Case Information
*1 IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT EASTERN DISTRICT OF NORTH CAROLINA WESTERN DIVISION
) CAROLINA POWER & LIGHT COMPANY )
d/b/a PROGRESS ENERGY CAROLINAS, INC., )
) Plaintiff, ) 5:08-CV-00460-FL v. )
) 3 M COMPANY, et aI., )
) Defendants.
) CONSOLIDATION COAL COMPANY, )
) Plaintiff, ) v. ) 5:08-CV-00463-FL
) 3 M COMPANY, et aI., )
) Defendants. ) CONSENT ORDER AND STIPULATION REGARDING THE
COURT'S MARCH 24, 2010 ORDER
THIS CAUSE came to be heard on the joint application of Plaintiffs and Defendants with respect to the application of this Court's March 24,2010 Order (CP&L DE # 277; Consol DE # 305) dismissing Plaintiffs' § 107 claims as to certain Defendants.
In pertinent part, the Court's March 24 Order held as foIlows: Concurring defendants' supplemental motion to dismiss plaintiffs' § 107 claim (CP&L DE # 266; Consol DE # 256) is GRANTED. Plaintiffs' claims are DISMISSED as to the concurring defendants only. Cross-claimant's § 107 claims are unaffected by this disposition.
March 24 Order, at 33.
The Court's March 24 Order with respect to the Plaintiffs' § 107 claim was made in response to a motion made by a limited number of defendants. Accordingly, the Order granting the motion was made with respect to only that limited number of defendants. The Plaintiffs and Defendants agree and stipulate that the Court's March 24 Order dismissing the Plaintiffs' § 107 claim as to that limited number of defendants is applicable as to all Defendants.
THEREFORE, IT IS HEREBY STIPULATED, AGREED AND ORDERED that Plaintiffs' § 107 claims as to the remaining defendants are DISMISSED for the reasons set forth in the Court's March 24 ORDER. Cross-claimant PCS Phosphate Company, Inc.'s § 107 claims are unaffected by this disposition.
IT IS FURTHER STIPULATED, AGREED AND ORDERED that Defendants' respective § 113(f) counterclaims asserted in response to the dismissed § 107(a) claims are hereby DISMISSED. Defendants' § 113(f) crossclaims in response to PCS Phosphate's § 107(a) and §113(g)(2) claims are unaffected by this disposition.
It is further stipulated, agreed and ordered that Defendants' Motion to Strike Pursuant to Fed. R. Civ. P. 12(f) Count I of Plaintiff Carolina Power & Light Company d/b/a Progress Energy Carolinas, Inc. 's Consolidated and Third Amended Complaint (CP&L DE # 342; Consol DE # 348) is DENIED as MOOT.
SO ORDERED, THIS ~ DAY OF ~ 2010. LO I . FLANAGAN Chief United States District Court Judge *3 CONSENTED TO:
Counsel for Plaintiffs:
lsi Christopher G. Smith lsi J. Donald Cowan, Jr.
CHRISTOPHER G. SMITH J. DONALD COWAN, JR.
N.C. Bar No. 22767 N.C. Bar No. 0968 CAROLINE N. BELK ELLIS & WINTERS LLP N.C. Bar No. 32574 1100 Crescent Green Drive, Suite 200 SMITH, ANDERSON, BLOUNT, DORSETT, Cary, NC 27518 MITCHELL & JERNIGAN, LLP Telephone: (919) 865-7000 Post Office Box 2611 Facsimile: (919) 865-7010 Raleigh, NC 27602-2611 Email: don.cowan@elliswinters.com Telephone: (919) 821-1220
lsi Jane Borthwick Story Facsimile: (919) 821-6800 Email: csmith@smithlaw.com MICHAEL H. GINSBERG cbelk@smithlaw.com Pa. Bar No. 43582 MARY BETH DEEMER Pa. Bar No. 41887 COUNSEL FOR PLAINTIFF CAROLINA POWER & LIGHT COMPANY d/b/a JANE BORTHWICK STORY Pa. Bar No. 205641 PROGRESS ENERGY CAROLINAS, INC.
JONES DAY 500 Grant Street, Suite 4500 lsi William W. Pollock Pittsburg, PA 15219-2514 WILLIAM W. POLLOCK Telephone: (412) 391-3939 N.C. Bar No. 19381
Facsimile: (412) 394-7959 CRANFILL SUMNER & HARTZOG LLP Email: mhginsberg@jonesday.com Post Office Box 27808 mbdeemer@jonesday.com Raleigh, NC 27611-7808 jbstory@jonesday.com Telephone: (919) 828-5100 Facsimile: (919) 828-2277
COUNSEL FOR CROSSCLAIM PLAINTIFF Email: wpollockra\:shluw.com PCS PHOSPHATE COMPANY, INC. lsi Daniel M. Darragh
DANIEL M. DARRAGH
Pa. Bar No. 34076
Attorneys for Plaintiff
COHEN & GRIGSBY, P.C.
