Durfey v. ThalheimerDurfey v. Thalheimer
- Reporters:
- , ,
- Before:
- Battle
Frank Durfey commenced suit against Benjamin and Sidney Thalheimer in the Pulaski Chancery Court, alleging in his complaint that he was the owner of a certain house in a residential part of Tittle Rock, Arkansas, which had been occupied by himself and his ancestors for many years; that defendants had purchased certain adjoining lots and intended to build on the same a brick livery stable, and to keep therein mules, horses and other stock, and all kinds of vehicles, and to operate it with a large number of servants, at all times, in the day and night. If built and operated, the stench from the animals and their droppings, danger from fire, swarms of flies, and the noises during the day and night would render it an intolerable nuisance, and greatly depreciate plaintiff’s property, and inflict upon him .an irreparable injury, and he asked that they be restrained from erecting the stable.
The defendants answered and denied the allegations in
Thereafter plaintiff and his wife, whom he had married since the institution of this suit, filed a supplemental complaint, in which they alleged, in addition to what was already alleged in the complaint, that the defendants had erected on the lots purchased by them a two-story building, and were using it as a livery and sale stable, .and kept many horses, mules and other stock and all kinds of vehicles, and have hired a large number of servants, mostly negroes, who are boisterous, blasphemous and offensive; that they keep on hand hay, grain and other highly inflammable material; that they stable their animals in the second story of the building, where windows open opposite to plaintiffs’ bed rooms and within a few feet; that odors from the animals and their droppings pour into their bed rooms, and make them uninhabitable; that the negroes are so placed that they have sight into the interior of their private apartments, and could, with small efforts, pass into them at any hour of the day or night; that plaintiffs and their children are kept in fear and dread of the negroes; that defendants openly violate the Sabbath by operating the stable on that day, thereby disturbing the quiet and rest of plaintiffs, who are members of the Christian Church; that their property has greatly depreciated, and has been rendered unfit for residence, and has been practically confiscated, as they can not use or sell it, and the health of Mrs. Durfey has been impaired; and they asked that defendants be perpetually enjoined and restrained from using the building as a stable.
The defendants answered and denied the allegations in the supplemental complaint; and alleged that they obtained a permit from the city to build the stable, and that it had been properly built and kept.
Evidence was adduced by plaintiffs tending to prove that they owned and occupied as a residence the lots and house thereon claimed by them in their complaint, and defendants had erected a brick livery stable on lots adjoining as stated in the complaint, which rendered the house of plaintiffs undesirable as a boarding house or residence.
Mrs. Wilson: She lives in fifty feet of stable, on sofi‘th side of plaintiffs. “The odor, noise ‘of horses, and ringing of bells wake her up often at different times during the night!”
Mrs. Banister: Resides at 313 Spring street, Tittle Rock, Arkansas. Knows defendants’ stable at. the corner of Third and Spring streets. Could not say that the noise of the stable disturbed her, .but have “heard noise and bells and smelt odors from there.” The noises did not awaken her, as she was a sound sleeper. Have heard horses and mules in the stable squealing and kicking. When it is dry could not smell odors, but can when it is damp, or the wind is blowing toward her.
D. B. Neal: Is a physician; visited Mrs. Durfey professionally ; the livery stable affected her health; while visiting her, noticed the proximity of the stable and the noises from the horses and negroes, but did not notice any obnoxious odors.
Tillar: Thinks property of plaintiffs greatly damaged in value on account of stable.
Greenwood: Occupied a room at 313 Spring street. The odors from the stable occasionally were not very pleasant.
The plaintiffs sustained the allegations in their complaint by their testimony.
Dr. G. M. D. Cantrell: “Practising physician thirty-one years. Knows the situation of the stable relative to residence. It is close. Would say as a physician that the unavoidable effect upon a family living in the house, of the livery stable, with a number of horses and mules and attendants, upon the health, quietude and enjoyment of the family, from the noise,-dust, odor and disturbance, would be about as near a total destruction of the property (the residence near the livery stable) as he knew or could think of. If his, he would do anything to get rid of it; would give it away, anything to get away from there.”
