Commonwealth v. FlynnCommonwealth v. Flynn
- Reporters:
- Before:
- Donahue
The defendant was tried and found guilty by a jury on an indictment which charged that he “did steal one chow dog of the value of one hundred dollars . . . of the property” of one Belzarine “against the peace of the Commonwealth . . . and contrary to the form of the statute in such case made and provided.” The defendant excepted to the ruling by the trial judge that *137the fact that the dog was not licensed was of no consequence and immaterial and to the refusal of the judge to direct a verdict of not guilty. It is not here argued by the defendant that the evidence did not warrant a conviction if, in this Commonwealth, it is a crime to steal an unlicensed dog, and the entire argument before us was directed to that question.
At common law while an action of trover or trespass would lie for the wrongful taking of a dog, that animal was held not to be the subject of larceny. See Blair v. Forehand, 100 Mass. 136, 140. Various reasons were given from time to time for the common law rule, among them “the baseness of their nature,” 3 Coke Inst. 109; because (at a time when the larceny of property of trifling value was punishable by death) “They ought not to be things of a base nature, as dogs, cats, bears, foxes, monkeys, ferrets, and the like, which, howsoever they may be valued by the owner, shall never be so highly regarded by the law, that for their sakes a man shall die; as he may for stealing a hawk . . . in respect of that very high value which was formerly set upon that bird,” 1 Hawk. P. C. c. 19, § 36; because dogs are kept for whim and pleasure and are unfit for food and as a class have no intrinsic value, 4 Bl. Com. 236; and because “even in a state of domestication, [they] never wholly lose their wild natures and destructive instincts.” Blair v. Forehand, supra. The common law rule has been abrogated by statutes in England beginning with St. 10 Geo. III, c. 18, “An Act for preventing the stealing of Dogs.” In this country reasons given for the common law rule have generally not been considered adequate under existing conditions to justify its retention and in many States it is a crime to steal a dog. In some States this has been accomplished by statutes specifically declaring a dog to be the subject of larceny. See Graham v. Smith, 100 Ga. 434; Johnson v. McConnell, 80. Cal. 545. In many jurisdictions the result has been reached by the interpretation of words in larceny statutes stating in general terms the subjects of larceny. The word “chattels” in such a statute has been held to include *138a dog, Hamby v. Samson, 105 Iowa, 112, Commonwealth v. Hazelwood, 84 Ky. 681, Mullaly v. People, 86 N. Y. 365, State v. Brown, 9 Baxt. (Tenn.) 53, In re Burkell, 2 Alaska, 108, as have the words “corporeal personal property,” Hurley v. State, 30 Tex. App. 333, “personal property or valuable thing,” Harrington v. Miles, 11 Kans. 480, “property” and “personal goods,” State v. Brown, 9 Baxt. (Tenn.) 53, 56. In some States the common law rule was adhered to. Findlay v. Bear, 8 S. & R. 571. State v. Lymus, 26 Ohio St. 400. State v. Holder, 81 N. C. 527. Ward v. State, 48 Ala. 161. In Blankenship v. Commonwealth, 133 Va. 638, the opinion quotes a statement from 17 R. C. L. 32 to the effect that while at strict common law the words “goods and chattels” would not include dogs, courts have declined to follow that rule and have held that the common understanding of the meaning of such words would be resorted to and that in such view dogs are clearly chattels. The opinion goes on to say that the court would be inclined to follow that conclusion if the question were an open one in Virginia and if the court did not feel that such course would contravene the established statutory policy in that State as to dogs.
The trial of the present case seems to have proceeded on the theory that the defendant was indicted under a statute of this Commonwealth which provides that “Whoever, without the consent of the owner and with a felonious intent, takes any domesticated animal, or a beast or bird which is ordinarily kept in confinement and is not the subject of larceny at common law, shall be guilty of larceny.”
The statute here to be interpreted employs the broad term “any domesticated animal.” (Compare Osborn v. Lenox, 2 Allen, 207, 209.) It seems to us that the words taken in their ordinary and literal sense include dogs and indicate an intention of the Legislature in passing the act to include any dog as the subject of larceny. But in addition to the literal meaning of words, before the completion of the process of interpretation of a legislative enactment, consideration should be given to the system of law of which it is a part and to previous judicial decisions and statutes of the Commonwealth dealing with the same general subject. Commonwealth v. S. S. Kresge Co. 267 Mass. 145, 148. Armburg v. Boston & Maine Railroad, 276 Mass. 418, 426.
During the last two hundred years Legislatures in this Commonwealth have from time to time passed, repealed, and amended many statutes declaring under what circumstances dogs may lawfully be killed without redress to their owner, and regulating the keeping, the collaring and the licensing of dogs. The primary object of these statutes has not been to confer a benefit on individuals or to give them rights or immunities with reference to another man’s dog. Their general purpose has been the protection of the public from injury or damage done by dogs. Cummings v. Perham, 1 Met. 555. Blair v. Forehand, 100 Mass. 136. Commonwealth v. Brahany, 123 Mass. 245. Morewood v. Wakefield, 133 Mass. 240. Nesbett v. Wilbur, 177 Mass. 200. See Carrington v. Worcester Consolidated Street Railway, 222 Mass. 119, 120; Andrews v. Jordan Marsh Co. 283 Mass. 158, 162. The statutes recognize some property rights of ownership in a dog; they make constant reference to the “owner” of a dog. They manifest no design that an owner who does not comply with their provisions by that very fact has no rights which the law will protect.
The fact that the owner of a dog has not complied with statutory provisions as to its keeping gives no right to *141another to take it away and keep it as his own. Cummings v. Perham, supra. See Bond v. Commonwealth, 236 Ky. 472, 475; Ewings v. Walker, 9 Gray, 95. A person who under the statutes is authorized to kill an unlicensed dog, or a police officer who has a warrant for such killing issued in accordance with the statutes, acts without justification and incurs liability to its owner if he commits a trespass in doing the authorized act. Cozzens v. Nason, 109 Mass. 275. Bishop v. Fahay, 15 Gray, 61. While a person acting pursuant to statutory provisions may kill the unlicensed dog of another with impunity (Morewood v. Wakefield, 133 Mass. 240), if his dog in his absence kills the unlicensed, uncollared dog of another on the highway he is liable in damages to its owner. Baer v. Tyler, 261 Mass. 138. An unlicensed dog when on a highway is not a trespasser and outlaw and one who there negligently kills such a dog incurs a legal liability to its owner. Lacker v. Strauss, 226 Mass. 579. In the statutes in this Commonwealth pertaining to dogs we find nothing indicative of a legislative policy or purpose which prevents giving to the words “any domesticated animal” in the statute here construed their literal meaning and an interpretation including dogs licensed and unlicensed.
Exceptions overruled.