Creavin v. MoloneyCreavin v. Moloney
- Reporters:
- , ,
- Before:
- Utter
OPINION
UTTER, Justice.Fidelma M. Creavin, appellant, filed an original suit affecting the parent-child relationship against Thomas M. Moloney, ap-pellee, seeking child support, a “confirmation” of appellant as the managing conservator, and attorney’s fees. The entire suit, however, was subsequently dismissed by the trial court for lack of jurisdiction.
The parties were married in the Republic of Ireland, a country in which they were both citizens and residents. Their only child was bom in 1977 while they were still residing in Ireland. Appellee subsequently immigrated to the United States and joined a family practice residency program in Pennsylvania, where he was later joined by appellant and their child. Approximately *700 three years later, appellant and their child returned to Ireland. Appellee thereafter sought and obtained a decree of divorce in Pennsylvania which terminated the marriage, but which did not refer to or make any determinations regarding either support or custody of the child of the marriage. Appellee has resided in Corpus Christi, Nueces County, Texas since January of 1984, and is currently a resident alien with application for citizenship pending. The child has lived with appellant in Ireland since the parties were divorced.
During the course of the hearings, the following stipulations in the form of judicial admissions were entered by appellant’s counsel: (1) that both appellant and the child are residents and citizens of Ireland; (2) that neither appellant nor the child are physically present in the United States, but rather are in Ireland; (3) that the child is not and never has been a Texas resident; and (4) that the parties were divorced in Pennsylvania in 1982 by the decree of divorce attached to her original petition.
Appellee filed a “Special Appearance to Challenge Jurisdiction” under the authority of
On March 25, 1987, the trial court sent the parties a letter which stated, in relevant part: Counsel:
This is an original suit to have the custodial parent confirmed as managing conservator, and to establish support for the child.
[[Image here]]
Respondent has challenged the juris-deiction [sicj of the Court to hear this matter.
Considering the pleadings, evidence presented at hearing 13 March 1987, and briefs filed, it appears:
Petitioner may bring suit. Family Code Section 11.03(a)(1) and (8).
However, venue does not appear to lie, and another court may have jurisdiction of the “claim.” Family Code 11.04, and various subparts.
Further, there does not appear to be any compelling constitutional basis for the Court to exercise its jurisdiction. Family Code 11.051.
Custody is an issue in this cause. The Court has been asked to “confirm” a de facto managing conservatorship. It seems that before the Court can require a parent to pay child support, custody must first be determined. Hence, Family Code 11.51 et seq., are applicable.
Petitioner herein has not pled her cause in accordance with Family Code 11.59.
Finally, if the Court has jurisdiction it may be under Family Code 11.53(a)(4). Pleadings and proof are necessary.
Petitioner may have a reasonable time to replead her cause, per Family Code 11.02, or alternatively, the cause will be dismissed for lack of jurisdiction.
Appellant filed her First Amended Petition on April 1, 1987, wherein she alleged that the “court has jurisdiction to make a child custody determination by initial decree because it is in the best interest of the child that this court assume jurisdiction and [that] no other state would have jurisdiction under prerequisites substantially in accordance with
Appellee thereafter filed his First Amended Motion to Dismiss for Lack of Jurisdiction. This motion challenged jurisdiction on both grounds that there were no pleadings to show that “Texas had jurisdiction over Pennsylvania” under the Uniform Child Custody Jurisdiction Act, and that appellant had failed to file pleadings in accordance with the trial court’s March 25, 1987 instructions. Specifically, appellee complained that appellant had still not filed verified pleadings in accordance with
On May 4,1987, the court held a hearing on appellee’s motion to dismiss for want of jurisdiction. Appellant was not personally present, but was represented by counsel. At the beginning of that hearing, appellant’s counsel informed the court that he had sent appellant an affidavit for her to sign but that he had not yet received it back in the mail. Appellee subsequently argued that
THE COURT: ... I am of the opinion that custody remains the primary matter that the Court has got to consider before it can get to the matter of support. This, notwithstanding that the Family Code does require that both parties support the child. Again, I think before I can order one parent to pay the other one support, there has got to be custody or conservatorship determination.
I am of the opinion, as I was earlier, I believe specifically on the 25th day of March, 1987 when I wrote counsel a letter outlining my feelings about this case that the Court does not have — it does not have jurisdiction in this case. The petitioner’s supporting affidavit, filed along with the First Amended Suit pertaining to the parent/child relationship, is not enough. It does not comply with, in my opinion, Sec. 11.59(a) of the Family Code. Therefore, I am going to dismiss this case for want of jurisdiction.
By six points of error, appellant contends the trial court erred in dismissing her suit affecting the parent-child relationship. Point one generally complains that the trial court erred in dismissing her suit for lack of jurisdiction. Points two through four assert that the trial court erred in compelling her to replead her suit for child support to include a claim for custody, in dismissing her entire suit for lack of jurisdiction, and in concluding that a parent has no duty to support a minor child prior to the appointment of a conservator. Specifically, appellant argues that the designation of conservatorship is not a condition precedent to a cause of action for child support, but rather, that they are mutually exclusive causes of action. Points five and six contend that the trial court erred in applying the Uniform Child Custody Jurisdiction Act (U.C.C.J.A.) to the facts of the case at bar, and in determining that a cause of action for custody was barred in Texas under that Act.
Before reaching the merits of appellant’s arguments, we note that although appellant has complained generally on appeal concerning the trial court’s failure to file findings of fact and conclusions of law, there is no point of error on this issue in her brief. Appellant, therefore, has waived *702 her right to complain. See Department of Human Resources v. Wininger, 657 S.W.2d 783, 783 (Tex.1983); Cameron v. MacDonell, 659 S.W.2d 911, 912 (Tex.App.—Corpus Christi 1983, no writ). Where findings of fact and conclusions of law are not filed, the judgment of the trial court must be affirmed if it can be upheld on any theory that finds support in the evidence. Point Lookout West, Inc. v. Wharton, 742 S.W.2d 277, 278 (Tex.1987); In the Interest of W.E.R., 669 S.W.2d 716, 717 (Tex.1984).
