midpage

Drum v. SeawellDrum v. Seawell

District Court, M.D. North Carolina
Nov 30, 1965
C-168-WS-65
Reporters:
,
Before:
J. Spencer Bell, Edwin M. Stanley, Algernon L. Butler

J. SPENCER BELL, Circuit Judge:

This action is brought by the plaintiff, Renn Drum, Jr., a citizen of North Carolina and a registered voter, on behalf of ‍​‌​‌‌‌‌​​​​‌‌​‌‌​‌‌‌​‌‌‌​​‌‌​​‌‌‌​​​​‌‌‌​​​​‌‌​‌‌​‌‌‌‌‌‌​​​‌‌‌‌‌​‌‌‌‌​‌​​‌​‌‌​‌‌‌​‌‌​‌‌‌​​​​​​‌‌‍himself and others similarly situated against the Chairman and members of the North Carolina Board of Elections. He alleges invidious discrimination against himself and others so situated in the manner in which the State has been apportioned for the election of members of the two Houses of the State Legislature and of the United States House of Representatives. The action seeks a declaratory judgment holding Article II, Sections 5 and 6, of the North Carolina Constitution and the Acts apportioning the State to be unconstitutional and an injunction forbidding further elections until the Legislature shall properly apportion and if the Legislature fails properly to apportion within a specified time, that the court then do so itself. During the pendency of the action, D. S. Swain, Jr., moved for leave to file a complaint in intervention for the purpose of seeking an injunction against the holding of a special primary and election to fill a vacancy existing in the First Congressional District. The intervention was allowed.

The parties to the action have stipulated the facts with respect to the geographical areas, the population and the representation of each of the districts and counties into which the State is divided for the purposes of electing State Senators and Representatives and United States Representatives. The court finds the facts to be as stipulated with respect to these statistics and data, copies of which are appended.

The defendants concede that the complaint states a cause of action. Baker v. Carr, 369 U.S. 186, 82 S.Ct. 691, 7 L.Ed.2d 663 (1962); 42 U.S.C. §§ 1983 and 1988; U.S.Const. Amend. XIV. Jurisdiction is vested in this court under 28 U.S.C. § 1343(3) and the declaratory judgment act, 28 U.S.C. § 2201.

In Reynolds v. Sims, 377 U.S. 533, 84 S.Ct. 1362, 12 L.Ed.2d 506 (1964), the Supreme Court laid down guide lines to assist the lower courts in implementing the constitutional guaranties of suffrage. The Equal Protection Clause requires substantially equal representation for all citizens in a state in each of the two Houses of a state bicameral Legislature. This right may not be debased by weighing votes differently according to where a citizen happens to reside. Representation in state legislative bodies must be, as nearly as practicable, apportioned on districts of equal population though mechanical exactness is not required. Political subdivisions may be recognized but not at the cost of substantial equality among the several districts. Considerations of history, economic or other group interests or area alone do not justify substantial deviations from the equal population concept. Nor will the presence of large numbers of military and military related personnel justify the under-representation of an area. “Discrimination against a class of individuals, merely because ‍​‌​‌‌‌‌​​​​‌‌​‌‌​‌‌‌​‌‌‌​​‌‌​​‌‌‌​​​​‌‌‌​​​​‌‌​‌‌​‌‌‌‌‌‌​​​‌‌‌‌‌​‌‌‌‌​‌​​‌​‌‌​‌‌‌​‌‌​‌‌‌​​​​​​‌‌‍of the nature of their employment, without more being shown, is constitutionally impermissible.” Davis v. Mann, 377 U.S. 678, 691, 84 S.Ct. 1441, 1448, 12 L.Ed.2d 609 (1964).

The court, while rejecting a rigid application of a mathematical formula, has laid down two statistical tests in evaluating the State‘s “honest and good faith effort to construct districts, * * * as nearly of equal population as is practicable.” First, the minimum controling percentage; i. e., the percentage of the State‘s population which resides in the least populous districts which can elect a majority of each House; and second, the population variance ratio; i. e., the ratio between the most populous district and the least populous district of the State.