625 Liberty Avenue
Pittsburgh, PA 15222-3125
Telephone: (412) 297-4718
Facsimile: (412) 209-1940
Email: ddarragh@cohenlaw.com
COUNSEL FOR PLAINTIFF
CONSOLIDATION COAL COMPANY
Counsel for Defendants: lsi Jane E. Fedder lsi Julia S. Bright Jane E. Fedder Julia S. Bright Joseph G. Nassif John S. Slosson Husch Blackwell Sanders, LLP Nelson Mullins Riley & Scarborough, LLP 190 Carondelet Plaza, Suite 600 100 North Tryon Street, Bank of America S1. Louis, MO 63105 Corporate Ctr. , Suite 4200 314-4801500 I 314-4801505 (fax) Charlotte, NC 28202-4007 jane.fedder@huschblackwell.com 704-417-3136 1704-417-3249 (fax) joseph.nassif@huschblackwell.com julia.bright@nelsonmullins.com
jack.slosson@nelsonmullins.com Counselfor Atlantic City Electric Company; Blue Ridge Electric Cooperative, Inc.; Broad River Electric Cooperative, Inc.,' Cargill, Incorporated,' Consumers Energy Company; Danny Corporation; Delmarva Power & Light Company,' Dixon Lumber Company, Inc.,' Electric Control Equipment Co.,' Electric Equipment Corporation of Virginia; Florida Power & Light Company,' GKN Driveline North American, Inc.,' General Electric Company,' Gladieux Trading & Marketing Co., LP, and/or Limited Corporation,' Glenwood Resolution Authority, Inc.,' LWB Refractories Company,' Occidental Chemical Corporation; Pharmacia Corporation; Potomac Electric Power Company,' Sonoco Products Company; Southland Electrical Supply, Inc.,' St. Joseph Medical Center, Inc.; T and R Electric Supply Company, Inc.; Tri-State Armature Electrical Works, Inc.; Unimin Corporation; and United Technolo ies Cor oration
*5 lsi Donald 1. Camerson, II lsi Patrick A. Genzler Donald J. Camerson, II Patrick A. GenzIer NJ State BarNo. 012921990 NC State Bar No. 23737 Kirstin K. 0' Callaghan Vandeventer Black LLP NJ State Bar No. 028612005 101 West Main St.
Bressler, Amery & Ross, P.C. 500 World Trade Center Norfolk, VA 23510 325 Columbia Turnpike Phone: (757) 446-8600 Florham Park, NJ 07932 pgenzleri(l)van bIk.com d i camerson: d bress ieI' .com and
kocall aghan (a) bres s ieI'. co m
Norman W. Shearin Attorneys by Special Appearance for NC State Bar No. 3956 Defendants 3M Company & Kraft Foods Vandeventer Black LLP P.O. Box 2599 Global, Inc.
Raleigh, NC 27602-2599 and
nsheari ni(i'vanblk .com lsi John W Bowers Attorneys for Defendant Cape Hatteras John W. Bowers Electric Membership Corporation NC State Bar No. 24133 D. Christopher Osborn
NC State Bar No. 22237
Horack Talley
2600 One Wachovia Center
301 South College Street
Charlotte, NC 28202 bowers((/1 horac ktallev .com
cosborn(l:l)horacktalley.com Counsel for Defendants 3M
Company & Kraft Foods, Global, Inc. *6 Troutman Sanders LLP lsi Andrea L. Rimer Andrea L. Rimer lsi Gavin B. Parsons GA State Bar No. 605735 Gavin B. Parsons 600 Peachtree St., NE, Suite 5200 NC State Bar No. 28013 Atlanta, GA 30308-2216 Phone: (404) 885-3265 Post Office Drawer 1389 Fax: (404) 962-6669 Raleigh, NC 27602 and rea. ri mer(aitrou tm an sanders.com Phone: (919) 835-4107 Attorneys for Virginia Electric and Power Fax: (919) 829-8715 Company Gavin.parsons(dltrolltm an sanders.com and
and lsi D. Kyle Deak Daniel S. Reinhardt Patricia P. Kerner GA State Bar No. 600350 NC State Bar No. 13005 Hollister A. Hill D. Kyle Deak GA State Bar No. 003910 NC State Bar No. 35799
Jeffrey J. Hayward 434 Fayetteville Street GA State Bar No. 159051 Two Hannover Square, Suite 1900 5200 Bank of America Plaza Raleigh, NC 27601 600 Peachtree Street, N.E. Phone: (919)835-4100
Atlanta, GA 30308-2216 Fax: (919) 835-4101 Phone: (404) 885-3084 tri cia. kern er((lltro II tm ansand ers .co m Fax: (404) 962-6679 kyle.deak(citrolltmansandcrs.colll Dan ie I. re in hardt((/1trolitmansanders.eDm 110 II ister.h i IJ(dtrolitmansanders.com Counselfor Virginia Electric and
.J cIT. ha ,,\VaI'd (a) tro lit man sand ers .com Power Company Attorneys for Georgia Power Company,
individually and as successor-in-interest to Savannah Electric and Power Companv
*7 /s/ Joseph P. Williams /s/ Jacob H Wellman Joseph P. Williams Henry W. Gorham Ryan K. McKain NC State Bar No: 6174 Shipman & Goodwin LLP Jacob H. Wellman One Constitution Plaza N.C. State Bar No.: 28853 Hartford, CT 06103-1919 Teague Campbell Dennis & Gorham LLP P.O. Box 19207 Raleigh, NC 27619-9207 jwill iamsl(l)goodwin.com hgorham(a)tcd g.com
Connecticut Juris No. 57385
jwellman(c/ i tcdg.col11 Attorney for Defendant Bonner Electric, Inc.
Attorneysfor Defendant Royal Street Junk Company, Inc. and
/s/ H Clay Hodges
H. Clay Hodges, NCSB #29270
Donald J. Harris
Harris, Winfield, Sarratt & Hodges, LLP
1620 Hillsborough Street
Suite 200
Raleigh, NC 27605
chodges((l'harriswin1~eld.com Counsel for Bonner Electric, Inc.
