Crull v. KeenerCrull v. Keener
- Reporters:
- Before:
- Catón
This court has only appellate jurisdiction, except in certain specified cases, of which this is not one. Sec. 5, Art. 5, Const. In this case no decision was ever made in the Circuit Court; but the counsel have stipulated or certified that certain
Nor do we think the legislature misunderstood it, when they passed the sixteenth and seventeenth sections of the twenty-ninth chapter R. S., or that they ever contemplated that, under that statute, this court would ever assume to exercise any thing but appellate jurisdiction. The sixteenth section is this: “ The parties in any suit or proceeding at law or in chancery, in any Circuit Court, may make an agreed case containing the points of law at issue between them, and file the same in the said court; and the said agreed case may be certified to the Supreme Court by the clerk of such Circuit Court, without certifying any further record in the case; and upon such agreed case being so certified and filed in the Supreme Court, the appellant or plaintiff in error may assign errors, and the case shall then be proceeded in in the same manner as it might have been, had a full record been certified to the said Supreme Court.” Nothing c‘an be more manifest than
The seventeenth section, upon which more especial reliance was placed at the bar, by the counsel of both parties, in support of this jurisdiction, is this: “Any judge of a Circuit Court may, if the parties litigant assent thereto, certify any question or questions of law arising in any case tried before him, to the Supreme Court, together with his decision thereon; or, the parties in the suit may agree as to the questions or points of law arising in the case, and the same may be certified by the counsel or attorneys of the respective parties, who shall sign their names thereto; and upon such certificate being made, the same shall be filed in the Supreme Court; and a copy of said certificate, certified by the clerk of said Circuit Court to the Supreme Court, and filed therein, and, upon filing the same, the like proceedings may be had in the Supreme Court as if a full and complete record had been transcribed and certified to said court.” Now let me ask, in the first place, what proceedings would be had in this court, should a party bring a case here in the usual mode, by a complete transcript of the record, from which it appeared that no decision had been made in the Circuit Court ? All who are acquainted with the practice of this court, know that it would at once be dismissed for want of jurisdiction; .and such the statute declares shall be the proceeding, when such a case is brought up by a certificate under this section. Under the first clause of the section, when the certificate is made by the judge, it is expressly provided that his decision thereon shall be certified, together with the questions of law presented in the case. Then, in that case at least, a decision must first be made before the case can come here for review. Now, it is plain, from the language of the law, that the subsequent provision of the same section was merely intended to provide another mode for bringing up the same case. It was not intended to authorize the bringing up a case in one mode, which could not be brought up in the other
This question, submitted to the court for its opinion, must be dismissed for want of jurisdiction to determine it.
Case dismissed.