We turn to the congressional districting of the State. There are eleven districts and the proportional representation per district is 414,196 persons. We note that six of the eleven districts vary from the average by more than 10 per cent; four by more than 15 per cent, and only two districts are within 5 per cent of the average. The smallest district in population (the first) contains 136,335 less than the average while the largest (the eighth) contains 77,265 more than the average. No valid explanation is offered to justify these glaring discrepancies, if indeed they could be justified. We agree with the statement in the Amicus brief that the minimum controlling percentage is not significant. We are concerned with the population variance ratio of 1.8 to 1. Such a variance cannot be justified. In Wesberry v. Sanders, 376 U.S. 1, 84 S.Ct. 526, 11 L.Ed.2d 481 (1964), the Court said:

“We hold that, construed in its historical context, the command of Art. I, § 2, that Representatives be chosen `by the People of the several States\’ means that as nearly as is practicable one man\‘s vote in a congressional election is to be worth as much as another\‘s.”

Because of the unconstitutionally discriminatory apportionment embodied therein, we hold the statute (N.C.G.S. § 163-103) creating the several districts for the purpose of selecting representatives to the Congress of the United States to be null and void.

The Constitution of North Carolina (Art. II, §§ 5 and 6) provides that the House of Representatives shall consist of 120 members and that each of the State‘s counties shall have at least one representative “although it may not contain the requisite ratio of representation.” The remaining 20 are to be divided among the more populous counties. The House is now apportioned in accordance with this requirement. The proportional representation in the House is one member per 37,968 persons. The member from Wayne County has 82,059 constitutents and the member from Tyrrell 4,520. A population ‍​‌​‌‌‌‌​​​​‌‌​‌‌​‌‌‌​‌‌‌​​‌‌​​‌‌‌​​​​‌‌‌​​​​‌‌​‌‌​‌‌‌‌‌‌​​​‌‌‌‌‌​‌‌‌‌​‌​​‌​‌‌​‌‌‌​‌‌​‌‌‌​​​​​​‌‌‍variance of 18.2 to 1. Sixty-one of the least populous counties having a population of 1,234,325 can elect a majority of the House. Thus the minimum controlling percentage is 27.1%. These variances are too great to be acceptable. Reynolds v. Sims, 377 U.S. 533, 84 S.Ct. 1362, 12 L.Ed.2d 506 (1964); Lucas v. Forty-Fourth General Assembly, 377 U.S. 713, 84 S.Ct. 1459, 12 L.Ed.2d 632 (1964); Davis v. Mann, 377 U.S. 678, 84 S.Ct. 1441, 12 L.Ed.2d 609 (1964); Harris v. Anderson, 194 Kan. 302, 400 P.2d 25, cert. denied, 382 U.S. 894, 86 S.Ct. 185, 15 L.Ed.2d 150. We cannot accept the State‘s argument that this formula has been in the Constitution since 1836 and that the State re-entered the Union with the formula in effect. Reynolds v. Sims, supra. We note, however, that when the formula originally took effect the State had 65 counties, leaving 55 memberships in the House to be apportioned. Today with 100 counties only 1/6 of the House remains to be apportioned among the most populous counties. North Carolina has no provisions for initiative and referendum; its Governor has no veto power, thus the people of the State have no practical means by which to rectify an imbalance of representation in one of the most powerful legislative bodies in America.

We hold that the provisions of the State Constitution requiring that each county be afforded at least one Representative regardless of its population and the implementing statute (N.C.G.S. § 120-2) to be in violation of the Equal Protection provisions of the Fourteenth Amendment and therefore null and void.

The North Carolina Constitution, Article II, Section 4, requires the General Assembly to alter the senatorial districts after the return of every census so that each district, as nearly as may be, shall have an equal number of inhabitants. Pursuant to this mandate, the 1963 Act (N.C.G.S. § 120-1) apportioned the fifty Senators among 36 districts of the State. An examination of the evidence shows that each of the fifty Senators should ideally represent 91,123 persons; that the smallest district in terms of population contains 65,722 persons and the three largest, respectively, 123,260, 127,074, and 148,418. We note that the minimum controlling percentage is 47.1 and the population variance ratio 2.3 to 1.

We note that every one of the counties in the five most overrepresented senatorial districts is also overrepresented in the House and that the seven most over-represented counties in the House are included in the three most overrepresented senatorial districts.