*8 lsi R. Steven DeGeorge lsi Carson Carmichael R. Steven DeGeorge Carson Carmichael Robinson, Bradshaw & Hinson, PA NC State Bar #9734 101 North Tryon Street David S. Coats NC State Bar #16162
Suite 1900 Bailey Dixon, LLP Charlotte, NC 28246-1900 sdcgcorgci(j: rbh .com P.O. Box 1351
Raleigh, NC 27602 Attorneysfor Bruce-Merrilees Electric Co.,
Conoco Phillips Company, Monongahela
Power Co., CBS Corporation, West Penn and
Power Co.
Dennis J. Conniff Kentucky State Bar # 14150 Amy D. Cubbage Kentucky Bar #86902 Frost Brown Todd LLC 400 West Market St., 32 nd Floor Louisville, Kentucky 40202 dconni rt!(l'fbtlaw.com acubbagcruitbtlaw.com Attorneys for East Kentucky Power Cooperative, Inc.
*9 /s/ Nicholas 1. Voelker /s/ Joel Herz Nicholas J. Voelker, NC Bar No. 35841 Joel L. Herz Bradley Arant Boult Cummings, LLP AZ State Bar No. 015105 Law Offices of Joel L. Herz Bank of America Corporate Center 100 N. Tryon Street, Suite 2690 3573 East Sunrise Drive, Suite 215 Charlotte, NC 28202 Tucson, AZ 85718 Phone: (520) 529-8080 Phone: (704) 332.8842 Fax: (520) 529-8077 Fax: (704) 332.8858 nvoel kcr(({ibabe.eom joel(cDjoelhcrz.eom Attorney by Special Appearance for LR 83.1 Counsel City ofHuntsville d/b/a Defendant NL Industries, Inc. Huntsville Utilities and And /s/ Paul Klein
/s/ Benjamin L. McArthur Paul Klein Benjamin L. McArthur NC State Bar No. 18636
AL State Bar No. ASB-I049-B61M
Klein & Freeman, PLLC 4521 Sharon Road, Suite 150 /s/ E. Cutter Hughes P.O. Box 221648 E. Cutter Hughes Charlotte, NC 28222-1648 AL State Bar No. ASB-2272-E67E Phone: (704) 442-0660 Bradley Arant Boult Cummings LLP Fax: (704) 364-2295 200 Clinton Avenue West, Suite 900 paulk lein:e/:k kin tl'ccman .enm Huntsville, AL 35801-4900 Phone: 256.517.5100 LR 83.1 Counsel
Fax: 256.517.5200 bm earth u ria) babc.com Attorney for Defendant NL Industries, Inc. ehughcs(cDbabe .com Special Counsel for City of Huntsville d/b/a Huntsville Utilities
*10 /s/ Susan H. Briggs /s/ Kurt J Olson Susan H. Briggs Kurt J. Olson NC State Bar No. Law Office of Kurt J. Olson, PLLC Dickie, McCamey & Chilcote, P.C. 3737 Glenwood Avenue, Suite 100 2115 Rexford Road, Suite 210 Raleigh, NC 27612 Charlotte, NC 28211 Phone: 919-573-6172 Fax: 919-573-6173 Phone: 704.998.5184 kurt. .olson((jigrnai I.com sbri ggs(({)d rnc law .com and Attorney for Arkema, Inc., BASF Corp.,
Stauffer management Co. on behalf ofBayer /s/ Peter T. Stinson CropScience, Inc., CSX Residual Co., Peter T. Stinson, Esquire Duquense Light Co., Sara Lee Corp., P.A.I.D. No.: 39044 Chemical Products, Corp., Sumter Electric Dickie McCamey & Chilcote, PC Cooperative, Inc., Mid American Energy Co., Two PPG Place, Suite 400 Norfolk Southern Railway Co., Haines & Pittsburg, PA 15222-5402 Kibblehouse, Inc., South Central Power Co., Phone: 412.392.5432 General Extrusions, Inc., Cooper Tire and pSlinson((1idmc law .com Rubber Co., American Skiing Co.,
Appalachian Power Co., Kingsport Power Attorneysfor Carlisle Syntec Incorporated Co., International Paper Co., Kobe Copper and PPG Industries, Inc. Products, Inc., Environmental Protection
Services, Inc., Jessop Steel, LLC, Foremost Electric and Transmission, Inc., Holladay Property Services, Midwest, Inc. (aka Holladay Corp.), Erachem Comilog *11 /s/ Kurt J Olson /s/ Ronald E. Cardwell Kurt J. Olson Ronald E. Cardwell Law Office of Kurt 1. Olson, PLLC NC State Bar No. 17027 3737 Glenwood Avenue, Suite 100 McNair Law Firm, P.A.