Carter Johnson, Morehead Wright, E. J. Bodeman, B. Bode-man, R. Colburn Butler, and J. E. Turpin, real estate agents, testified
Dr. Anderson Watkins testified: Is city physician of the city of Little Rock, and has been since 1898; is acquainted with appellant’s stable, and it has an admirable arrangement. The floors, sewerage and method of cleaning seems to be about as good as could be contrived. The stable is kept in .a sanitary condition, and nothing could be done by the owners to make it more so.
A. S. Reaves testified: Boarded three years at Mrs. Wilson’s, adjoining appellees’ residence. Prior to that time boarded in appellees’ residence. While at Mrs. Wilson’s, witness never detected- any disagreeable odors from appellant’s stable. Don’t know of any boarder leaving Mrs. Wilson’s on account of the stable. Mrs. Wilson has now more boarders than she ever had.
• Charles M. Simon: “Is acquainted with Thalheimer’s stable, and the stable is located in the livery stable district. Witness has a stable two blocks from’ Thalheimer’s, and has recently erected a building on Third and Louisiana streets, seventy-five feet from his stable, eight feet from Kraft’s stable, and the width of a street from Reinman’s and Ehrman’s stables; said building to be used as flats ; is in use now for the same and wholly occupied. That the proximity of said stable has not impaired the use of said building for flats nor its rental value. Thalheimer’s stable is the cleanest stable in Little Rock, except Kraft’s, and is equal to that in cleanliness; and Thalheimer could do nothing to make his stable more sanitary.”
Asbury Winder testified: “That he occupies a portion of Thalheimer’s stable — that is, fifty feet on Third street and ninety feet upstairs for a livery and boarding stable. He feeds at five and eleven a. m., and six p. m. ; takes about half an hour to feed. There are only two people in the stable after 8 p. M.; they all leave sometime before eight. The stable is swept several times a day, and the manure is taken out every morning. The bell which they use is so weak that it can hardly be heard on the sidewalk, as was shown by a test which was made. Witness is in the stable each day from seven a. m. until ten or ten-thirty p. M., and there is absolutely no -profanity or loud noises made either by himself or his employees. It is impossible to see out
Tom Kinley testified: Is night watchman at Winder’s stable, and works from eight p. m. to eight A. m. ; this is in appellants’ property. There are no noises in the stable at night and very little at feeding time. There is no profanity or singing. There are no odors, as the manure is taken out each day and the floors are cleaned three times a day.
Hugh Oliphint testified: “Has a stable at 1518 Scott Street. Is acquainted with appellants’ stable and doesn’t know of any which is kept cleaner or more sanitary than Thalheimer’s. Witness’ stable is in the residence district of Fifteenth and Scott streets; one residence being five feet away, another nine feet away, and another across the street; never had any complaints. Has visited Thalheimer’s stable, and never detected any odors there.”
Sidney Thalheimer sustained his answer by his testimony.
Dr. B. H. Merchant testified: “Veterinary surgeon for sixteen years. Visited Thalheimer’s stable often, as also other stables in the city. Thinks Thalheime‘r’s is the only stable in town that makes any attempt at sanitary consideration. It is the only well constructed one, and the only clean one. It is kept very clean, and is not injurious to health.”
J. J. Hawkins testified: “Is chief of police and chief sanitary officer; Thalheimer’s stable is in good sanitary condition, and there are no objectionable features.”
Peter Conrad testified: “Is a sanitary officer, and has inspected Thalheimer’s stable at least ten times. The stable is in good
F. G. Smith testified: “Is a sanitary officer, and has inspected Thalheimer’s stable several times this summer, and found it in better shape than any other stable in the city. Complaints have been made about other stables, but never one about this.”
John Peters testified: “Sanitary officer; Thalheimer has the best kept livery stable in Little Rock, and witness always found it in a good sanitary condition. It is the best constructed stable witness ever saw, and witness never found any objectionable features.”
J. W. Hopkins’ testified: “Is a veterinary surgeon, of sixteen years’ experience. Thalheimer’s stable is always kept in first class condition, and is far ahead of any other stable in cleanliness and from a sanitary standpoint. Witness has been there frequently, and was never bothered with any unpleasant odors — • never noticed any odor which could be offensive to anybody. Witness would have detected the same if they had existed.”
Permission was given to the defendants by the building inspector of Little Rock, Arkansas, to erect the livery stable.
