for fraud.
Reversed in part and remanded.