148 F. 718 | E.D. Wis. | 1906
This is a demurrer to a bill in equity filed by complainants for the infringement of a patent and for an injunction and accounting. The demurrer is based upon 11 grounds. The demurrer is overruled as to the second, third, fifth, sixth, seventh, and tenth grounds of demurrer. The demurrer is sustained as to the fourth, eighth, ninth, and eleventh grounds.
. The ruling on the fourth ground, that “there is no sufficient allegation that the letters patent in suit were issued in the name of the United States of America, nor under the seal of the Patent Office, nor that they were signed by the Commissioner of Patents,” is predicated upon the case of Elliott & Hatch Book Typewriter Co. v. Fisher Typewriter Co. (C. C.) 109 Fed. 331, where the averments of the bill were identical with those in suit upon this subject. Under a liberal rule of pleading, the general averments in the bill that the patent was issued by the proper officers of the government, in conformity with the special acts of Congress relating to that subject, would probably be sufficient; but, inasmuch as the sufficiency of such general averments in a bill of this kind has been passed upon, I feel constrained to follow the authority of the case above cited.
As to the eighth, ninth, and eleventh grounds of demurrer, it was practically conceded by the learned counsel for the complainants, upon the argument, that it would be inequitable and unjust to require the defendants to make search and preparation upon the 18 claims in the
Reave is granted for the complainants to amend the bill, as they may be advised, on or before the January rule day.