Raleigh, NC 27612 104 South Main St., Suite 700 Phone: 919-573-6172 P.O. Box 447
Fax: 919-573-6173 Greenville, SC 29602 kurt. .OISolli<vgmail.com Phone: (864)271-4940
Fax: (864) 271-4015 John S. EllenHahn rcardwell({1)mcnair.net Robert B. Cordle
Mayer Brown LLP and
1999 K Street NW Washington, DC 20006 Lee W. Zimmerman 202-263-3346 Ethan R. Ware
202-236-5346 (fax) McNair Law Firm, P.A. 1301 Gervais St., 1 i h Floor
jhahn(a'mavcrbrown.com P.O. Box 11390 Attorney for Defendant Frontier Columbia, 29211 Communications Corp.,flkla Citizens Phone: (803) 799-9800 Communications Company Fax: (803) 753-3219
Izim Il1crm an(/:t:l1lcllair.nct cwarcic/'mcnai r.nct Attorneys for Furman University, Intertape Polymer Group, Lafarge Mid-Atlantic and Owen Electric Steel *12 lsi GreJZOrv 1. Lucht lsi Herman L. Fussell Kevin D. Margolis, OHSB #0042043 Hennan L. Fussell, Georgia SB #281100 Gregory J. Lucht, OHSB #0075045 Shapiro Fussell Wedge & Martin, LLP One Midtown Plaza, Suite 1200 Benesch, Friedlander, Coplan Aronoff, LLP 1360 Peachtree St. Atlanta, GA 30309
200 Public Square, Ste. 2300 Cleveland,OH 44114-2378 Fax: (404) 870-2213
Phone: (216)363-4511 Fax: (216) 363-4588 Attorney for Defendant Cleveland Electric
kman.rol is(dbeneschlaw .COI11 gillcht!cj'benesch law .com Co.
Attorneys for Defendant Green Circle and
Growers, Inc.
lsi Brian 1. Schoo/man Brian J. Schoolman, NCSB #26266 and
Safran Law Offices 120 South Boylan Avenue (27603) lsi Steven K. McCallister Post Office Box 587 Kieran J. Shanahan, NCSB #13329 Raleigh, North Carolina 27602-0587 Steven K. McCal1ister, NCSB #25532 Shanahan Law Group, PLLC
128 E. Hargett Street, Third Floor
Raleigh, NC 27601 LR Counselfor Defendant Cleveland Electric Company
kierarvdshanahanlm\ group.com
smcca II isterl(vshanahanalawgrollp.com 83.1 Counselfor Defendant Green Circle
Growers, Inc. *13 lsi Timothv 1. Bergere lsi Donald H Beskind Timothy 1. Bergere Donald H. Beskind Pennsylvania Attorney I.D. No. 39110 NC State Bar No. 8138 Montgomery McCracken beskind(a)nctrial.com 123 South Broad Street Avenue of the Arts lsi Jesse H Rigsby. IV Philadelphia, PA 19109-1030 Jesse H. Rigsby, IV Phone: (215) 772-1500 / Fax: (215) 772-7620 NC State Bar No. 35538 lbergerc(c1Jmmwr.com rigsby(d1nclrial.com Twiggs Beskind Strickland & Rabenau, PA Attorneys by Special Appearancefor Wachovia Capital Center Defendant Carr & Duff, Inc. 150 Fayetteville Street, Suite 1100 Raleigh, NC 27601 And lsi Mason Avrigian. Jr. Mason Avrigian, Jr. 83.1 Counsel Defendant Union Electric Pennsylvania Attorney I.D. No. 51647 Company
Jeffrey P. Wallack
Pennsylvania Attorney I.D. No. 69112 and
Wisler Pearlstine, LLP
484 Norristown Road, Suite 100 lsi Joseph F. Madonia Blue Bell, PA 19422-2326 Joseph F. Madonia Phone: (610) 825-8400 / Fax: (610) 828-4887 IL State Bar No. 6190852 mavri gian(a;w ispearl.com madonia((/!wi Idman.com jwallack({/)w ispearl.com
lsi Meghan M Hubbard Attorneys by Special Appearancefor Meghan M. Hubbard Defendant Carr & Duff, Inc. IL State Bar No. 6275155
hubbard(i~wildman.com and Wildman, Harrold, Allen & Dixon, LLP
225 W. Wacker Drive, Suite 2800 lsi E. Hardy Lewis Chicago, IL 60606 E. Hardy Lewis Phone: (312)201-2810 NC Bar No. 18282 Fax: (312)201-2555 Blanchard, Miller, Lewis Styers, P.A.
1117 Hillsborough Street Attorneys for Union Electric Company Raleigh, NC 27603
Phone: (919) 747-8107 /Fax: (919) 755-3994
hIewis(iiJbm lslaw.com
Local Rule Counselfor Defendant Carr
& Duff, Inc. *14 /s/ Joel A. Kramer /s/ William H Harkins, Jr. Joel A. Kramer William H. Harkins, Jr.
District of Maryland Bar No.: 04224 John C. Millberg 14501 Sweitzer Lane, 12 th Floor Millberg Gordon Stewart PLLC Laurel, MD 20707 1101 Haynes Street, Suite 104 Phone: (301) 206-8159 Raleigh, NC 27604 Fax: (301) 206-8157 whark i ns({i!m gsattomeys.com 111 i 11 bcrgtt/im gsattornevs.com jkramen(lwsscwater.com Attorney for Defendant Washington Brian K. Lewallen Suburban Sanitary Commission Julie S. Solmer Stine
Caterpillar Inc., - Legal Services Division 100 N.E. Adams St.
Peoria, IL 61629-6485 309-675-1553 309-494-1467 (fax) Icwa lien brian k l t/1<.:aLcol11 stine julie s({fJcaLcom Attorney for Defendant Caterpillar Inc. /s/ John A. Sheehan /s/ Marc J. Wojciechowski John A. Sheehan Marc J. Wojciechowski R. Dennis Fairbanks TX State Bar No. 21844600 Wojciechowski & Associates, P.c. Hunton & Williams, LLP 1900 K Street, N.W. 17447 Kuykendahl Road, Suite 200 Washington, D.C. 20006 Spring, Texas 77379 jsheehan!(ilhunton.com
dfa irban ks(a)hunton.com I11arc~li\'"oiolaw .com Attorney for Defendants Alcoa, Inc. & Attorneys for Defendant Ventech Equipment, Tredegar Film Products Corporation Inc.
