Duresky v. HansonDuresky v. Hanson
- Reporters:
- ,
- Before:
- Kelley
Appellants commenced an action to recover damages for personal injuries sustained in an automobile accident by service on the Commissioner of Public Safety 9 days after the 6-year statute of limitations had run. Respondent moved to dismiss, claiming the court did not have jurisdiction because of lack of personal service upon him and for failure of appellants to commence the action within the prescribed period of the statute of limitations. The trial court dismissed the action “with prejudice.” We reverse and remand for further proceedings.
On May 13, 1973, the appellants were involved in an automobile accident with the respondent Mark Hanson. At the time of the accident, respondent was a resident of the State of Minnesota. Following the accident, the respondent’s insurer reimbursed appellants $2,000 for medical expenses and $1,300 for damage to an automobile belonging to the appellants. A few months after the accident the appellants retained counsel to represent them. Over a lengthy period of time, negotiations were conducted between appellants’ attorney and respondent’s insurer in an attempt to settle the appellants’ claims for permanent injuries. In 1977 the respondent’s insurer made an offer for settlement which was rejected. Negotiations continued on into 1978. Near the end of the 6-year statute of limitations period, it became apparent to appellants that settlement could not be reached. Thereupon, they commenced efforts to locate Hanson so service of process could be made upon him. They did not locate him in Minnesota but ascertained a possible address of respondent in the State of Montana. On April 20, 1979, the summons and complaint were mailed to the sheriff of the Montana community for service on Hanson. On May 4 the sheriff executed an affidavit that Hanson could not be located there for service. On May 22, 1979, 9 days after the 6-year statute of limitations had run, appellants served the summons and complaint on the Commissioner of Public Safety in attempted compliance with
Hanson’s automobile liability insurer was notified of the commencement of the action by service on the commissioner. Subsequently, an answer to the complaint was filed on behalf of respondent in which he denied negligence and maintained the court lacked jurisdiction because the statute of limitations had run and because of lack of personal service of process upon him. Thereafter respondent moved to dismiss the action on both grounds. The trial judge dismissed the action with prejudice.
1. We must first determine whether respondent was “subject to process” during the 6-year period of the statute
2. Section 170.55 permits substituted service upon the Commissioner of Public Safety when the resident involved in an automobile accident has been absent from this state continuously for 6 months or more following the accident.
6
Appellants argue that because section 170.55 gives them the right to serve the commissioner as respondent’s agent, but only after it is established that respondent has been continuously absent from the state for a period of time in excess of 6 months, the statute operates to toll the general limitation statute for that 6-month period and, in effect, gives them, in addition to the 6-year statutory period of
3. In our view, under
The present case was dismissed on the pleadings.
See
Reversed and remanded for further proceedings.
Notes
.
Subdivision 1. Except where the uniform commercial code otherwise prescribes, the following actions shall be commenced within six years:
(5) For criminal conversation, or for any other injury to the person or rights of another, not arising on contract, and not hereinafter enumerated;
.
[I]f, after a cause of action accrues, he departs from and resides out of the state and while out of the state is not subject to process under the laws of this state or after diligent search he cannot be found for the purpose of personal service when personal service is required, the time of his absence is not part of the time limited for the commencement of the action, (emphasis added)
. In Nelson v. Sandkamp, 227 Minn. 177, 183-84, 34 N.W.2d 640, 644 (1948), we said:
The words “he departs from and resides out of the state” as used in§ 541.13 are to be construed as meaning he departs from and acquires a domicile out of the state. In other words, the statute contemplates a change of domicile as a prerequisite for tolling the statute of limitations. In this sense, the statute has been construed as if the words “residence” and “domicile” are synonymous in meaning (contrary to the accepted distinction in meaning), and that a change of domicile involves a change of a person’s true, fixed, and permanent home or place of abode, to which such person intends to return whenever he is absent. * * * A departure from the state which involves merely a temporary sojourn elsewhere, as distinguished from the acquirement of a new domicile, is insufficient to toll the statute of limitations. Whether a person departs from the state to domicile himself elsewhere is a question of fact for the jury, (citations omitted)
. We note as a practical matter appellants may not have been able to serve him because they apparently did not know his whereabouts, but he was still “subject to service of process” under the law.
.
Subdivision 1. As to a cause of action arising from any acts enumerated in this subdivision, a court of this state with jurisdiction of the subject matter may exercise personal jurisdiction over any foreign corporation or any non-resident individual, or his personal representative, in the same manner as if it were a domestic corporation or he were a resident of this state. This section applies if, in person or through an agent, the foreign corporation or non-resident individual:
(c) Commits any act in Minnesota causing injury or property damage * * *
Subd. 2. The service of process on any person who is subject to the jurisdiction of the courts of this state, as provided in this section, may be made by personally serving the summons upon the defendant outside this state with the same effect as though the summons had been personally served within this state.
Subd. 3. Only causes of action arising from acts enumerated in subdivision 1 may be asserted against a defendant in an action in which jurisdiction over him is based upon this section.
Subd. 4. Nothing contained in this section shall limit or affect the right to serve any process in any other manner now or hereafter provided by law or the Minnesota Rules of Civil Procedure.
Subd. 5. Non-resident individual, as used in this section, means any individual or his personal representative, who is not domiciled or residing in the state when suit is commenced.
.
Subdivision 1. The use and operation by a resident of this state or his agent, or by a nonresident or his agent of a motor vehicle within the state of Minnesota, shall be deemed an irrevocable appointment by such resident when he has been absent from this state continuously for six months or more following an accident, or by such nonresident at any time, of the commissioner of public safety to be his true and lawful attorney upon whom may be served all legal process in any action or proceeding against him * * growing out of such use and operation of a motor vehicle within this state, resulting in damages or loss to person or property, whether the damage or loss occurs on a highway or on abutting public or private property. * * * Such use or operation of a motor vehicle by such resident or nonresident is a signification of his agreement that any such process in any action against him * * * which is so served, shall be of the same legal force and validity as if served upon him personally * * *. Service of such process shall be made by serving a copy thereof upon the commissioner or by filing such copy in his office, together with payment of a fee of $2, and such service shall be sufficient service upon the absent resident or the nonresident * * * provided that notice of such service and a copy of the process are within ten days thereafter sent by mail by the plaintiff to the defendant at his last known address and that the plaintiff’s affidavit of compliance with the provisions of this chapter is attached to the summons, (emphasis added)
. The lack of precedent from other jurisdictions is probably the result of the unique provision in
. The record here fails to reveal what, if any, efforts were made by appellants or their attorney until very shortly before the statute had run to ascertain either if respondent had changed residence or continuously absented himself from the state for more than 6 months.
. The order of the court was a dismissal under