Commonwealth v. OrsinoCommonwealth v. Orsino
- Reporters:
- , ,
- Before:
- Rhodes
Opinion by
Rhodes, P. J.,This is an appeal by John Orsino from the order of the Court of Oyer and Terminer and General Jail Delivery and the Court of Quarter Sessions of Philadelphia County dismissing his petition for writ of error coram nobis and remanding him to the Eastern State Penitentiary. 1
On July 28, 1958, appellant pleaded guilty to fourteen bills of indictment charging, inter alia, rape of a thirteen-year-old girl, corrupting the morals of a minor, indecent assault, armed robbery, assault and battery with intent to murder, commission of a crime of violence while armed with a firearm, operating an automobile without consent of the owner, and conspiracy. The rape was committed on September 1, 1953. The robberies took place on February 5 and 8, 1958, and May 8, 1958. Appellant, with an accomplice, forced drivers of three different trucks making coin collections to lie on the floor while the trucks were driven to prearranged destinations. The trucks involved were used in making collections; one from cigarette vending machines, and two from coin receptacles in public telephone booths. Cigarettes and money totaling $1,800 were taken from the vending machine company truck and $3,000 from one telephone company truck. Three detectives, who were’ notified by radio, joined in pursuit of the telephone company’ truck in the robbery of May 8, 1958. One detective pursued appellant who had abandoned the truck. Shots were exchanged; the de
On September 9, 1958, appellant, then thirty-one years of age, was brought before the court for sentence; he was lying on a stretcher. His prior record included two sentences to the Pennsylvania Industrial School at Camp Hill for robbery and burglary, respectively. Exhaustive pre-sentence investigation was made by the probation officer of the court of quarter sessions. The medical report from the Philadelphia General Hospital where appellant was confined showed that appellant was unable to move his trunk and lower extremities as the result of a transection of the spinal cord causing complete and permanent paralysis below the level of the injury. With physical therapy and nursing care it was believed he would be able to get about on a wheel chair. Dr. John Shearer, Director of the Eastern Diagnostic and Classification Center of the Eastern State Penitentiary stated that that institution would be able to handle such a case, but it was preferable that appellant be admitted to a veterans’ hospital. A letter from the authorities of the Philadelphia office of the Veterans Administration Hospital indicated appellant would be eligible for special care there if he were placed on probation and sentence suspended. Accordingly, the sentence was suspended and appellant placed on probation for thirty years. It was ordered that he remain in the Philadelphia General Hospital pending possible transfer to a Veterans Administration Hospital.
On November 24, 1959, a hearing was held in appellant’s presence, as a result of which his probation was revoked and he was sentenced to imprisonment in the Eastern State Penitentiary for terms totaling not less than twelve years nor more than thirty-six years. At this hearing appellant’s wife testified that he became moré demanding on her visits to him at the Philade].
On June 27, 1961, appellant’s attorney filed a petition for writ of error coram nobis in the Court of Oyer and Terminer and General Jail Delivery, and the Court of Quarter Sessions of Philadelphia County. In the petition it was alleged that appellant’s wife’ gave false testimony against him at the hearing on November 24, 1959, at which his probation was revoked and sentence imposed; that his wife gave birth to two children, one on May 9, 1960, and the other on April 20, 1961, listing
On June 27, 1961, the court ordered that a writ of error coram nobis issue and that a hearing be held to supplement the record and inform the conscience of the court. The hearing on appellant’s petition for writ of error coram nobis was held before President Judge Francis Shunk Brown, Jr., on July 11, 1961. Appeldant’s sister testified to facts showing that appellant’s wife and her brother-in-law lived together at the time a child was born to the wife on May 9, 1960. Contradicting the wife’s testimony of November 24, 1959, appellant’s brother testified that appellant did not strike his wife on the hospital visit in August, 1959. Appellant’s mother also testified she was present and saw no evidence that he struck his wife in August, 1959. Appellant stated he was unaware that his wife was pregnant when she testified against him on November 24, 1959. An assistant district attorney, who represented the Commonwealth at all the hearings involving appellant, stated he was unaware of the wife’s pregnancy on November 24,1959, and admitted that this fact, if true, would in all probability affect the credibility of the wife and her motives in testifying on November 24, 1959, to violent conduct by her husband in the hospital. A probation officer testified appellant’s wife readily admitted that the father of the child born on May 9, 1960, was her brother-in-law, Thomas Sylvester, and that she was seeking a divorce from appellant.
