Da Silva Neto v. HolderDa Silva Neto v. Holder
- Reporters:
- , ,
- Before:
- Stahl
This appeal presents the discrete question of whether malicious destruction of property under Massachusetts law qualifies as a crime involving moral turpitude (CIMT). We conclude that it does and therefore deny the petition for review.
I. Facts & Background
Joao Palmeira Da Silva Neto (Palmeira) is a native and citizen of Brazil. He entered the United States without inspection in 1994 with his wife, Maria, who is also a Brazilian citizen. Together, the Palmeiras had two children, who are both United States citizens. Eventually, the Palmeiras separated. On January 1, 2006, Maria invited Palmeira to a New Year’s party at her house. Despite the fact that Maria had a restraining order against him, Palmeira attended the party. He got drunk at the party and, after initially leaving, quickly returned to Maria’s house, wishing to speak with her. When his wife would not open the door, Palmeira kicked it open; once inside the home, he broke some glass 1 and apparently threw some furniture. Police officers were dispatched to Maria’s house for a report of a disturbance, and Palmeira was arrested at the scene.
Palmeira admitted to sufficient facts to support a finding of malicious destruction of property under
Before the Immigration Court in Boston, Palmeira applied for cancellation of removal, which “is a form of discretionary relief, the granting of which allows a nonresident alien, otherwise removable, to remain in the United States.”
Ayeni v. Holder,
617 F.3d 67, 70 (1st Cir.2010);
see also
On remand, the IJ focused on whether Palmeira’s conviction for malicious destruction of property prevented him from qualifying as a person of good moral character, finding that question to be outcome-determinative. She concluded that malicious destruction of property under Massachusetts law is a CIMT and that Palmeira was therefore statutorily barred from establishing eligibility for cancellation of removal. Palmeira appealed to the BIA, which issued an opinion agreeing with the IJ’s conclusion but offering its own reasoning. Palmeira then filed a timely petition for review with this court, challenging the BIA’s determination that malicious destruction of property under
II. Discussion
Though we lack jurisdiction to review the agency’s discretionary or factual determinations regarding an individual’s application for cancellation of removal,
see
Where, as here, “the BIA has rendered a decision with its own analysis of the question at issue, our review focuses on the BIA’s decision, not the IJ’s.” Vásquez v. Holder, 635 F.3d 563, 565 (1st Cir.2011). We review the BIA’s legal conclusions de novo, but we afford Chevron deference to the BIA’s interpretation of the Immigration and Nationality Act (INA), including its determination that a particular crime qualifies as one of moral turpitude, unless that interpretation is “arbitrary, capricious, or clearly contrary to law.” 3 Idy v. Holder, 674 F.3d 111, 117 (1st Cir.2012); see also Maghsoudi v. INS, 181 F.3d 8, 14 (1st Cir.1999).
We begin with an overview of the meaning and import of the phrase “crime involving moral turpitude.” In order to establish eligibility for cancellation of removal, an applicant must, among other things, have “been a person of good moral character” during the ten years immediately preceding his application.
4
The term “moral turpitude” first appeared in a federal immigration statute in 1891.
Cabral v. INS,
15 F.3d 193, 194 (1st Cir.1994). Congress has never defined the phrase, but we have found that “[t]he legislative history leaves no doubt
The relatively amorphous nature of the moral turpitude definition has led to “a patchwork of different approaches” to the CIMT analysis among the circuit courts. Silva-Trevino, 24 I. & N. Dec. at 688. In Silvar-Trevino, the Attorney General (AG) responded to that patchwork by attempting “to establish a uniform framework for ensuring that the [INA’s] moral turpitude provisions are fairly and accurately applied.” Id. Under the first step of the AG’s three-part framework, the adjudicator must determine whether the crime at issue categorically involves moral turpitude by examining “whether there is a ‘realistic probability, not a theoretical possibility,’ ” that the criminal statute “would be applied to reach conduct that does not involve moral turpitude.” Id. at 690 (quoting Gonzales v. Duenas-Alvarez, 549 U.S. 183, 193, 127 S.Ct. 815, 166 L.Ed.2d 683 (2007)). If that “categorical” approach does not resolve the issue, the adjudicator must then apply a “modified categorical” approach, by examining the record of conviction to determine whether it “evidences a crime that in fact involved moral turpitude.” Id. If the modified categorical approach is not conclusive, under Silva-Trevino, an adjudicator should proceed to a third step, which involves examining “evidence beyond the formal record of conviction.” 6 Id.
Our approach to the CIMT analysis has been generally consistent with the first two steps of the
Silva-Trevino
framework, though we have not specifically applied the “realistic probability” test.
