Commonwealth v. GonzalesCommonwealth v. Gonzales
- Reporters:
- , ,
- Before:
- Smith
A jury convicted the defendant on indictments charging him with unlawful possession of heroin with intent to distribute (
On appeal, the defendant claims that (1) the evidence was insufficient to permit a finding that the defendant violated the school zone statute because the Commonwealth made no
1.
The evidence concerning the alleged violation of the school zone statute.
“Any person who violates the provisions of section thirty-two, thirty-two A, thirty-two B, thirty-two C, thirty-two D, thirty-two E, thirty-two F or thirty-two I while in or on, or within one thousand feet of the real property comprising a public or private elementary, vocational, or secondary school whether or not in session shall be punished by [penalties as specified] . . . .”
The Commonwealth presented evidence that on January 27, 1990, while executing a search warrant, the police searched the defendant and found ten glassine packets containing heroin. The distance between the place where the defendant was arrested and a nearby school was 606 feet. That school was identified as “Worcester Academy.” There was no evidence that the school was an “elementary, vocational, or secondary school.”
The defendant filed a motion for a required finding of not guilty. Although in his motion the defendant did not argue that the school was not adequately defined,
The language of the statute is unequivocal and, therefore, “the Legislature must be presumed to have intended to limit
Here, testimony only as to the name of the school (“Worcester Academy”) does not give any indication whether the school falls within one of the statutory categories and, therefore, does not satisfy the Commonwealth’s burden of proving this element beyond a reasonable doubt. Commonwealth v. Latimore, 378 Mass. 671, 676-678 (1979). Accordingly, the defendant’s conviction on the school zone charge is reversed, and judgment is to be entered for the defendant.
2.
The sufficiency of the evidence concerning the possession with intent to distribute indictment.
The defendant argues that the judge erred in denying his motion for a re
“Intent is a factual matter that may be proved by circumstantial evidence.” Commonwealth v. LaPerle, 19 Mass. App. Ct. 424, 427 (1985). The amount of heroin (.32 grams) seized by the police was small. The fact that the amount of drugs seized was small does not, by itself, require a finding of not guilty to so much of the indictment as states “intent to distribute.” A dealer’s inventory of drugs may have been reduced before his arrest to a small amount by a number of sales. Therefore, we examine other evidence introduced by the Commonwealth in regard to the indictment.
The drugs that were seized were in ten glassine packets held together by an elastic band. Such packaging was considered to be a bundle which, according to the testimony, was consistent with distribution rather than personal use. See Commonwealth v. Davis, 376 Mass. 777, 779, 788 (1978), which held that the form of packaging is a recognized factor in the question of intent to distribute. According to expert testimony, a bundle would bring approximately $180 to $200 when sold. Further, each bag had a “scorpion” mark which was indicative of an individual dealer’s brand name. The defendant was arrested in an area of high drug activity. Finally, the defendant, although unemployed, in addition to the heroin, had $167 in loose currency in his pocket when arrested. Although the decision whether to allow or deny the defendant’s motion for a required finding of not guilty was a close one, we think that the combination of factors enumerated above made it a proper case for submission to the jury.
The judgment on the indictment charging the defendant with a violation of
So ordered.
Notes
Our holding that the Commonwealth must establish the type of school does not, we think, set up a heavy burden for the prosecution to bear. The arresting officer or any other witness may testify that the school in question is an elementary, vocational, or secondary school if he or she has personal knowledge of that fact. A principal of the school, an employee of the school, or anyone associated with the school may testify as to the type of school. Of course, the parties may stipulate to that fact..
Whether a particular school is an elementary, vocational, or secondary school does not seem to us to be a proper subject of judicial notice at the trial level as a matter of common knowledge. See Commonwealth v. Green, 408 Mass. 48, 50 & n.2 (1990).
Nor does the term “academy” necessarily signify an elementary, vocational, or secondary school. See