Commonwealth v. ScaramuzzinoCommonwealth v. Scaramuzzino
- Reporters:
- , ,
- Before:
- Nix
Opinion by
Mr. Justice Nix,Appellant, Samuel Scaramuzzino, was tried by a jury and found guilty of the first degree murder of Mrs. Kathleen Gensler. Following the denial of post-trial motions a sentence of life imprisonment was imposed. This appeal followed.
During the course of the trial the Commonwealth was permitted to introduce, over defense counsel’s timely objection, fourteen color slides in support of the pathologist’s testimony as to the cause of death. Appellant contends that despite cautionary instructions 1 the trial judge abused his discretion in allowing these exhibits. We agree. In view of our disposition of this issue we need not consider the other points of error set forth in appellant’s brief.
The slides in issue involved three photographs of the heart removed from the body of the deceased; five portrayed the wounded portions of the nude torso emphasizing, because of the color, the dried blood, including a side view of the torso with glass rods protruding from
At the outset it should be noted that the practice of admitting photographs of the body of the deceased, unless they have essential evidentiary value, is condemned. Commonwealth v. Peyton, 360 Pa. 441, 450, 62 A. 2d 37, 41 (1948). See also, Commonwealth v. Dankel, 450 Pa. 437, 441, 301 A. 2d 365, 367 (1973). Our law is well-settled that the admission of such evidence is a matter within the discretion of the trial judge and, absent an abuse of discretion, there is no reversible error. Commonwealth v. Woods, 454 Pa. 250, 252, 311 A. 2d 582, 583 (1973) citing Commonwealth v. Dickerson, 406 Pa. 102, 176 A. 2d 421 (1962).
“The proper test to be applied by a trial court in determining the admissibility of photographs in homicide cases is whether or not the photographs are of such essential evidentiary value that their need clearly outweighs the likelihood of inflaming the minds and passions of the jurors.” Commonwealth v. Powell, 428 Pa. 275, 278-79, 241 A. 2d 119, 121 (1968). Such photographs will not be excluded merely because they are horrid or gruesome, Commonwealth v. Snyder, 408 Pa. 253, 257, 182 A. 2d 495, 496 (1962), but the more inflammatory the photograph the greater the need to establish the essential evidentiary value.
Never before have we been faced with the admission of so many slides, unquestionably repetitive, and viewed for so long a period of time.
2
In support of its claim
While we do not condemn the use of photographs to aid the fact-finder in understanding a witness’ testimony, Commonwealth v. Snyder, supra at 256, 182 A. 2d at 496, they should not be resorted to where the witness can clearly convey the facts to the jury without their use. These slides were simply cumulative to the pathologist’s testimony as to the cause, position, number, and severity of the wounds. In Powell we said “assuming [the relevance of the photographs] with respect to appellant’s intent to commit grievous bodily harm, nowhere is it illustrated to our satisfaction that the pathologist could not have adequately and effectively testified without the use of these photographs.” Commonwealth v. Powell, supra at 279, 241 A. 2d at 121.
In addition, the defense did not vigorously contest the testimony as to the nature of the wounds, the cause of death, or that a deadly weapon was used on a vital part of the body. See
Commonwealth v. Woods, supra
at 255, 311 A. 2d at 584 where we said: “Even assuming the relevancy of these photographs, . . . appellant did not . . . deny the act of . . . burning his wife’s body . . . and allowing the photographs of the incinerated body to go to the jury could only have served to inflame their minds and prejudice them against him.” Compare,
Commonwealth v. Smalls,
note 2
supra,
and
Commonwealth v. Dickerson,
note 2,
supra.
Thus, under the
Judgment of sentence reversed and a new trial ordered.
Mr. Justice Pomeroy concurs in the result.
Notes
The judge charged as follows: “. . . there are a number of photographs and items of evidence that have been received in this case. They have been received for the purpose of assisting you in deciding the facts and what happened. You are not permitted to let them inflame your passions or cause you to be prejudiced or to divert your attention from your true duties; and that is, determine the truth. That is what we are here for. We are not to be prejudiced or sympathetic, inflamed by matters such as this. Don‘t permit these exhibits to do that to you.”
Commonwealth v. Ross,
452 Pa. 500, 307 A. 2d 898 (1973);
Commonwealth v. Sullivan,
450 Pa. 273, 299 A. 2d 608 (1973); and
Commonwealth v. Robinson,
433 Pa. 88, 249 A. 2d 536 (1969); inv
The Commonwealth does not contend that the slides were necessary to allow the jury to draw the inference of specific intent necessary for first degree murder from the use of a deadly weapon on a vital part of the body.
Although this argument was not addressed in the Commonwealth’s brief, we further find that the presence of cautionary instructions, relevant to the question of resulting prejudice, does not cure the error here. Commonwealth v. Powell, supra; cf. Commonwealth v. Biebighauser, note 2 supra at n. 4.