De Vendell v. Doe ex dem. HamiltonDe Vendell v. Doe ex dem. Hamilton
- Reporters:
- Before:
- Chilton
The statute by which the validity of the deeds under which the defendant claims must be tested, declares that “ All deeds and conveyances of personal property, in trust to secure any debt or debts, shall -be recorded, in the office of the clerk of the county court of the county wherein the person making such deed or conveyance shall reside, within thirty days, or else the same shall be void against creditors *164and subsequent purchasers without notice; and if any such conveyance be made of real estate, the same shall be recorded, in the office of the clerk of the county court of the county wherein the estate may be situate, within sixty days, or the same shall be void against creditors or subsequent purchasers without notice.” — Olay’s Digest, pages 255-56, § 5.’
It will be observed that this statute uses the same language in respect to deeds of both personal and real property, except that thirty days are allowed for recording deeds of trust of personalty, and sixty days as to real property. If not so recorded, they are equally void as to creditors and subsequent purchasers without notice. The same rules of construction equally apply to each. In respect of personal property, it is well settled, that if a lien attaches in favor of a judgment creditor, before notice of a deed not duly recorded, the purchaser is protected, although, at the time of the purchase, he may have had notice of such deed. — Wallis v. Rhea & Ross, 10 Ala. R. 451; same parties, 12 ib. 646 : Jordan v. Meade, 12 ib. 247 ; Chamberlain v. Adams, in MS., per Dargan, C. J. The same rule, for similar reasons, must apply to ‘deeds conveying real estate. — See Avent v. Read, 2 Stew. 488 ; Mallory v. Stodder, 6 Ala. 801; Daniel v. Sorrells, 9 Ala. 436.
*166Whether the appellant would not, as against such purchaser, be required to prove the existence, and bona fides of some of the demands provided for in the trust deed, before it could avail him, is a question it is unnecessary to decide ; for the view we have taken above is conclusive of the case in this court.
Let the judgment be affirmed.