222 Pa. 304 | Pa. | 1908
The first assignment of error is to the overruling of the
The second assignment is that the evidence does not warrant a conviction of murder of the first degree. This assignment seems to be founded on the provision of the Act of February 15, 1870, P. L. 15, requiring the Supreme Court to review the law and the evidence and “to determine whether the ingredients necessary to constitute murder in the first degree shall have been proved to exist.” But this review is limited to the inquiry whether competent evidence has been given which if believed will sustain the conviction. Whether it shall be believed or not is exclusively for the jury: Com. v. Morrison, 193 Pa. 613.
The objection on which the assignment is based in the present case is that the witness furnishing the testimony which established the degree of the crime was not worthy of belief. But the credibility was for the jury and is not within our province.
Judgment affirmed and record remitted for purpose of execution.