Dodge v. HartDodge v. Hart
- Reporters:
- ,
- Before:
- Ladd
But the evidence fails to establish a state of facts upon which the appellant rests his argument. The real design in leaving the space back of the Empire Block is not disclosed by the record. It may have been because of the convenience of an alley at the rear of the building, or for the reason that storerooms 80 feet long were large‘enough for business purposes, or owing to necessity of such space for the transaction of the peculiar kind of trade then carried on. That it was deemed essential in the early days of the city’s life is not questioned. While this might furnish a strong reason for its dedication as an alley, it also quite as satisfactorily explains why it was not otherwise occupied. Dp to the time of the fire, in 1867, it was mainly used by the occupants of the Empire Block, though also by any one who wished to drive or walk through. But it must be remembered that the principal purpose of a public alley is to furnish the owners of the abutting lots and those dealing with them convenient access thereto. The main lines of travel are in the streeets. Webster defines an “alley” as “a narrow passage or way in a city, as distinct from a public street.” And this was adopted by the supreme court of Minnesota in Winston v. Johnson, 42 Minn. 398 (45 N. W. Rep. 958). In Bailey v. Culver, 12 Mo. App. 183, it was said, when not private, to mean a “narrow street in common use,” and was declared a road in Sharrett‘s Road, 8 Pa. St. 92. In Bagley v. People, 43 Mich. 355 (5 N. W. Rep. 415), the court said: “It is designed more especially for the use and accommodation of the owners of property abutting thereon, and to give the public the came unqualified rights therein would defeat the very *689■end and object intended.” See, also, Horton v. Williams, 99 Mich. 427 (58 N. W. Rep. 369). Alleys are not intended “to be substitutes for streets, but to serve as means of accommodation to a limited neighborhood for chiefly local convenience.” _ Beecher v. People, 38 Mich. 291. Our statute, in authorizing cities and towns “to establish, lay off, open, widen, straighten, narrow, vacate, extend, improve and repair” alleys, distinctly recognizes their public use and necessity. The extent and manner of such use must inevitably depend largely upon location and the character of the business, conducted by the occupants of the buildings abutting thereon. The Empire Block was the business center of the city, and the use of this strip, mainly by the proprietors of the stores therein and those dealing with them, was not different than it would have been if platted as a public alley. True, little discrimination was exercised in those days by residents of the city in traveling over vacant land. These circumstances are mentioned, not as establishing a dedication, but as indicating the situation prior to the erection of the defendant’s building; for, even though a private way, it might have been thereafter dedicated as an alley. McAllister v. Pickup, 84 Iowa, 65.