While we note that the apportionment of the Senate is far more nearly equitable than that of the House, we may not validate either body in the abstract since it ‍​‌​‌‌‌‌​​​​‌‌​‌‌​‌‌‌​‌‌‌​​‌‌​​‌‌‌​​​​‌‌‌​​​​‌‌​‌‌​‌‌‌‌‌‌​​​‌‌‌‌‌​‌‌‌‌​‌​​‌​‌‌​‌‌‌​‌‌​‌‌‌​​​​​​‌‌‍must be considered in relation to the other branch of the legislative body as it is finally apportioned.

“* * * the proper, and indeed indispensable subject for judicial focus in a legislative apportionment controversy is the overall representation accorded to the State\‘s voters, in both houses of a bicameral state legislature.” Maryland Committee for Fair Representation v. Tawes, 377 U.S. 656, 673, 84 S.Ct. 1429, 1439, 12 L.Ed.2d 595 (1964).

We hold that the apportionment of the Senate as it now exists is not sufficiently grounded on population to be constitutionally sustainable. N.C.G.S. § 120-1 is therefore held to be null and void. Lucas v. Fourth General Assembly of State of Colo., 377 U.S. 713, 84 S.Ct. 1459, 12 L.Ed.2d 632 (1964). Counsel for the State has urged this court to furnish in its opinion as much guidance as possible to the Legislature, should we find it necessary to require reapportionment. In conformity with this request we point out that the variance ratio between the three highest districts and the remainder of the State is on its face unjustifiable in the light of the fact that the remainder of the State could be apportioned on a population variance of only 1.3 to 1. The obligation of the State is to apportion as nearly equally as possible on a population based representation, and even minor deviations must be free from any taint of arbitrariness or discrimination. Roman v. Sincock, 377 U.S. 695, 84 S.Ct. 1449, 12 L.Ed.2d 620 (1964).

The plaintiff having proven his charge of discrimination on the basis of population by evidence to which the parties have stipulated, the burden was placed upon the defendants to justify the variations from this standard which were shown to exist. The defendants have failed to meet this burden and we are forced to the conclusion that the plaintiff and those in his class are entitled to relief. Mann v. Davis, 213 F.Supp. 577, 584 (E.D.Va.1962). We will enter a judgment declaring the invalidity of the pertinent State constitutional and statutory provisions.

We cannot allow the regularly scheduled 1966 primaries and elections to proceed under laws now held to be invalid. We recognize, however, that it is fit and proper that the Legislature of this State should be given an opportunity to rectify the inequities which exist before this court should undertake to do so. Ample time now exists before the primary scheduled for May 28, 1966, for the Governor to call a special session of the Legislature. We will, therefore, stay the mandate of our injunction until January 31, 1966, in order that such a session may be convened. If apportionment compatible to constitutional standards cannot ‍​‌​‌‌‌‌​​​​‌‌​‌‌​‌‌‌​‌‌‌​​‌‌​​‌‌‌​​​​‌‌‌​​​​‌‌​‌‌​‌‌‌‌‌‌​​​‌‌‌‌‌​‌‌‌‌​‌​​‌​‌‌​‌‌‌​‌‌​‌‌‌​​​​​​‌‌‍be achieved by that date this court will regretfully undertake to fashion a scheme of apportionment which will permit the 1966 primaries and elections to proceed on a just and equitable basis. We think that the right of the people of the First Congressional District to be represented in the Congress during the interval which must intervene while adequate consideration is given to a statewide reapportionment of our Congressional representation requires us to decline to interfere with the special election which has been called to fill the vacancy in that District.

Jurisdiction in this matter is retained.

An order will be entered in accordance herewith.