Dr. Martucci testified that, following the healing of the leg fracture and appellant’s discharge from the
At the conclusion of the hearing on July 11, 1961, the writ was refused and appellant remanded to the Eastern State Penitentiary. In so doing, President Judge Brown stated: “It is apparent that no matters of fact were brought before the court at the hearing on the petition for the writ which, if known at the time sentence was imposed, would have prevented such judgment. While the testimony at this hearing about John Orsino’s striking his wife and her motives for charging him with violation of probation may seriously affect the credibility of her testimony against him, there was other evidence presented at the earlier hearing when he was sentenced to justify the revocation of his probation and the imposition of sentence. Thus, the writ of coram nobis was not applicable to the facts of this case.
“Furthermore, when sentence was suspended and defendant John Orsino was placed on probation, it was ordered that he remain in the Philadelphia General Hospital pending his transfer to a Veterans Administration Hospital. The latter part of the order contemplated that he was not to be released from custody until he was removed and actually admitted to a hospital of the Veterans Administration. Indeed, this might Well be regarded ás a condition of his probation, for,
“Therefore, defendant John Orsino was not discharged from prison but remanded to the Eastern State Penitentiary.”
The appeal to this Court was taken on August 25, 1961.
The order of the court must be affirmed. Initially, the present appeal might well be quashed because of a serious violation of Rule 34 of this Court relating to appellant’s statement of the questions involved on appeal. Cf. Epstein v. Epstein, 93 Pa. Superior Ct. 398; Creachen v. Bromley Brothers Carpet Company, 214 Pa. 15, 17, 63 A. 195. Rule 34 reads as follows: “The statement of the questions involved must state the question or questions in the briefest and most general terms, without names, dates, amounts or particulars of any kind. It should not ordinarily exceed fifteen lines, must never exceed one page, and must always be printed on the first page of the Brief, without any other matter appearing thereon. This rule is to be considered in the highest degree mandatory, admitting of no exception; ordinarily no point will be considered which is not set forth in the statement of questions involved or suggested thereby.” Appellant’s statement of questions involved covers three pages and violates Rule 34 in other important respects.
The purpose of the writ of error coram nobis is to correct errors of fact only, and its function “ ‘is to bring before the court rendering the judgment matters of fact which, if known at the time the judgment was
However, a hearing was held on the petition, and it was properly ruled that appellant was not entitled to the relief prayed for. Appellant’s brief argumentatively refuses to accept this ruling as a fact.
The sentencing of a defendant is a matter committed to the sound discretion of the trial judge.
Com. ex rel. Lockhart v. Myers,
193 Pa. Superior Ct. 531, 165 A. 2d 400. The court in sentencing may receive any relevant information which will enable it to exercise its discretion in determining the proper sentence or penalty. Subject to the limitations prescribed by statute the
In this case, instead of merely sentencing appellant to prison and prison hospitalization, the court placed him on probation in order that he might receive the benefit of the best possible medical care so as to enhance his chances of at least partial recovery. Later, when it developed that appellant was not entitled to care in a Veterans Administration Hospital, and when there was evidence that appellant’s conduct was such as to constitute a violation of his probation, it was permissible for the court to revoke his probation and impose a sentence. See Com. v. Meyer, 169 Pa. Superior Ct. 40, 82 A. 2d 298. We think the court exercised its discretion fairly to both society and appellant.
Whether we treat appellant’s petition as one seeking coram nobis or habeas corpus, no error is shown in the action of the court in any of the proceedings comprising appellant’s pleas of guilty, probation, and sentence, and, after hearing thereon, refusing appellant’s petition for writ of error coram nobis.
The order is affirmed.
Notes
Now State Correctional Institution at Philadelphia. See Act of October 22, 1959, P. L. 1356,