CRAIN AUTOMOTIVE GROUP, INC., D/B/a Automotive News, Appellant,
v.
J & M GRAPHICS, INC., Appellee.
District Court of Appeal of Florida, Third District.
*301 Smith & Mandler and Steven L. Schwartzberg, Miami Beach, for appellant.
Horton, Perse & Ginsberg and Mallory Horton, Miami, for appellee.
Before HUBBART, BASKIN and DANIEL S. PEARSON, JJ.
BASKIN, Judge.
We reverse the final judgment awarding damages for lost profits to J & M Graphics, an advertising agency. The award was based upon Crain's publishing an ad placed by J & M's recently retained client, Joseph Bottierri, one week later than the anticipated date. Bottierri relied on the publication date and mailed brochures to dealers informing them that the ads for his product would appear on the scheduled date. Crain was not informed of the mailing. As a result of the ad's omission, Bottierri terminated his contract with J & M. When Crain sued J & M for the unpaid sums owed for the ads, J & M counterclaimed to recover lost profits. At the conclusion of a non-jury trial, the court awarded J & M damages of $32,500 on the counterclaim and ruled in favor of Crain on the question of unpaid bills.
In order to recover damages, J & M must prove: (1) that Crain was negligent in delaying the ad; (2) that it actually sustained a loss as a proximate result of that negligence; (3) that the loss was or should have been within the reasonable contemplation of the parties; (4) that the loss alleged is not remote, contingent, or conjectural, and that damages are reasonably certain. Florida East Coast Ry. v. Peters,
Because Crain was not aware of Bottierri's mailing, it cannot be said that lost profits to J & M could reasonably have been contemplated to be the proximate result of moving the ad. See Poinsettia Dairy Products, Inc. v. Wessel Co.,
Furthermore, the alleged losses are not capable of reasonably certain ascertainment. The rule is that lost profits must be shown with a reasonable degree of certainty. Beverage Canners, Inc. v. Cott Corp.,
Affirmed as to paragraphs one and two of the final judgment; reversed as to the remainder.
