Crook v. PeopleCrook v. People
- Reporters:
- Before:
- Scates
Informations against persons for contempts, in disturbing the order of court in its presence or out of it, for breach of injunctions, and disobeying its orders and decrees, and such like, are not within the meaning, nor of the character of informations, in the 5th section of the act in relation to change of venue, Rev. Statutes, 528. Informations, within the meaning of said act, are such as are punishable under the provisions of the criminal code, upon presentment of the grand jury, informations filed ex-officio by the State’s attorneys, and on appeals from justices of the peace, etc. The order of the Peoria circuit court, changing the venue in this case, was simply void, and did not have the effect to divest the court of its jurisdiction, and no order of the Tazewell circuit court was necessary to re-instate it. Consequently, there was no case for the application of the rule, as laid down in The People v. Scates, 3 Scam. R. 355, and the Tazewell circuit court could not acquire jurisdiction under a nugatory order of another court.
In the examination of the merits of the remaining questions raised in the assignment of errors and arguments, we would be understood -as distinctly waiving any determination, whether a defendant in a criminal information for a contempt, can appeal or maintain a writ of error. See in the case of Yates, 4 John. Rep. 353, a very full examination and discussion of the doctrine of contempts, and the mode and power of revision.
The first objection we notice is, that no attachment for a contempt, by breach of an injunction, can issue, after the dissolution of the injunction. The case cited, Moat v. Holbein, 2 Edw. Ch. R. 188, does not lay down the rule in reference to issuing an alias attachment after dissolution. The party there had never been charged and proceeded against for the alleged contempt, during the continuance of the injunction. Here they had been under recognizance to answer.
When the charge is made, it becomes a distinct proceeding on behalf of the people, and will not depend upon the continuance of the injunction. Although an application for an attachment originally,
The party then may controvert the answers in a case like this. If the affidavits taken on the hearing, are before us in the record, which I altogether doubt, yet no objection was taken to looking into them, we find abundant reason for dismissing the injunction, and it may be the bill itself, in the breach shown. The mischiefs intended to be prevented by the injunction, had been irreparably committed by the breach, and its continuance would appear to be without object. The house was undermined and the walls thrown down. When the attachment had been granted for the breach, and a prosecution instituted to punish its authors, the bill might well be dismissed, and the complainant proceed at law to recover his damages, while he proceeded with the attachment for redress by fine for contempt. We do not think this proceeding was discontinued by dismissing the bill.
Judgment below approved.
Judgment affirmed.