Commonwealth v. DixonCommonwealth v. Dixon
- Reporters:
- , ,
- Before:
- Fine
The issue in this case is whether assault and battery is a lesser included offense within
•Assault and battery is not a lesser included offense within attempted murder by strangulation unless assault and battery requires proof of no facts additional to those required to prove attempted murder by strangulation. See
An assault and battery is the intentional, unprivileged, unjustified touching of another with such violence that bodily harm is likely to result. See
Commonwealth
v.
Burke,
390 Mass. 480, 482-483 (1983). The offensive touching may be direct, as by striking another, or it may be indirect, as by setting in motion some force or instrumentality with the intent to cause injury. See
Commonwealth
v.
Stratton,
114
One may be found guilty of attempted murder either under the general attempt statute,
To make the determination whether proof of strangulation is required, we must first determine whether the words “poisoning, drowning or strangling” in the statute modify the word “attempts” or whether they modify the word “murder.”
1
If, as the Commonwealth suggests, those words modify “attempts,” a defendant could be convicted, assuming the requisite intent, only if he engaged in the act of poisoning, drowning, or strangling. If, on the other hand, those words modify “murder,” the defendant could be convicted under the statute if he committed an overt act towards the commission of the murder, but the overt act could be something other than actually drowning, poisoning, or strangling.
2
We
The question remains whether it would be possible for attempted murder by strangulation to be committed without the use of actual physical force on the person of another, direct or indirect, such as to constitute an assault and battery. Certainly, strangling or choking, manually or by ligature, usually constitutes the overt act required for attempted murder by strangulation. See
Commonwealth
v.
Grogan,
11 Mass. App. Ct. 684, 686-687 (1981);
Commonwealth
v.
Beattie,
29 Mass. App. Ct. at 358. Admittedly, it is very dif
Simple assault, however, is a lesser included offense within attempted murder by strangulation. An assault is “an attempt (or offer) to do bodily harm to another by force or violence; or simply, an attempt to commit a battery.” Commonwealth v. Slaney, 345 Mass. 135, 138 (1962). See Commonwealth v. Burke, 390 Mass, at 482. Neither fear nor apprehension of harm is an essential ingredient of the crime, see Commonwealth v. Slaney, 345 Mass, at 139, nor is physical touching. Commission of an overt act intended to cause death by strangulation which comes very close to accomplishment would necessarily be an attempt to commit a battery. As simple assault is also a lesser included offense within assault and battery, the crime of which the jury convicted the defendant, the portion of the guilty verdict which found simple assault may stand.
Accordingly, the judgment of conviction of assault and battery is vacated, and judgment of conviction of assault
So ordered.
Notes
“Whoever attempts to commit murder by poisoning, drowning or strangling another person, or by any means not constituting an assault with intent to commit murder, shall be punished . . . .”
By definition, the words “poisoning,” “drowning,” and “strangling” usually, but not always, refer to acts that result in death. The American Heritage Dictionary of the English Language 1273 (3d ed. 1992), defines the verb to strangle as “La. To kill by squeezing the throat so as to choke or suffocate; throttle, b. To cut off the oxygen supply of; smother.”
One possible example would be a case in which a perpetrator, intending to cause a person’s death, sneaked up behind the person with a garotting cord and, just as the perpetrator reached his arms over the person’s head, someone burst into the room and interrupted the attempt.