 APPENDIX TO OPINION
CONGRESSIONAL DISTRICTS — 11

             Proportional Representation Per District = 4,556,155
                                                        --------- = 414,196
                                                           11
             Minimum Controlling Percentage - 48.6
             Population Variance Ratio      - 1.8 to 1

                                               Population     Population
                               Percent of      Shortage for   Excess for      Percent of
District     Population in     State‘s Total   Apportioned    Apportioned     Over or Under
             District          Population      Representation Representation  Representation
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
No. 1         277,861            6.099           136,335                        + 32.9
No. 2         350,135            7.685            64,061                        + 15.5
No. 3         430,360            9.446                           16,164         -  3.9
No. 4         460,795           10.114                           46,599         - 11.3
No. 5         454,261            9.970                           40,065         -  9.7
No. 6         487,159           10.692                           72,963         - 17.6
No. 7         448,933            9.853                           34,737         -  8.4
No. 8         491,461           10.787                           77,265         - 18.7
No. 9         404,093            8.869            10,103                        +  2.4
No. 10        390,020            8.560            24,176                        +  5.8
No. 11        361,077            7.925            53,119                        + 12.8

HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES - 100 COUNTIES WITH 120 MEMBERS

             Proportional Representation Per Member   = 4,556.155
                                                        --------- = 37,968
                                                           120
             Minimum Controlling Percentage - 27.1
             Population Variance Ratio      - 18.2 to 1

             Number of                          Population
             Representatives   Population Per   Apportioned
County       in House          Representative   Shortage       Excess
---------------------------------------------------------------------
Alamance         2                 42,837                      4,869
Alexander        1                 15,625        22,343
Alleghany        1                  7,734        30,234
Anson            1                 24,962        13,006
Ashe             1                 19,768        18,200
Avery            1                 12,009        25,959
Beaufort         1                 36,014         1,954
Bertie           1                 24,350        13,618
Bladen           1                 28,881         9,087
Brunswick        1                 20,278        17,690
Buncombe         2                 65,037                      27,069
Burke            1                 52,701                      14,733
Cabarrus         1                   68,137                      30,169
Caldwell         1                 49,552                      11,584
Camden           1                  5,598        32,370
Carteret         1                 30,940         7,028
Caswell          1                 19,912        18,056
Catawba          1                 73,191                      35,223
Chatham          1                 26,785        11,183
Cherokee         1                 16,335        21,633
Chowan           1                 11,729        26,239
Clay             1                  5,526        32,442
Cleveland        1                 66,048                      28,080
Columbus         1                 48,973                      11,005
Craven           1                 58,773                      20,805
Cumberland       3                 49,473                      11,505
Currituck        1                  6,601        31,367
Dare             1                  5,935        32,033
Davidson         1                 79,493                      41,525
Davie            1                 16,728        21,240
Duplin           1                 40,270                       2,302
Durham           2                 55,998                      18,030
Edgecombe        1                 54,226                      16,258
Forsyth          3                 63,143                      25,175
Franklin         1                 28,755         9,213
Gaston           2                 63,537                      25,569
Gates            1                  9,254        28,714
Graham           1                  6,432        31,536
Granville        1                 33,110         4,858
Greene           1                 16,741        21,227
Guilford         4                 61,630                      23,662
Halifax          1                 58,956                      20,988
Harnett          1                 48,236                      10,268
Haywood          1                 39,711                       1,743
Henderson        1                 36,163         1,805
Hertford         1                 22,718        15,250
Hoke             1                 16,356        21,612
Hyde             1                  5,765        32,203
Iredell          1                 62,526                      24,558
Jackson          1                 17,780        20,188
Johnston         1                 62,936                      24,968
Jones            1                 11,005        26,963
Lee              1                 26,561        11,407
Lenoir           1                 55,276                      17,308
Lincoln          1                 28,814         9,154
McDowell         1                 26,742        11,226
Macon            1                 14,935        23,033
Madison          1                 17,217        20,751
Martin           1                 27,139        10,829
Mecklenburg      5                 54,422                      16,454
Mitchell         1                 13,906        24,062
Montgomery       1                 18,408        19,560
Moore            1                 36,733         1,235
Nash             1                 61,002                      23,034
New Hanover      1                 71,742                      33,774
Northampton      1                 26,811        11,157
Onslow           2                 41,353                       3,385
Orange           1                 42,970                       5,002
Pamlico          1                  9,850        28,118
Pasquotank       1                   25,630        12,338
Pender           1                 18,508        19,460
Perquimans       1                  9,178        28,790
Person           1                 26,394        11,574
Pitt             1                 69,942                      31,974
Polk             1                 11,395        26,573
Randolph         1                 61,497                      23,529
Richmond         1                 39,202                       1,234
Robeson          2                 44,551                       6,583
Rockingham       1                 69,629                      31,661
Rowan            2                 41,408                       3,440
Rutherford       1                 45,091                       7,123
Sampson          1                 48,013                      10,045
Scotland         1                 25,183        12,785
Stanly           1                 40,873                       2,905
Stokes           1                 22,314        15,654
Surry            1                 48,205                      10,237
Swain            1                  8,387        29,581
Transylvania     1                 16,372        21,596
Tyrrell          1                  4,520        33,448
Union            1                 44,670                       6,702
Vance            1                 32,002         5,966
Wake             3                 56,361                      18,393
Warren           1                 19,652        18,316
Washington       1                 13,488        24,480
Watauga          1                 17,529        20,439
Wayne            1                 82,059                      44,091
Wilkes           1                 45,269                       7,301
Wilson           1                 57,716                      19,748
Yadkin           1                 22,804        15,164
Yancey           1                 14,008        23,960

