DeMaupassant v. EvansDeMaupassant v. Evans
- Reporters:
- Before:
- Boyer, Spector, McCord
Tony Cunningham, of Wagner, Cunningham, Vaughan, Hapmer & May, Tampa, Robert Orseck, of Podhurst, Orseck & Parks, Miami, for appellee.
BOYER, Judge.
Consideration of the record on appeal, the briefs and oral argument of respective counsel in this cause fails to convince us that reversible error occurred in the trial of this personal injury action.
The primary issue raised by appellant is that the verdict rendered by the jury is excessive. We must reject that contention when we view the evidence adduced on the issue of damages in light of the principles expounded in this court‘s decision in St. Vincent‘s Hospital, Incorporated v. Crouch, Fla.App. 1st 1974, 292 So.2d 405.
However, we do think that this case raises an issue which should be considered by the Supreme Court of Florida when it next undertakes a revision of the Rules of Civil Procedure. But for the specific provision of
This case arises out of a collision between a taxi cab in which plaintiff was the passenger and a vehicle driven by appellant William Edmund DeMaupassant and insured by appellant State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company. Plaintiff initially filed suit against appellants, the taxi company and the cab driver. The case proceeded to trial against all of those defendants. During closing arguments the plaintiff‘s attorney as well as the attorneys for the taxi cab company and the cab driver laid the blame for the accident on appellant William Edmund DeMaupassant. Then after the defendants finished their closing arguments, the plaintiff‘s attorney, on “rebuttal” announced to the jury and to the trial judge simultaneously that a non-suit was being taken pursuant to the above mentioned rule as to the taxi cab company and as to the taxi driver, thus leaving only appellants to take the brunt of the jury‘s decision.
Being unhappy with the rule above mentioned and discussed, but finding no reversible error, the judgment appealed is
Affirmed.
SPECTOR, Acting C.J., and McCORD, J., concur.