192 Pa. 188 | Pa. | 1899
Opinion by
In 1897, two actions of trespass were brought against the de
On the trial, the joint plaintiffs were nonsuited by the learned trial judge for the reason given by him in the concluding sentence of his charge, viz: “ the plaintiff either saw the dangerous wire and tread upon it, or was negligent in failing to see it, and in either case having contributed to the accident, we must direct the entry of a compulsory nonsuit.” Doubtless, for the same reason, because there is no possible ground for any other, he afterwards denied the motion to take off the nonsuit. Hence this appeal by the plaintiffs. The specifications of error, so far as relevant, are directed to the court’s action in refusing to take off the judgment of nonsuit.
It was not denied, nor could it be with any reasonable hope of success, that the evidence tended strongly to prove that the defendant company was grossly negligent in leaving the wire in a position where it was liable to come in contact with other wires heavily charged with electricity, and thus endanger the lives of unsuspecting pedestrians and others passing and repassing along and across the public street. One of the two reasons assigned in support of the motion for a nonsuit was, “Because plaintiffs failed to prove negligence upon the part of the defendant.” This was wholly unwarranted by the testimony, and the learned trial judge rightly disposed of it by saying : “The evidence showed that the defendant in making some alterations in its line allowed an arc wire to lie upon the pavement in a much traveled part of the city, without guard or warning to passersby; that the plaintiff stepped upon it, and immediately received a shock that felled her to the ground and occasioned the injuries of which she complains. This, in our judgment, was sufficient to establish the negligence of the defendant in the first instance and require it to make answer.”
Inasmuch as the case goes back for trial by a jury,.further comment.on the questions involved is neither necessary nor desirable.
Judgment reversed, motion to take off nonsuit granted, and record remitted with a procedendo.