STATE SENATORIAL DISTRICTS - 36 WITH 50 SENATORS

District Senatorial Data: Proportional Representation Per Senator = 4,556,155 Minimum Controlling Percentage - 47.1 --------- = 91,123 Population Variance Ratio - 2.3 to 1 50

                                                Population    Change Needed for
                     Population   Percent of    Underage for  Overage for     Number      Population per   Equal Senatorial
Senatorial           of           State‘s       Apportioned   Apportioned     of          Apportioned      Representation
District             District     Population    Representation Representation Senators    Senator          Shortage    Excess
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
No. 1                 67,990        1.492         58,570                         1            67,990        23,133
    2                 65,722        1.442         60,838                         1            65,722        25,401
    3                 73,879        1.622         52,681                         1            73,879        17,244
    4                 82,706        1.815         43,854                         1            82,706         8,417
    5                165,844        3.640         39,284                         2            82,922         8,201
    6                 86,683        1.903         39,877                         1            86,683         4,440
    7                 81,365        1.786         45,195                         1              81,365         9,758
    8                 78,608        1.725         47,952                         1            78,608        12,515
    9                 98,132        2.154         28,428                         1            98,132                     7,009
   10                178,533        3.919         51,973                         2            89,266         1,857
   11                 82,059        1.801         44,501                         1            82,059         9,064
   12                181,654        3.987         55,094                         2            90,827           296
   13                 93,867        2.060         32,693                         1            93,867                     2,744
   14                 89,102        1.956         37,458                         1            89,102         2,021
   15                148,418        3.258         21,858                         1           148,418                    57,295
   16                195,867        4.299         69,307                         2            97,934                     6,811
   17                181,359        3.981         54,799                         2            90,680           443
   18                189,383        4.157         62,823                         2            94,692                     3,569
   19                 85,674        1.880         40,886                         1            85,674         5,449
   20                 89,541        1.965         37,019                         1            89,541         1,582
   21                246,520        5.411        119,960                         2           123,260                    32,137
   22                162,286        3.562         35,726                         2            81,143         9,980
   23                189,428        4.158         62,868                         2            94,714                     3,591
   24                178,642        3.921         52,082                         2            89,321         1,802
   25                272,111        5.972        145,551                         3            90,704           419
   26                 82,817        1.818         43,743                         1            82,817         8,306
   27                 79,254        1.739         47,306                         1            79,254        11,869
   28                 98,021        2.151         28,539                         1            98,021                     6,898
   29                 97,611        2.142         28,949                         1            97,611                     6,488
   30                127,074        2.789            514                         1           127,074                    35,951
   31                183,678        4.031         57,118                         2            91,839           716
   32                102,253        2.244         24,307                         1           102,253                    11,130
   33                 92,649        2.033         33,911                         1            92,649                     1,526
   34                 71,873        1.577         54,687                         1            71,873        19,250
   35                186,157        4.086         59,597                         2            93,078                     1,955
   36                 69,395        1.523         57,165                         1            69,395        21,728

Case Details

Case Name: Drum v. Seawell
Court Name: District Court, M.D. North Carolina
Date Published: Nov 30, 1965
Citations: 249 F. Supp. 877; 1965 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 6184; C-168-WS-65
Docket Number: C-168-WS-65
Court Abbreviation: M.D.N.C.
Log In