Donalson v. ThomasonDonalson v. Thomason
- Reporters:
- , ,
- Before:
- Evans
The action was in trespass for cutting timber, by John E. Donalson against T. I. Thomason. The plaintiff claimed title to the land and timber, and the defendant claimed title only to the timber on the land. The plaintiff was nonsuited, and error is assigned on this judgment. It was admitted that F. E. and C. E. Graham owned the land, and that both parties deraigned their respective titles from them. On April 6, 1906, F. E. and C. E. Graham executed a mortgage on the land to the Decatur County Bank to secure a debt of $2,500; the mortgage was recorded the next day. The Decatur County Bank foreclosed its mortgage, ‘and also obtained a common-law judgment; and the land was sold, by virtue of executions based on these judgments, for the sum of $2,100, to the Decatur County Bank, and a deed made to it by the sheriff on October 8, 1908. On February 8, 1909, the Decatur County *850Bank executed a quitclaim deed to the plaintiff. The common grantors, F. B. and C. R. Graham, on February 9, 1907, conveyed the timber on the land to Smith and Howell, who conveyed it to the defendant. The timber was cut and removed from the land after the plaintiff obtained his deed; and its value was proved. In moving for a nonsuit, the defendant insisted that the evidence disclosed that the mortgage from the Grahams to the Decatur County Bank was defectively executed, and illegally recorded; and that he and his vendors were bona fide purchasers for value, without notice of the lien of the mortgage.
Allusion is made, in the oral testimony, to the record of the conveyance of the timber from the Grahams to Smith and Howell. The date of its record, and whether it was properly attested for record, is not made to appear. Hence the question is not presented as to whether, under our registry laws, a subsequent purchaser of land under a recorded deed, who. has made a partial payment, without notice actual or constructive of a prior mortgage, acquires title free of such mortgage.
Hnder the evidence the plaintiff was entitled to go to the jury. We have discussed the various aspects of the case as presented by the evidence, so that on the next trial the case may be more fully developed and tried under the principles of law herein expressed.
Judgment reversed.
All the Justices concur.