/s/ Scott Brown Scott Brown Brown, Crump, Vanore & Tierney, LLP 421 Fayetteville Street, Suite 1601 Raleigh, North Carolina 27601 S Brow tYdbcvtlaw.col11 L.R. Counsel for Defendant Ventech Equipment, Inc.
*15 lsi William A. White lsi Zackary D. Knaub Stephen L. Gordon William A. White Zackary D. Knaub NC State Bar No. 21484 Moore & Van Allen, PLLC Beveridge & Diamond, PC 477 Madison Ave., 15 th Floor 100 North Tryon St., Suite 4700 Charlotte, NC 28282-4003 New York, NY 10022-5802 zknLlUbr({)bdlaw.col11 bi 11 ...... 11 ite({im valLl""" .com
lsi David E. Fox David E. Fox lsi David E. Fox 430 Davis Drive David E. Fox (N.C. Bar No. 10332) Suite 500 Michael J. Byrne (N.C. Bar No. 23577) Morrisville, NC 27560-6832
Moore Van Allen, PLLC cia vid t()x(u)mvalaw .com P.O. Box 13706 Research Triangle Park, NC 27709 Attorneys for Defendant Cogentrix Energy, LLC
daviclfox((7Jmvalaw.com
111 icl1aelbyrne Li 1 111valaw .C0111
Attorneysfor Defendants Martin Marietta
Materials, Inc.; North Carolina State
University; Nucor Corp.; University ofNorth
Carolina at Chapel Hill; Town ofBlackstone,
Virginia; City ofDover, Delaware and
Wartburg College *16 /s/ Robert 0. Renbarger /s/ Bret W Jedele Robert O. Renbarger Bret W. Jedele
TX State BarNo. 16768100 RI State Bar No. 6053 Fritz, Byrne, Head & Harrison, PLLC Chace, Ruttenberg & Freeman, LLP 98 San Jacinto Blvd., Suite 2000 One Park Row, Suite 300 Austin, TX 78701 Providence, RI 02903 Phone: (401) 503-6411 Fax: (401) 503-6411 Fax: (512) 477-5267 bob,(i" lbhh .com bicdclcrZhrlllp.com Attorney by Special Appearancefor Attorneys for Defendant Jet Electric Motor Company, Inc. Defendant CHRISTUS Health Northern
Louisiana
/s/ James F. Hopf /s/ Curtis L. Bentz James F. Hopf Curtis L. Bentz NC State Bar No. 13551 Hopf & Highley, P.A. NC State Bar No. 19733 1694 E. Arlington Blvd., Suite E Battle, Winslow, Scott & Wiley, PA Greenville, NC 27858 2343 Professional Drive P.O. Box 7100
Rocky Mount, NC 27804-0100 jim@hopthighlev.colll LR 83.1 Coum'elfor Defendant Jet Electric cbcntz(albwsw.com
Company, Inc. Counselfor Defendant CHRISTUS
Health Northern Louisiana *17 Wyrick Robbins Yates & Ponton, LLP /s/ David 1. Mazza David J. Mazza /s/ Grady L. Shields NC State Bar No. 26082 Womble Carlyle Sandridge & Rice, PLLC Grady L. Shields One West Fourth Street NC State Bar No. 13101 Winston-Salem, NC 27101 4101 Lake Boone Trail, Suite 300 Raleigh, NC 27607-7506 Phone: (336) 728-7031 drnazzar(7)wcsr.col11 Attorney for Defendant Veolia Fax: (919) 781-4865 gshields((iiwvrick.com Environmental Services Waste-to-Energy
flk/a Montenay Power Corporation Special Counselfor Defendant Koch Industries
Lathrop & Gage, LLP /s/ Scott Lewis
/s/ Jessica E. Merrigan Scott Lewis Jessica E. Merrigan NC State Bar No. 22167 Hedrick, Gardner, Kincheloe & Garofalo, MO State Bar No. 54982 L.L.P. Thomas A. Ryan 1838 sir Tyler Drive, Suite 200
MO State Bar No. 32437 2345 Grand Blvd., Suite 2800 Wilmington, NC 28405 Kansas City, MO 64108 slcwis(ijJhedrickgardner.com mcrrigan(d lathrop gage .com Attorney for Defendant Dean's Light Box, Inc.
trvan (c} Iathropgagc.coJl1
Attorneys by Special Appearance for
Defendant Koch Industries *18 POYNER SPRUILL, LLP lsi Charles K. Douthwaite Charles K. Douthwaite lsi Keith H. Johnson WA State Bar No. 9246 Keith H. Johnson P.O. Box 9777 NC State Bar No. 177885 Federal Way, WA 98063-9777 Andrew H. Erteschik
NC State Bar No. 35269 Fax: (253) 928-2184 Poyner Spruill, LLP Chari ie .dollth waitc(a)weycrhaellser .com 301 Fayetteville Street, Suite 1900
Raleigh, NC 27601 Attorneys for Defendant Weyerhaeuser Phone: (919)783-1013 Company
k johnsonle.r:poynerspru II.com lsi Scott C. Hart aCl1csch ik(a:povnersprll i II.com Scott C. Hart
NC State Bar No. 1906 Attorneys for Defendants Dorey Electric Co., Sumrell, Sugg, Carmichael, Hicks & Hart, Town of Louisburg, North Carolina P.A.
