Dennis M. Wolfel v. Herbert R. Bates, Gary BrownDennis M. Wolfel v. Herbert R. Bates, Gary Brown
- Reporters:
- ,
- Before:
- Martin
Counsel for appellant Dennis Wolfel appeals the trial court’s dismissal of his motion for attorney’s fees. This appeal requires us to clarify the procedure by which counsel may seek, and the court may determine, permissible fees for appellate litigation when the motion for attorney’s fees raises disputed factual issues.
In the underlying action, Ohio state prison inmate Dennis Wolfel prevailed in a pro se action in the district court on a section 1983 claim alleging denial of his first amendment right to petition for redress of grievances. The trial court awarded Wol-fel nominal damages but denied punitive damages. The State appealed and Wolfel cross-appealed the denial of punitive damages. Wolfel was represented on that appeal by attorney Michael Geltner. In an opinion filed on June 3, 1983, this Court affirmed both aspects of the trial court’s decision. 707 F.2d 932.
On June 9, 1983, Geltner moved this Court for an award of attorney’s fees pursuant to
Geltner renewed his motion in the district court. That court, relying on our decision in Buian v. Baughard, 687 F.2d 859 (6th Cir.1982), held that a district court may not award attorney’s fees to counsel for appellate work when we have declined to award costs to the party who seeks attorney’s fees. It is from this decision of the district court that Wolfel now appeals.
In
Buian
we held that recovery of costs
on
appeal is “a prerequisite to the award of attorney’s fees under
Problems may arise, however, when counsel submits to the appeals court a motion for attorney’s fees that, as here, raises disputed issues of fact. Here, appellee Bates questioned the validity of the rate charged and hours expended by counsel for appellant Wolfel. Faced with this factual issue, this Court, in its order dismissing appellant Wolfel’s motion for attorney’s fees, deferred to the superior factfinding powers of the district court. Unfortunately, by the date of the entry of this Court’s order, our Clerk had already issued a mandate denying Wolfel’s request for costs. The district court was thus prevented by our decision in Buian from considering Wolfel’s motion for attorney’s fees.
To avoid the double obstacles of inadequate factfinding and a collision with our
Buian
decision, the appeals court may by order pursuant to
To forestall any future delays in bringing this case to a close, we note that we
We also note that this is not an appropriate ease for application of the “carving out” principles of Hensley v. Eckerhart, 461 U.S. 424, 103 S.Ct. 1933, 76 L.Ed.2d 40 (1983). Geltner’s cross-appeal for punitive damages and his defense of the State’s appeal of the award of nominal damages involved a “common core of facts” and was, indeed, a “single claim.” See Hensley v. Eckerhart, 103 S.Ct. at 1940. Therefore, the Hensley Court’s direction to separate successful from unsuccessful claims is inapplicable. “Instead the district court should focus on the significance of the overall relief obtained by the plaintiff in relation to the hours reasonably expended on the litigation.” Id. We bring these conclusions to the district court’s attention only in order to prevent yet another round of “the least socially productive type of litigation imaginable: appeals from awards of attorney’s fees....” Id. at 1944 (Brennan, J., with Marshall, Blackmun and Stevens, JJ., concurring in part and dissenting in part).
Accordingly, the district court should determine the appropriate amount of attorney’s fees for attorney Geltner’s work on the original petition on appeal from the district court’s judgment on the merits, the earlier motion for attorney’s fees in this court, the motion for attorney’s fees in the district court, the appeal of the denial which is now before us, and the proceedings on remand.
The judgment of the district court is vacated. Wolfel’s prior motion to recall the mandate in Nos. 82-3059 and 82-3060 was denied before oral argument was heard in this case. We will sua sponte recall the mandate in Nos. 82-3059 and 82-3060, direct that costs be entered for Wolfel, and remand that case to the district court for an award of attorney’s fees consistent with this opinion. Appropriate orders shall be entered.
Costs of this appeal are awarded to appellant.