DeMarco v. PeaseDeMarco v. Pease
- Reporters:
- , ,
- Before:
- Sanderson
The plaintiff, as administrator, seeks to recover damages for the conscious suffering and death of his intestate, Simone Montani, who, it is alleged, while employed as a laborer by the defendant, received fatal injuries resulting from the cave-in of a ditch located on his premises. The amended declaration was in five counts. Two of the counts for conscious suffering were at common law. A verdict for the plaintiff was rendered April 30, 1924.
The defendant died November 9,1924. After a suggestion of death, the executors of his will entered their appearance and filed a motion for a new trial, in which they contended that no verdict for death could stand against the executors because damages under the death statute are vindictive and exemplary within the meaning of
The defendant operated a quarry in the town of Lee under the name of Lee Marble Works. Montará was working for him under the direction of his superintendent, digging and laying a pipe in a ditch on the defendant’s premises. It could have been found that at the time of the accident he was at the place in the ditch where the performance of his work required him to be. After the cave-in, he was discovered held in the dirt up to his hips with his shovel upright partly buried. At this point the ditch was about six feet deep, having a width of twenty to twenty-four inches at the bottom and three to four feet at the top, without shoring on either side. The certificate of death which stated the cause to be “Accidental fractured pelvis and injury to abdominal viscera caused by caving of ditch,” and the medical testimony to the effect that the injury hastened his death, was evidence for the jury of the causal connection between the accident and the ’ death.
The defendant’s requests, relating to obvious danger, could not have been given upon the facts in this case. The dangers connected with the caving in of the ditch arose after *507the contract of employment was made, and the employer could not relieve himself from the responsibility of furnishing the employee with a reasonably safe place in which to work by proving contributory negligence or an assumption of the risk.
Notice that the injury was caused by reason of a cave-in, resulting in the instant death of Simone Montani in the town of Lee, in the quarry, was sent to the defendant by the plaintiff, as administrator, accompanied by a letter from the plaintiff’s attorney. The defendant replied that he carried no insurance covering any employee. He excepted to the admission of the notice on the ground that it did not show the correct place or cause of injury and was not a legal notice. He also excepted to the refusal of the court to give his request to the effect that the notice was insufficient because it incorrectly stated the place and nature of the alleged injury, and was otherwise misleading. The defendant could not complain of the recital therein that death was instantaneous. The plaintiff was required to state the time, place and cause of injury and nothing more. Bartley v. Boston & Northern Street Railway, 198 Mass. 163, 171.
The remaining questions to be considered relate to the defendant’s contention that there is no evidence • of the existence or dependency of next of kin of the deceased. Evidence offered of communications from the parents of the deceased and the power of attorney from the father made the question of the existence of next of kin at the time of the death of Montani one of fact for the jury. The defendant contends that, by a proper construction of
The question, whether the evidence would justify the jury in finding that the next of kin were dependent for their support upon the wages of the deceased at the time of his death, was sought to be raised by two requests for rulings both of which were unsound in that they asked in substance for a ruling that the verdict must be for the defendant on all counts if the jury find the facts to be as stated in the requests relating to the dependency of parents. But the evidence as to dependency has no relation to the counts for conscious suffering. There might be recovery on these without evidence of dependent next of kin. Battany v. Wall, 232 Mass. 138.
Exceptions overruled.