Department ofAgriculture and Consumer Post Office Drawer 889 Services, North Carolina Department of New Bern, NC 28563 Health Human Services (named as:
Cherry Hospital, Central Regional Hospital and O'Berry Neuro-Medical Center), shart:C,lnc la \VVe rS.com Phoenix Solutions Co. and Peace College of
Raleigh, Inc. Counselfor Defendant
Weyerhaeuser Company *19 lsi Joan W Hartley lsi Joan W Hartley Marcus A. Manos Marcus A. Manos NC State Bar No. 21783 NC State Bar No. 21783 Joan Wash Hartley Joan Wash Hartley NC State Bar No. 36361 NC State Bar No. 36361 William T. Lavender, Jr. William T. Lavender, Jr. S.C. State Bar No. 3143
S.C. State Bar No. 3143 Nexsen Pruet, LLC Nexsen Pruet, LLC 1230 Main Street, Suite 700 1230 Main Street, Suite 700 P.O. Box 2426 P.O. Box 2426 Columbia, SC 29201
Columbia, SC 29201 Phone: (803) 771-8900 mmanos(a) ncx scn pruet.colll Illmanos({i nexscn pruet .com i hart I CVrZl) ncx se 11 pruet.co 111 i hat11cv i {j ncxsen pruct.cum t lavcndcrl(J) ncxscn pruct.com tIav en d crill> ne :\SCIl pruct .COIll Russell S. Warner Cynthia M. Currin NC State Bar No. 9184 Marissa A. Savastana MacDonald, Illig, Jones Britton, LLP Crisp, Page & Currin, LLP 4010 Barrett Drive, Suite 205 100 State Street, Suite 700 Raleigh, NC 27609 Erie, PA 16507-1459 msa vastana(a;m i i b.com
rwarncr((Jlm i b.com ccurri nrZikpclaw .com
Attorneys for Defendant Bedford Rural Electric Cooperative, Inc. Attorneysfor Defendant Warren Electric Cooperative
*20 Isl Joan Wash Hartley lsi Joan W Hartley Marcus A. Manos Marcus A. Manos NC State Bar No. 21783 NC State Bar No. 21783 Joan Wash Hartley Joan Wash Hartley NC State Bar No. 36361 NC State Bar No. 36361 William T. Lavender, Jr. William T. Lavender, Jr.
S.c. State Bar No. 3143 S.c. State Bar No. 3143 Nexsen Pruet, LLC Nexsen Pruet, LLC 1230 Main Street, Suite 700 1230 Main Street, Suite 700 P.O. Box 2426 P.O. Box 2426
Columbia, SC 29201 Columbia, SC 29201 Phone: (803) 771-8900 Phone: (803) 771-8900 I1lll1anos(c/)nexsenpruet.com mmanos(a)nexsenpruet.com hart leY((lJ nexsenpruet.com i hart Iev((u nex senpruet .com tlavender@nexsenpruct.coIn tlavender@nexsenpruet.com Attorneys for Defendants Greenwood Mills, David Bates Gardere Wynne Sewell, LLP
Inc., Palmetto Electric Cooperative, Inc., and Santee Electric Cooperative, Inc. 1000 Louisiana, Suite 3400
Houston, TX 77002 Phone: (713) 276-5355 d bates((/' garderc .com Attorneys for Defendants IES Commercial, Inc., and Integrated Electrical Services, Inc. *21 lsi Bonnie Allyn Barnett lsi William E. Hvidsten Bonnie Allyn Barnett William E. Hvidsten Joshua Kaplowitz CA Bar No. 113030 P.O. Box 13222 Drinker Biddle & Reath, LLP Sacramento, CA 95813-6000 One Logan Square 18 th & Cherry Streets Phone: (916) 351-8524 Fax: (916) 355-3603 Philadelphia, PA 19103 Wi II iam.hv idslen((i1gencorp.com Fax: (215) 988-2757 Attorney for Defendant Buist Electric, Inc. Bonnie.barnelVddbr.com Gencorp, Inc.
Joshua.kaplowitz(uidbr.com
lsi Curtis L. Bentz lsi Sara W Higgins Curtis L. Bentz Sara W. Higgins NC State Bar No. 19733
Higgins Law Firm, PLLC Battle, Winslow, Scott & Wiley, P.A. 6525 Morrison Blvd., Suite 402 P.O. Box 7100
Charlotte, NJ 28211 Rocky Mount, NC 27804 sail yrii'lhehi ggi ns Iawfi nn .com cbentzrZilbwsw.com Attorneysfor Defendants PPL Electric Counselfor Defendant Buist Utilities Corp, Niagara Mohawk Power Corp. Electric, Inc.
and Trap Rock Industries, Inc. *22 /s/ F. Bryan Brice, Jr. /s/ F. Bryan Brice, Jr. F. Bryan Brice, Jr. F. Bryan Brice, Jr.
NC State Bar No. 17840 NC State Bar No. 17840 Catherine W. Cralle-Jones Catherine W. Cralle-Jones NC State Bar No. 23733 NC State Bar No. 23733 Law Offices of F. Bryan Brice, Jr. Law Offices ofF. Bryan Brice, Jr.
