Corson v. CorsonCorson v. Corson
- Reporters:
- , ,
- Before:
- Finley
Appellant was granted a divorce from respondent on October 24, 1951. Custody of their one child, then three years of age, was awarded to appellant wife, and
On March 8,1954, respondent filed a petition for modification of the support money provision of the divorce decree. On March 10, 1954, appellant procured an order directing respondent to show cause why he should not be adjudged in contempt of court for failure to make the support money payments provided for in the decree. These matters came on regularly for hearing, and, as a result thereof, an order was entered by the trial court, (1) requiring the respondent to pay ten dollars per month on account of the sum of twenty-nine hundred dollars (the amount of the unpaid support money installments), to avoid being adjudged in contempt of court; and (2) relieving respondent of the duty to make further support money payments until the further order of the court, or until such time as the appellant should return the minor child of the parties to the state of Washington. From this order, appellant wife has appealed.
Appellant contends that, in so far as the trial court’s order provides for payment by respondent of ten dollars per month on the past-due installments of support money, it is a modification of the obligation due on these past-due installments, because it deprives appellant of her remedies for collection of them. Appellant states, and correctly so, that past-due installments for support money under a divorce decree constitute a fixed obligation, and cannot be modified by any subsequent order of the trial court.
Sanges v. Sanges,
44 Wn. (2d) 35, 265 P. (2d) 278, and cases cited. However, we do not agree with appellant’s contention
We believe this argument of appellant is without merit. The proceeding instituted by appellant was a civil contempt proceeding, addressed to the discretion of the superior court, which, after a hearing, may enter such an order as the court, in the exercise of its discretion, deems appropriate. Lear v. Lear, 29 Wn. (2d) 692, 189 P. (2d) 237, and cases cited. We find no abuse of discretion on the part of the trial court in entering that part of the order referred to, which enables respondent to avoid being adjudged in contempt of court.
Appellant next contends that it was error for the trial court to modify the support money provision of the decree by relieving respondent of any duty to make further support money payments, when, by the terms of the divorce decree, he had previously been required to pay one hundred dollars per month toward the support of the minor child of the parties. In Feek v. Feek, 187 Wash. 573, 60 P. (2d) 686, we said:
“The fact that appellant subsequently remarried and has another child, or possibly two children, does not, of itself, relieve him of the obligation fixed by the original decree. In such cases, the court will make such adjustment as the necessities of the parties demand and the ability of the husband permits, [citing cases].”
The party petitioning for modification of the support money provision of a divorce decree has the burden of presenting evidence which shows such a change of conditions or circumstances since the entry of the divorce decree, or the last preceding order fixing support money payments, as
In determining whether or not a petition for modification of support money payments should be granted, the trial court has a large discretion, and its orders will not be reversed or modified unless some abuse of the court’s discretion or other manifest error occurs. Farrar v. Farrar, 34 Wn. (2d) 152, 208 P. (2d) 643. The evidence on the issue of modification of the support money provision, from an adversary’s point of view, may seem to be sufficient to have enabled the court to exercise its discretion and enter an appropriate order of modification. However, divorce actions and proceedings ancillary thereto are not adversary in the customary sense, for the state is an interested party. In effect, such proceedings involve three parties: the plaintiff, the defendant, and the state. Where minor children are involved, the state’s interest is that, in so far as is possible, provision shall be made for their support, education, and training, to the end that they may grow up to be worthy and useful citizens. Heney v. Heney, 24 Wn. (2d) 445, 165 P. (2d) 864. A proper exercise of the discretion of the trial court in this matter would seem to require further information as to the circumstances of appellant wife, particularly more specific information as to her present husband’s income, in the sense that these matters relate to the welfare of the minor child involved.
Appellant contends that the trial court erred in entering that part of the order providing that respondent is
Finally, appellant contends that it was error for the trial court to admit evidence of appellant’s predivorce conduct. With this we agree. In a proceeding to modify the support money provision of a divorce decree, evidence of the predivorce conduct of the parties is immaterial and inadmissible. Dinesen v. Dinesen, 29 Wn. (2d) 178, 186 P. (2d) 611. In such a case, the only relevant inquiry is whether or not there has been such ao change of circumstances since the date of the last judicial pronouncement regarding support money payments as would justify or require a modification thereof. White v. White, supra.
Respondent, however, argues that the issue of predivorce conduct was opened up by counsel for appellant because of certain allegations in his opening statement, and, therefore, respondent was entitled to rebut these allegations. We think otherwise. If appellant did in fact open up the question of the predivorce conduct of the parties by remarks made in her counsel’s opening statement, this did not justify the trial court in receiving further testimony on this issue, offered in rebuttal by respondent. Erroneous admission of evidence is not cured by the reception of additional inadmissible evidence, even though the latter is admitted to counter the possible prejudicial effect of the former. In
The order is reversed,, and the cause remanded to the superior court for further proceedings consistent with the views expressed in this opinion. Neither party shall receive costs on this appeal.
Hamley, C. J., Schwellenbach, Donworth, and Weaver, JJ., concur.