7
We have begun by looking “to the inherent nature of the crime of conviction, as defined in the criminal statute,” to determine whether it fits the CIMT definition.
Idy,
674 F.3d at 118 (citation and internal quotation marks omitted). If it does, we have said that “our inquiry may end there.”
Id.
If, however, “the face of the statute is insufficient for us to make a moral-turpitude determination (e.g., if the statute con
The criminal statute at issue here reads as follows:
Whoever destroys or injures the personal property, dwelling house or building of another in any manner or by any means not particularly described or mentioned in this chapter shall, if such destruction or injury is wilful and malicious, be punished by imprisonment in the state prison for not more than ten years or by a fine of three thousand dollars or three times the value of the property so destroyed or injured, whichever is greater and imprisonment in jail for not more than two and one-half years; or if such destruction or injury is wanton, shall be punished by a fine of fifteen hundred dollars or three times the value of the property so destroyed or injured, whichever is greater, or by imprisonment for not more than two and one-half years; if the value of the property so destroyed or injured is not alleged to exceed two hundred and fifty dollars, the punishment shall be by a fine of three times the value of the damage or injury to such property or by imprisonment for not more than two and one-half months; provided, however, that where a fine is levied pursuant to the value of the property destroyed or injured, the court shall, after conviction, conduct an evidentiary hearing to ascertain the value of the property so destroyed or injured. The words “personal property”, as used in this section, shall also include electronically processed or stored data, either tangible or intangible, and data while in transit.
As we review the BIA’s conclusion that malicious destruction of property under Massachusetts law is a CIMT, we have no case law directly on point to guide us.
8
Against that backdrop, we turn to the BIA’s decision in this case. The BIA began by applying the categorical approach and determined that
The BIA’s analysis could certainly have been more thorough, but the agency did not reach an unreasonable conclusion.
Idy,
674 F.3d at 117. Palmeira’s primary
Of course, in order to qualify as a CIMT, malicious destruction of property must also involve an act that is “per se morally reprehensible and intrinsically wrong.” Id. This statute, unlike others we have examined in the CIMT context, does not require any risk of physical harm to another person, which can render conduct inherently reprehensible. See Idy, 674 F.3d at 119 (reckless conduct under New Hampshire law “is necessarily reprehensible because its definition includes an aggravating factor — ‘serious bodily injury’ ”); Nguyen v. Reno, 211 F.3d 692, 695 (1st Cir.2000) (assault in the second degree under Connecticut law is a CIMT because it requires “serious physical injury”); cf. Maghsoudi, 181 F.3d at 14-15 (indecent assault under Massachusetts law is a CIMT); Cabral, 15 F.3d at 195-97 (being an accessory after the fact to voluntary murder under Massachusetts law is a CIMT). Nor does the crime involve fraudulent conduct. See Jordan v. De George, 341 U.S. 223, 232, 71 S.Ct. 703, 95 L.Ed. 886 (1951) (“The phrase ‘crime involving moral turpitude’ has without exception been construed to embrace fraudulent conduct.”). But Palmeira has given us no reason to doubt the BIA’s conclusion that an intentional, destructive act committed with malice (that is to say, out of cruelty, hostility, or revenge) toward an individual is necessarily “reprehensible” and thus satisfies the CIMT definition. Maghsoudi, 181 F.3d at 14.
Indeed, the cases Palmeira has cited as involving acts that do not, in his opinion, rise to the level of a CIMT only underscore the reasonableness of the BIA’s decision. In
McGovern,
the defendant broke into a parking lot booth, was observed “tearing it apart,” and caused extensive damage, including breaking a window, knocking in a door, pulling electrical wiring off the ceiling of the booth, and throwing various items onto the street. 494 N.E.2d at 1299. In
Commonwealth v. Cimino,
34 Mass.App.Ct. 925, 611 N.E.2d 738 (1993), the defendant went on a “shooting round,” during which he and a group of his friends took turns shooting a BB gun at (and thereby breaking) the windows of seventeen parked cars,
id.
at 740. Because the defendant and his accomplices had deliberately “aimed the BB pistol and
One can certainly argue that destroying property, even with an evil mindset, is not necessarily “base, vile, or depraved” behavior, or the sort of crime that should render an individual deportable. But that determination is not ours to make on a de novo basis; we must defer to the BIA’s conclusion that a crime involves moral turpitude if that conclusion “is neither arbitrary nor contrary to law.” Idy, 674 F.3d at 119. Malicious destruction of property in Massachusetts requires “gratuitous, excessive violence purposefully designed to intimidate and overpower, or destructive acts that were by design and hostile to the owner of the property, whoever that may have been.” Commonwealth v. Redmond, 53 Mass.App.Ct. 1, 757 N.E.2d 249, 253 (2001) (internal citation and quotation marks omitted). That is a high bar; the BIA’s conclusion that such conduct necessarily implicates moral turpitude was “neither arbitrary nor contrary to law.” Idy, 674 F.3d at 119.