19 W. Hargett Street, Suite 600 19 W. Hargett Street, Suite 600 Raleigh, NC 27601 Raleigh, NC 27601 Fax: (919( 832-0301 Fax: (919( 832-0301 br"an(i/)atty bryan bri cc.co 111 br\tlndatt\bryanbrice.com calh y((j!all vbrvan bri cC.com s:.alh \ /(/all"bryan brice.com Attorneysfor Defendant Hudson Light & /s/ Ron Byrd Ron Byrd Power
Federal Bar NO. 06654
Constellation Energy Grou~, Inc. 100 Constellation Way, 1 i Floor
Baltimore, MD 21202
Attorneys for Defendant Baltimore Gas & Electric
*23 lsi Ben L. Pfefferle III lsi Robert S. Adden. Jr. Ben L. Pfefferle III Robert S. Adden, Jr. OH State Bar No. 0024297 NC State Bar No. 10223 Gregory R. Flax Ruff, Bond, Cobb, Wade & Bethune, LLP OH State Bar No. 0081206 831 East Morehead Street, Suite 860 Baker & Hostetler LLP Charlotte, NC 28202 65 East State Street, Suite 2100 Phone: (704)377-1634 Columbus, OH 43215 Fax: (704) 342-3308 Phone: (614) 462-2601 radden@rbcwb.com Fax: (614) 462-2616 Counselfor Defendant Pactiv bpfefferle@bakerlaw.com Corporation
gflax@bakerlaw.com I
Reott Law Offices, LLC Special Appearance Counsel for Defendant
Guernsey-Muskingum Electric Cooperative, lsi Raymond T Reott Inc. Raymond T. Reott IL State Bar No. 3128141 lsi Julia Mimms Julia G. Mimms lsi Becky J. Schanz NC State Bar No. 27978 Becky J. Schanz 1001 Elizabeth Avenue, Suite IA
Charlotte, NC 28204 35 E. Wacker Drive, Suite 650 Chicago, IL 60601 i l.!,lllussistantr£:/)bcllsou1.h.nct Fax: (312)782-4519 rrcott(cD reotll a W .com Counselfor Defendant Guernsey- Attorneys for Defendant Pactiv Muskingum Electric Cooperative, Inc. Corporation
lsi Jeffrev H. Weir II Is/Stanley B. Green Jeffrey H. Weir III, Esquire N.C. Bar # 25539 Strauch Fitzgerald & Green, P.C. OH State Bar No. 0067470 Colella Weir, P.L.L. 118 South Cherry Street 6055 Park Square Drive Winston-Salem, NC 27101 Lorain, OH 44053 Phone: (336)-837-1064 Fax: (336)-725-8867 Email: sgrecl1 r cisfandl.!, law .com h\\ ci r (1'CI1 \\ Iu W .COI11
Attorneys for Duke Energy Carolinas LLC Attornevfor Defendant P.e. Campana, Inc.
*24 lsi Benjamin F. Sidburv RIKER DANZIG SCHERER HYLAND PERREITILLP Benjamin F. Sidbury NC State Bar No. 28071 I!,j Jeffrey B. Wagenbach Anthony B. Taylor Jeffrey B. Wagenbach NC State Bar No. 37220 Stephen W. Smithson Alston & Bird LLP Jaan M. Haus Bank of America Plaza, Suite 4000 New Jersey Bar No. 34540 101 South Tryon Street One Speedwell Avenue Charlotte, NC 28280 Morristown, NJ 07962-1981 Phone: (704) 444-1000 Fax: (704) 444-1111 bell. sid bu rv((iia I stoll.com jwagenbach@riker.com tonytaylor@alston.com ssm th SOniCl) ri kcr.com LR 83.I(d) Counsel jhaus@riker.com Douglas S. Arnold MARTIN & GIFFORD, PLLC GA State Bar No. 023208 lsi William H. Gifford, Jr. Kristin Holloway Jones William H. Gifford, Jr. GA BarNo. 041154 N.C. State Bar No. 25175 Alston Bird LLP 301 North Main Street, Suite 2200 One Atlantic Center Winston-Salem, NC 27101 2302 West Peachtree Street Phone: 336-714-0333 Atlanta, GA 30309-3424 Fax: 336-714-0334 Phone: (404) 881-7000 billomurtingiC/()rdlu w .col11
LR 83.1 Counsel Doug.arnoldi(valsloll.COIll
Kristi 11. jones@alslon.com Attorneys for Defendant, LR 83.I(e) Counsel G&S Motor Equipment Company, Inc
Attorneysfor Defendants ECC International, Inc.; Tennessee Electro Minerals, Inc.; Union Carbide Corp.; and Vulcan Construction Materials, L.P. *25 lsi Benjamin F. Sidbury Charles S. Conerly Benjamin F. Sidbury GA State Bar No. 180720 NC State Bar No. 28071 Smith Diment Conerly, LLP Anthony B. Taylor 402 Newnan Street NC State Bar No.3 7220 Carrollton, GA 30117 Alston & Bird LLP Phone: (770) 834-1160 Fax: (770) 834-1190 Bank of America Plaza, Suite 4000 cconerl v((J)sm ithd imcnt.col11 101 South Tryon Street Charlotte, NC 28280 LR 83.i(e) Counsel
Phone: (704) 444-1000 Fax: (704) 444-1111
bl'n.sid bury ((llal ston.com Henry C. Tharpe, Jr. tony.taylor@alston.com GA State Bar No. 703250 Sponcler & Tharpe, LLC LR 83.i(d) Counsel P.O. Box 398 225 W. King St.
