Cooper v. Mills CountyCooper v. Mills County
- Reporters:
- ,
- Before:
- Adamscii
Lead Opinion
On the fourth day of July, 1882, the plaintiff’s intestate, Mrs. Elizabeth Cooper, attempted to cross the bridge in question in a wagon drawn by two horses, and in which wagon, besides herself, were one Lowe, acting as driver, and five children, from tivo to thirteen or fourteen years of age. While thus attempting to cross the bridge it fell, and the plaintiff’s intestate received severe and permanent injuries. The wagon was’ an ordinary two-horse lumber wagon. Another wagon, with four adults in it, and six children, had crossed in safety a moment before. The plaintiff contends that the bridge fell by reason of being defective. The defendant contends that it fell by reason of an unexpected wash-out, producing a land-slide just at the moment of the plaintiff’s intestate’s attempted passage.
Reversed.
Dissenting Opinion
dissenting. — I cannot concur in the conclusion *358of the majority of the court announced in the tenth point of the foregoing opinion. The identical questions of law involved in this point arose in Collins v. City of Council Bluffs, 35 Iowa, 432. The facts in this case are very like those of that; and the conclusions reached in both are based upon the same grounds. What I said in my dissenting opinion in that ease is applicable to this. I still entertain the views of the law expressed therein, and now have no doubt of their correctness. For the reasons stated in that opinion, I dissent in this case. I concur in the foregoing majority opinion upon all points in the case save the tenth.