Dozier v. Dozier, 21 S.E.2d 655

Dozier v. Dozier

21 S.E.2d 655 | Ga. | 1942

The exceptions being taken to a judgment refusing interlocutory injunction, which was entered after hearing evidence, and there being no brief of evidence specified or made a part of the record, no error is shown, and the judgment will be affirmed.

No. 14193. JULY 15, 1942. The bill of exceptions of Mrs. Dozier brings up for review an order, entered upon interlocutory hearing, dissolving previously granted restraining orders and denying prayer for interlocutory injunction. The only record specified and brought up consists of the petition as amended, the defendant's answer, an affidavit signed by the plaintiff "filed and considered by the court in rendering judgment," together with the judgment excepted to. There is no brief of evidence specified or referred to in the exceptions. The copy of the affidavit mentioned as it appears in the record bears notation signed by the judge as follows: "Considered as part of evidence." What other evidence may have been before this court in such manner that it can be considered, and the only questions made by the assignments of error necessarily involve a consideration of the evidence, this court can not adjudicate that any error was committed or that there should be any judgment of reversal."Roberts v. Cairo, 133 Ga. 642 (4) (66 S.E. 938). A recent application of this rule was made and a judgment of affirmance *269 entered in McElveen v. O'Kelly, 193 Ga. 824 (20 S.E.2d 69). For a collection of authorities as touching the requirement for a brief of evidence in differing situations see BostonInsurance Co. v. Harmon, 66 Ga. App. 383 (18 S.E.2d 84). The basis of the rule announced is that where evidence is heard, it can not be ascertained whether error was committed in rendering the judgment based upon it, unless it can be examined, the presumption being that the judgment was valid, being based on some evidence to support it. The rule must be applied in this case.

Judgment affirmed. All the Justices concur.