Robert D. Mowrey Dalton, GA 307222-0398 GA State Bar No. 527510 Phone: (706) 278-5211 Kristin Holloway Jones Fax: (706) 270-9438 GA BarNo. 041154 hctharpettIlsponc lerandtharpc .COI11 Alston Bird LLP One Atlantic Center LR 83.i(e) Counsel 2302 West Peachtree Street Atlanta, GA 30309-3424
Phone: (404) 881-7000
Fax: (404) 881-7777
Bob.mowrevr(lJalstc)t1.com
[<ristin. ones(u)alston .com 83.i(e) Counsel
*26 /s/ Beniamin F. Sidbury /s/ Benjamin F. Sidbury Benjamin F. Sidbury Benjamin F. Sidbury NC State Bar No. 28071 NC State Bar No. 28071 Anthony B. Taylor Alston & Bird LLP NC State Bar No.3 7220 Bank of America Plaza, Suite 4000 101 South Tryon Street Alston & Bird LLP Charlotte, NC 28280 Bank of America Plaza, Suite 4000 Phone: (704) 444-1000 101 South Tryon Street Charlotte, NC 28280 Fax: (704) 444-1111 ben.sidbury(a)alston.col1l Phone: (704) 444-1000 LR 83.I(d) Counsel bcn.sidbury(q)alston.com tony.taylor@alston.com
Attorneys for Defendant Imerys Carbonates, LR 83.I(d) Counsel LLC
Robert D. Mowrey
GA State Bar No. 527510
Kristin Holloway Jones
GA Bar No. 041154
Alston Bird LLP
One Atlantic Center
2302 West Peachtree Street
Atlanta, GA 30309-3424
Bob.l1lowrev(c/)a!ston.com
Kristin. jones(iua Iston.com 83. 1(e) Counsel
Attorneys for Defendant Northrop Grumman
Shipbuilding, Inc. *27 /s/ John W Kalich /s/ Debora S. Lasch A. Bruce White Debora S. Lasch IL Bar No. 2999102 State Bar No. 0040441 John W. Katich Singerman, Mills, Desberg & Kauntz cO., IL Bar No. 6193109 L.P.A.
Karaganis, White & Magel, Ltd 3401 Enterprise Parkway, Suite 200 414 N. Orleans Street, Suite 810 Beachwood, Ohio 44122 Chicago, IL 60054-4459 Phone: (216) 292-5807 Phone: (312) 836-1177 Fax: (216) 292-5867 (312) 836-9083 dlaschiZl)smdk law.com Fax: bwhiteicrk-\\ .com Attorney for Defendant International Power
jkalich({!Jk-w.com
Machinery Company Attorneys by Special Appearance for /s/ Sean M Sullivan
Defendant Alcan Primary Products Corporation Sean M. Sullivan
State Bar No. 38957 /s/ Joshua H. Bennett Williams Mullen Richard V. Bennett 3200 BeechleafCourt, Suite 500 Raleigh, North Carolina 27604 NC State Bar No. 6028 Phone: (919) 981-4312 Joshua H. Bennett Fax: (919) 981-4300 NC State Bar No. 32576 Email: ssull ivan(Z/)w i II iamsm ullen .COIll Bennett & Guthrie, PLLC 1560 Westbrook Plaza Drive L.R. Counsel Defendant International
Winston-Salem, NC 27103 Power Machinery Company Phone: (336) 765-3121 Fax: (336) 765-8622
rbennctt:d' bennett -guth ric .com
lli'nncl1'il'hen nett - g lit hri e. corn
Attorneys for Defendant Alcan Primary Products Corporation
*28 IslBradley M Risinger lsi Dennis Reis Bradley M. Risinger Dennis Reis
NC State Bar No. 23629 WI Bar No. 1005696 Smith Moore Leatherwood, LLP Briggs and Morgan, P.A.
434 2200 IDS Center Fayetteville Street, Suite 2800 (27601) 80 South 8th Street P.O. Box 27525 Minneapolis, MN 55402 Raleigh, NC 27611 Fax: (612) 977-8650
Fax: (919)755-8800 dreis(dbri ggs.com j)rad. ri"j ngcr (( Sill lhllloorclaw .com
Mary Maclean D. Asbill Attorney for Defendants Apogee Coal N.C. Bar No. 38936 Company, LLC and Lockwood's Electric 2818 Exeter Circle Raleigh, N.C. 27609 Motor Service, Inc.
Phone: (919) 389-2636 I1lmasbi Wa)glllai I.com L.R. 83.1 Counsel Attorneys for Domtar Paper Company, LLC /s/ Todd S. Roessler lsi John J Butler Todd S. Roessler John J. Butler Kilpatrick Stockton, LLP N.C. Bar No.1 0820 3737 Glenwood Ave. Parker Poe Adams Bernstein, LLP 150 Fayetteville Street, Suite 1400 Suite 400 Raleigh, NC 27612
Post Office Box 389 919-420-1726 Raleigh, North Carolina 27602 919-510-6121 (fax) troess Ier(a)k i Ipatrickstoc klon.com
javbutlcr!(}parkerpoe.com
Attorneys for Bassett Furniture Industries, Inc. Kurt J. Olson
Law Office of Kurt J. Olson, PLLC
3737 Glenwood Ave., Suite 100
Raleigh, NC 27612
919-573-6172
919-573-6173 (fax)
kurt.j.olson@gmail.com
Attorney for New Southern Rocky Mount, Inc.