After hearing the evidence adduced by all the parties the court refused to abate the stable of defendants as a nuisance, but perpetually enjoined and restrained the defendants from raising or opening any of their windows or shutters in the southern wall of the stable, and rendered a judgment in favor of plaintiffs against the defendants for $2,000 on account of damages sustained by plaintiffs in the depreciation of their property by reason of the erection of the stable. Plaintiffs and defendants appealed.
A livery stable, even in a city or town, is not necessarily or prima facie a nuisance. It may become so by the manner-in which it is constructed or conducted. It is the duty of every one to so use his property as not to injure that of another; and it matters not how well constructed or conducted a livery stable may be, it is nevertheless a nuisance if it is so built or used as to destroy the comfort of persons owning and occupying adjoining premises, creating an annoyance which renders life uncomfortable; and it may be abated as a nuisance. Joyce on the Law of Nuisances, § § 200-202, and cases cited; 2 Wood on Nuisances (3 Ed.), § 594.
In Jargan v. Waddell, 9 Iredell’s Law, 244, Chief Justice Ruffin, speaking for the court, said: “It is true that a stable in a town is not, like a slaughter house or a sty, necessarily and prima facie a nuisance. There must be places in towns for keeping the horses of the people living in them or resorting thither; and, if they do not annoy others, they are both harmless and useful erections. But, on the contrary, if they be so built, so kept, or so used as to destroy the comfort of persons owning and occupying adjoining premises and impair their value as places of habitation, stables do thereby become nuisances. They are not necessarily so, but they may become so.” Coker v. Birge, 9 Georgia, 425; Burditt v. Swensen, 17 Texas, 489.
It is said in Bohan v. Port Jervis Gas Light Company, 122 N. Y. 18: “While every person has exclusive dominion over his own property, and -may subject it to such uses as will subserve his wishes and private interests, he is bound to have respect and regard for his neighbor’s rights. The maxim ‘Sic utere tuo ut alienum non laedas’ limits his powers. He must make a reasonable use of his property, and a reasonable use can never be construed to include those uses which produce
In Owen v. Phillips, 73 Ind. 293, Judge Elliott, in speaking for the court, said: “The right of appellants was not merely to have their house protected from wrongful injury, but they had the further right to be protected in its comfortable enjoyment. Noises, odors, smoke and dust may possibly work the house itself no material injury, and yet render it impossible for the owner to live in it with comfort. The appellants were not bound to prove both an injury to the property itself and an interference with its enjoyment. * * * It is true, as a general rule, that such’ acts as result in a mere diminution in value of property, which can be fully and readily compensated in damages, will not supply grounds for an injunction, and parties will be left to the redress afforded by an action for damages. But, while this is true, it by no means follows that interference with the enjoyment of the property will not furnish grounds for relief by injunction, although the property itself may-sustain no physical injury whatever. The right to enjoy property is as much a matter of legal concern as the property itself. * * * The owner of property is entitled to enjoy the ordinary comforts of life, and that right is not to be measured by the notions of the people of a particular locality. * *• * No man has a right to take from another the enjoyment of what are regarded by the community as the reasonable and essential comforts of life, because the notions of the people of a given locality may not correctly estimate the standard of such comforts.”
But “a lawful and useful business should not be destroyed by injunction unless the necessity for doing so be strong, clear and urgent. He who asks the intervention of the court in such a case must show that tthe acts complained of do cause him substantial
The burden of proving that defendant’s livery stable deprived them -of the comforts of home or rendered life in their home uncomfortable rested upon plaintiffs. It was incumbent upon them to do so by a preponderance of the evidence. They adduced some -evidence to support their contention, but the preponderance of the evidence, as we view it, shows that the defendant’s livery stable was not such a nuisance as subjected it to abatement and their business to destruction by injunction; and that the court erred in rendering the judgment for damages.
But we think that the southern -wall of the stable of defendants, which is next- to plaintiffs’ residence, should have been made solid, and no openings should have been left therein for windows or doors, and, for the better protection of plaintiff, such
The decree of the chancery court is reversed, and the cause is remanded with directions to the court to render a decree in accordance with this opinion.
The stable, of course, can be abated by proper proceedings, if at any time hereafter it shall become a nuisance.
Hart, J., being disqualified, did not participate.