III. Conclusion
We find no particular satisfaction in our conclusion today. It is unfortunate that Palmeira admitted to sufficient facts to support a finding of malicious destruction of property under the misapprehension that doing so would allow him to avoid the very immigration consequences that he now faces. There is also, as the BIA recognized, a real potential for hardship in this case, given that Palmeira has two United States citizen children who may soon be separated from their father. But because the BIA’s conclusion was a reasonable interpretation of the INA, we deny Palmeira’s petition for review. Id.
Notes
. The police report states that the foyer and kitchen floor of Maria’s house were covered in glass when the arresting officers arrived. During his removal hearing, Palmeira testified that he “slapped” some glasses or bottles on a table, causing them to fall and break, though the police report suggests that there was glass in the door that shattered when Palmeira kicked it in.
. On April 21, 2010, Palmeira filed a motion with the state court to vacate his conviction. Palmeira has not mentioned that motion in his brief on appeal; we therefore can only assume that it has not been granted.
. To be clear, we defer to the BIA‘s construction of the “ambiguous term ‘moral turpitude,’ ” Hernandez-Cruz v. Holder, 651 F.3d 1094, 1106 (9th Cir.2011), not to its interpretation of the underlying criminal statute, since “[t]he BIA has no special expertise in construing state and federal criminal statutes,” id. at 1105-06.
. A cancellation of removal applicant must also establish that: (1) he has been physically present in the United States for a continuous period of not less than ten years; (2) he has not been convicted of certain enumerated crimes; and (3) his removal would result in exceptional and extremely unusual hardship to a qualifying family member.
See
.Palmeira concedes that his admission to sufficient facts to sustain a guilty finding, coupled with his probation sentence, constitutes a “conviction” within the meaning of
. We need not decide today whether we will follow the third step of the AG’s framework, which has proven controversial. The Third, Fourth, Eighth, and Eleventh Circuits have rejected Silva-Trevino for its suggestion that adjudicators can look beyond the record of conviction and examine the specific facts of the offense at issue. See Prudencio v. Holder, 669 F.3d 472, 480-84 (4th Cir.2012); Fajardo v. U.S. Att’y Gen., 659 F.3d 1303, 1307-10 (11th Cir.2011); Guardado-Garda v. Holder, 615 F.3d 900, 902 (8th Cir.2010); Jean-Louis v. Att’y Gen. of U.S., 582 F.3d 462, 470-80 (3d Cir.2009). Only the Seventh Circuit has thus far adopted Silva-Trevino‘s third prong. See Mata-Guerrero v. Holder, 627 F.3d 256, 260-61 (7th Cir.2010).
. Because the parties have not briefed the issue, and it therefore is not properly before us, we will leave for another day the question of whether to adopt the “realistic probability” test, as the Seventh, Ninth, and Tenth Circuits have done. See Rodriguez-Heredia v. Holder, 639 F.3d 1264, 1267 (10th Cir.2011); Mata-Guerrero, 627 F.3d at 260; Nunez v. Holder, 594 F.3d 1124, 1129 (9th Cir.2010).
. Palmeira has cited three cases involving property crimes that the BIA has concluded are not CIMTs. Each of those cases is distinguishable because the underlying statute encompassed conduct less severe than the willful and malicious conduct required by
Also distinguishable, though the parties have failed to cite it, is the Ninth Circuit‘s decision in
Rodriguez-Herrera v. INS,
52 F.3d 238 (9th Cir.1995), holding that second-degree malicious mischief under Washington
law is not a CIMT. In that case, the state statute provided that a person was guilty of malicious mischief if he “knowingly and maliciously ... cause[d] physical damage to the property of another in an amount exceeding two hundred fifty dollars.”
Id.
at 239 (citation and internal quotation marks omitted). “Maliciously” was defined under Washington law as “importing] an evil intent, wish, or design to vex, annoy, or injure another person.”
Id.
(citation and internal quotation marks omitted). Importantly, however, malice could also “be inferred if the act [was] merely wrongfully done without just cause or excuse,”
id.
at 240 (citation and internal quotation marks omitted), which led the Ninth Circuit to conclude that the statute might apply to “pranksters with poor judgment,”
id.
That is not the case here. The Massachusetts courts have explicitly held, with regard to violations of