We must first address the issue regarding whether the Pennsylvania court which entered the decree of divorce has continuing, exclusive jurisdiction over all matters affecting the parent-child relationship, including child support and custody.
No proof of Pennsylvania law was introduced or even discussed at the hearings. Moreover, the trial court was never requested to take judicial notice of Pennsylvania law and the record is devoid of any indication that the trial court took judicial notice of those laws on its own motion. Therefore, the Pennsylvania law will be presumed to be the same as Texas law.
Ogletree v. Crates,
363 S.W.2d 431, 435 (Tex.1963);
Ewing v. Ewing,
739 S.W.2d 470, 472 (Tex.App.—Corpus Christi 1987, no writ); Tex.R.Civ.Evid. 202;
Under Texas law, a suit for divorce must include a suit affecting the parent-child relationship if there is a child of the marriage.
In the instant case, the Pennsylvania court entered a decree of divorce, but failed to enter any judgment regarding the parent-child relationship. No final order has been entered regarding the parent-child relationship in the Pennsylvania court, and “a court does not acquire continuing, exclusive jurisdiction over the matters provided for under this subtitle in connection with the child before the entry of a final decree.”
We conclude, therefore, that the Pennsylvania court which entered the decree of divorce no longer has jurisdiction to modify that decree on any matter affecting the parent-child relationship.
Carroll v. Jones,
654 S.W.2d 54, 56 (Tex.App.—Fort Worth 1983, no writ). Further, we conclude that insofar as the Texas court has jurisdiction over the causes of action, a subsequent suit could be commenced as an original proceeding in the Texas courts.
2
We now must turn to the more difficult questions concerning whether the Texas court has jurisdiction to entertain this suit affecting the parent-child relationship. In this case, the trial court has dismissed both appellant’s causes of action for child support and custody for lack of jurisdiction. A trial court’s refusal to exercise its jurisdiction over a suit affecting the parent-child relationship will not be disturbed on appeal absent a clear abuse of discretion. See Haley v. Haley, 713 S.W.2d 801, 804 (Tex.App.—Houston [1st Dist.] 1986, no writ).
JURISDICTION OVER CHILD SUPPORT
Texas law does not require that the court make a child custody determination prior to the entry of an order for child support.
We further hold that there is no requirement that a party comply with the Uniform Child Custody Jurisdiction Act, Tex.Fam.Code Ann. subch. B (Vernon 1986) (U.C.C.J.A.), prior to bringing a suit for child support.
Overcash v. Overcash,
466 So.2d 1261, 1262 (Fla.Dist.Ct.App.1985);
Olivia H. v. John H,,
130 Misc.2d 756, 497 N.Y.S.2d 838, 839-40 (N.Y.Fam.Ct.1986);
Rodgers v. Rodgers,
627 P.2d 1381,1383-84 (Wyo.1981). The jurisdictional prerequisites of the U.C.C.J.A. only govern in “custody” actions and do not limit the court’s jurisdiction to hear matters involving child support.
[a] court decision and court orders and instructions providing for the custody of a child, including visitation rights, but does not include a decision relating to child support or any other monetary obligation of any person.
The rationale behind this legislation is that due process requires that claims for child support be brought in a state where the
defendant
has at least some form of minimal contacts.
Perry,
604 S.W.2d at 313. This is because a support claim is analogous to a claim for debt and it is generally believed that the courts of the State in which the defendant resides are in a better position to determine the defendant’s ability to pay.
Id.
Child custody, on the other hand, focuses primarily on the “status” of the child, and it is generally believed that the state with the closest connection to the
child
has the greatest access to information concerning the child’s care, protection, training, and relationship.
See
We also hold that the status or subject matter jurisdiction permitted by
The record reveals that appel-lee’s special appearance to challenge jurisdiction under
JURISDICTION OVER CHILD CUSTODY
We believe our analysis of
On the other hand, one of the primary purposes behind the U.C.C.J.A. is to avoid jurisdictional competition and conflict with courts of other states in matters of child custody.
In the present case, appellant’s attorney filed an affidavit pursuant to
In the present case, there was no showing by any party that any other state, including Ireland, was a more appropriate forum.
3
Further, although appellant did not timely file her affidavit, her attorney’s affidavit and subsequent testimony indicated that he had personal knowledge that no other causes regarding this parent-child relationship had been filed. Finally, while the trial court had the authority to dismiss the suit for failure to timely file a proper affidavit complying with
In summary, appellant’s causes of action for child support and custody should not have been dismissed for lack of jurisdiction. We sustain appellant’s points of error.
The judgment of the trial court is REVERSED and the cause is REMANDED to the trial court.
Notes
. The trial court signed the Order of Dismissal on May 13, 1987. An affidavit signed by appellant personally on May 1, 1987 was subsequently filed on May 26,1987 with her second amended petition. This affidavit substantially complies with
. Although Tex.Rev.Civ.Stat.Ann. art. 4639c used to expressly provide for a situation in which a foreign jurisdiction had entered a divorce decree which was silent as to support and custody of a child, that article was repealed in 1985 and is no longer directly provided for under Texas law.
. Absolute divorce cannot be obtained in Ireland and the courts in Ireland do not have any power over the children of a marriage, including the ordering of a settlement for their benefit. See VIII Martindale Hubbell Law Directory, Ireland Law Digest 4-5 (1988 ed.).