Coulter v. SypertCoulter v. Sypert
- Reporters:
- , ,
- Before:
- Battle
This is a contest between a father and grandfather for the custody of a boy, about ten years old, named Richmond Sypert.
Henry Sypert married Caroline Coulter, the daughter of
In the ten .years that have expired since his wife’s death Henry Sypert accomplished the following: He married again; in the first year of the second marriage he separated from his wife and remained apart for about one year and a half; had three children by the last marriage; indulged sometimes, though not frequently, in shooting craps, for which he was indicted three times; and accumulated one cow and seven hogs and household furniture, worth, he says, about fifty dollars. His second wife owned an interest in about forty acres of land, of which eighteen acres were cleared. Henry purchased an interest in it, but never paid a cent of the purchase money. At the commencement of this proceeding he was earning twenty dollars a month; and he and his wife own one horse, two cows and a calf and about seven hogs and household furniture. Joe Coulter owns one hundred and seventeen acres of land, upon which is a farm of 80 acres in cultivation; he has two mules, one pony mare, ten hogs, six cattle,- and farming implements; and he is a carpenter, and has no young children. He paid $800 for his land, and does not owe a cent for it.
The father has no proprietary right or interest in or to the custody of his infant child. As said by Senator Paige in Mercein v. People, 25 Wend. 64, 103, decided in the Court of Errors of New York in 1840: “There is no parental authority independent of the supreme power of the State, but the former is derived altogether from the latter. * * * The moment a child is born, it owes allegiance to the government of the country of its birth, and is entitled to the protection of that government. And such government is obligated, by its duty of protection, to consult the welfare, comfort and interests of such child in regulating its custody during the period of its minority.” In the case of U. S. v. Green, 3 Mason, 482, which arose upon an application by habeas corpus of a father for his infant daughter, aged about ten years, alleged to be detained in the custody of her maternal grandfather, Judge Story said: “As to the question of the right of the father to have the custody of his infant child, in a general sense it is true. But this is not on account of any absolute right of -the father, but for the benefit of the infant, the law presuming it to, be for its interest to be under the nurture and care of its natural protector, both for maintenance and education. When, therefore, the court is asked to lend its aid to put the infant into the custody of the father, and to withdraw him from other persons, it will look into all the circumstances, and ascertain whether it will be for the real, permanent interests of the infant; and, if the infant be of sufficient discretion, it will also consult its personal wishes. It will free it from all undue restraint, and endeavor, as far as possible, to administer a conscientious, parental duty with reference to its welfare. It is an entire mistake to suppose that the court is, at all events, bound to deliver over the infant to his father, or that the latter has an absolute, vested right in the custody.”
In the Matter of Waldron, 13 Johns, 418, is something like this case. In that case a habeas corpus was issued to Andrew McGowan to’ bring up the body of Margaret Eliza Waldron, an infant, alleged to be detained in his custody. John P. Waldron had married the daughter of Andrew McGowan, and, becoming embarrassed and insolvent, McGowan took his daughter to his house. She lived with him until her death; and during her residence with
In McShan v. McShan, 56 Miss. 413, the court held: “While, as a matter of abstract law, the father, as head of the family bound to provide therefor, is entitled to the custody of his children, yet such -right is modified by the circumstances of each case; and where the mother, whom her husband has deserted without means among strangers, has found with her father a pleasant and permanent home, where her two infant girls are excellently cared for, her husband can not, repenting of having broken up the family, by habeas corpus take the little girls, although the mother refuses his proposals to again cohabit, and declares that the separation shall be perpetual. While the children, if of age of discretion, could be consulted, yet when very young the court must be guided by their best interests, in view of all the circumstances.”
Mr, Hochheimer, in his work on the “Custody of Infants,” says: “The following statement very nearly expresses the general‘result of authorities: ‘The courts are, in no case, bound to deliver a child into custody of the claimant or any other person, but will investigate all the circumstances, and act according to sound discretion in the exercise of a conscientious^ parental duty, as the welfare of the child at the time appears to require, without regard to any technical right of custody, when such custody is not proper and beneficial, and without regard to mere technicalities of procedure.’ ” Page 96, and cases cited.
“In this case the motherless infant, two days old, was taken by the maternal grandmother, with the father’s assent, and tenderly guarded through all the perils of infancy. There has been all of a mother’s care, and scarcely less than a mother’s affection. The child is yet scarcely three years of age, delicate in health: she is in a safe asylum, surrounded by those who may be trusted to guard her anxiously against pernicious influences, and to do their best to instill into her mind such principles as will promote her future usefulness and happiness. They, too, plead the full strength of natural affections. * * * * The father has shown himself to be a moral man, with the means of discharging his parental obligations. Certainly, under the circumstances, if he had been in possession of the child, no chancellor could have found warrant in equity for taking her away to be placed under the grandmother’s care. But it can not be ignored that the case does not present that attitude. The child was placed where she is by the father’s assent. By his assent ties have been woven between the grandmother and
The case before us is one of the exceptional cases. On the part of Henry Sypert, the ties of duty and affection for the son, to which preference is as a rule conceded to the father, are lacking. He has not shown as much concern and attachment for his son Richmond as some brutes manifest for their young. For ten years he has manifested an utter indifference for his son and contributed nothing to his • maintenance and support. He has shown no evidence of a disposition or ability to discharge the duties of a father to the son. No ties of affection of the father for the son exist to be torn asunder. But ties have been woven between grandparents and grandson. They have taken care of, maintained and supported him nearly all of his life, and they give evidence that they will continue, if permitted, to care for, maintain and support him as their own child. No doubt can be entertained that it will be more for the benefit of the son to remain with his grandparents than to be put under the care and custody of bis father.
The decree of the chancery court is reversed; and it is ordered that Richmond Sypert remain in the custody of Joe Coulter until the further order of a court of competent jurisdiction, with leave to the father, on all suitable occasions, to see him.