Eastmore v. BunkleyEastmore v. Bunkley
- Reporters:
- , ,
- Before:
- Lewis
This was a petition by Eastmore against the New Cumberland Island Company, to foreclose a contractor’s lien for a sum alleged to be due for constructing and repairing a certain dam and dock or pier on Cumberland Island. No defense was filed by the company, but at the trial term, over the objection of the plaintiff, the court allowed the executors of W. R. Bunkley to intervene and become parties defendant, on a petition in which they alleged that, as such executors, they held a mortgage on the realty against which the lien was sought to be established, which was for purchase-money of the property and was a superior lien; that the defendant company was insolvent, and the property insufficient in value to pay the mortgage debt; that the holders of the mortgage would have to pay the plaintiff’s claim if his alleged lien should be established; that these petitioners were not apprised of the foreclosure proceeding at the appearance term, and had just been ap*638prised of it for the first time; and that the defendant company’s failure to defend was due to its hope to impose a charge on the mortgaged property and thereby save itself from further obligation to pay it; which was wrongful and fraudulent. An answer denying the allegations of the plaintiff’s petition was filed by the intervenors, and the plaintiff moved to strike the answer, because: (1) The intervenors show no such cause as would entitle them to intervene. (2) The plaintiff is pursuing a statutory remedy, and is not proceeding on the equity side of the court. (3) It is not alleged that the defendant company is in the hands of a receiver, or likely to be so placed. (4) It is not alleged that there is a fund in hand over which a contest between the alleged mortgage and the plaintiff’s lien could be had. (5) It is not alleged that the intervenors have no remedy at law. (6) Their remedy is by money rule to contest for such funds as may be realized from a sale of the property under either their mortgage or the plaintiff’s lien. The court overruled this motion, and the plaintiff excepted. At the trial, before any evidence was introduced, the plaintiff contended that the burden in the case rested on the intervenors, and not on him, because: (1) The foundation of the suit was a contractor’s lien, which the law required to be in writing and recorded; and this being true, it assumed the dignity of a promissory note, and being regularly declared on, if proper service was had and no defense offered by the defendant, there was no burden on the plaintiff to make out his case, and had the suit1 stood simply between the plaintiff and the defendant no evidence would have been necessary in order that a verdict and judgment be had in favor of the plaintiff. (2) The case was in default as between the plaintiff and the defendant, and no burden to make out a complete case in favor of the plaintiff remained. (3) The intervenors having been made parties defendant and asserted certain facts in their answer, the burden of proving these allegations rested on them. The court overruled this contention and held that the burden was on the plaintiff. At the conclusion of the evidence introduced for the plaintiff, the intervenors moved for a nonsuit, because: (1) The evidence would not warrant a recovery. (2) It was clearly shown that the contract to do work on the dam was disconnected from the property on which the plaintiff sought to foreclose his lien. (3) The plaintiff failed to. prove the title of the property to have been in the *639defendant at the time the work was done. (4) No compliance with his contract was shown. The court sustained the motion, and the plaintiff excepted, assigning error on each of the rulings stated. By cross-bill of exceptions error is assigned on the overruling of a demurrer to the plaintiff’s petition, because: (1) No cause of action is stated. (2) The contract is not set out. (3) It is not alleged whether the contract was in parol or written; if in parol, its terms are not stated; if in writing, no copy is set out. Error is also assigned on the refusal to exclude certain documents set out in the cross-bill.
Affirmed. Gross-bill of exceptions dismissed.
All conmrring.