Dobbs v. HollandDobbs v. Holland
- Reporters:
- , ,
- Before:
- Smith
Lead Opinion
It is said the act is an infringement upon the jurisdiction of the county court, in that it undertakes to disburse county funds. In reply to this contention, it may be answered that a similar contention was disposed of in the case of Cain v. Woodruff County, 89 Ark. 456. There the constitutionality of an act fixing the fees for keeping county prisoners was questioned of being in conflict with section 28, article ,7, of the Constitution, and the court said: ‘ ‘ The fees and salaries that are paid by the respective counties to their respective officers are matters of local concern to the respective counties; and yet no one doubts that the Legislature has the power to fix the amount of those fees’ and salaries, and does. It Í3 because the exercise of that power is not in conflict with the provision of the Constitution relied herein upon by appellee. And so, too, the provisions of Act No. 136 of the General Assembly of 1907 are not inhibited by that provision of the Constitution.” Moreover, the money disbursed is that entitled by way of fees under the authority of an act itself, as we hereinafter decide.
The serious question in the case is whether the act is in conflict with section 11 of article 19 of the Constitution.
The act under review designates the compensation of the prosecuting attorney as salary and provides that the Greenwood District of Sebastian County shall pay $900 and the Port Smith District shall pay the sum of $1,800 and that Scott County shall pay the sum of $300 as salary to the prosecuting attorney, and that said sums shall be in lieu of all fees allowed by law for his services. Certain allowances for expense are also made together with allowances for the services of deputies, which compensation is paid in the same manner and in lieu of fees. No change is made in the fees of the prosecuting attorney, but the act provides that these fees shall he paid into the treasury of the respective counties.
Section 7 of the act provides that the quorum courts shall annually appropriate the sums sufficient to cover the expenses provided for in the act, and that until a meeting is held by said quorum courts the respective county clerks shall issue upon vouchers approved by the respective county judges monthly warrants to cover the expense therein provided for and that at the first meeting of the quorum court an appropriation shall be made to cover such back warrants.
We must assume, therefore, that the Legislature had it in mind that a maximum salary of $400 for prosecuting attorneys had been fixed in the Constitution and had enacted the act under review to conform thereto. It will be observed that this section 11 of article 19 does not fix the maximum compensation of prosecuting attorneys; upon the contrary, the exception is expressly made that prosecuting attorneys may receive to their own use any fees, costs, perquisites of office or other compensation which may be allowed by statute.
Now, no change is made in the fees of the prosecuting attorneys; they remain the same and are to be collected as they formerly were, but, instead of being paid to the-prosecuting attorney, they are paid into the county treasury. ’ The Legislature was no doubt advised what fees had formerly been collected by the prosecuting at= torney in this judicial circuit, and no doubt assumed that those fees would hereafter equal the compensation fixed by the act, and we think it a fair construction of the act to say that the Legislature intended that the compensation fixed in the act should be paid out of the fees which the act provided should be collected and paid into the county treasury.
Section 23 of article 19 of the Constitution provides that no officer of this State, nor of any county, city or town shall receive, directly or indirectly, for salary, fees and perquisites more than $5,000 net profits per annum, and that all sums in excess of this amount shall be paid into the State, county or city treasury as shall be directed by appropriate legislation.
In the case of Griffin v. Rhoton, 85 Ark. 89, it was held that this section of the Constitution applied to prosecuting attorneys, but it was there also held that it was not self-executing and could become effective only after appropriate legistlation had been enacted for that purpose. Evidently the legislation under review was enacted for that purpose. Section 3 of the act provides, “That in
It is true the act designates the compensation there fixed as salary, but that designation is not determinative of the fact that a salary has been fixed and we consider the act as a whole to determine its intent and meaning.
We conclude, therefore, that the salary of the prosecuting attorney has not been increased beyond the constitutional limitation but that a compensation has been fixed payable out of the fees which he earns, and that the act does not, therefore, offend against the Constitution.
Dissenting Opinion
(dissenting). I am unable to find language in the statute under consideration which justifies the construction that the salary fixed by the statute is to be out of fees collected and paid into the treasuries of the respective counties or that the payment by any of the counties of its allotted proportion of the prosecuting attorney’s salary is not to be exceed the amount of such fees paid into the county treasury. Certainly the statute does not contain any words to that express effect. It reads that the fixed salary is payable in lieu of all fees — not out of the fees collected — which means that the salary is to be paid in the place of fees, and I think it necessarily follows from that language that the lawmakers meant to give the prosecuting attorney of the 12th Judicial Circuit the amount of salary fixed in the statute, regardless of the fees paid into the treasury. I do not feel at liberty to read into the statute a restriction which the language used does not imply. If it had been intended to confine the salary
If the statute be construed as authorizing the payment of salary of the prosecuting attorney out of county revenues, regardless of the amount of fees collected and paid into the county treasury, then it is void for the reason that the prosecuting attorney is a State officer (Griffin v. Rhoton, 85 Ark. 89), and it is beyond‘the power of the Legislature to impose on a county the burden of paying the salary of a State officer. Cotham v. Coffman, 111 Ark. 108.