Commonwealth v. CowieCommonwealth v. Cowie
- Reporters:
- , ,
- Before:
- Lynch
The defendant appeals from the denial of his motion pursuant to
A description of the procedural history of this case is necessary to a full understanding of the issue before us. On December 19, 1983, the defendant was convicted on two indictments charging armed assault with intent to kill, two indictments charging assault and battery by means of a dangerous weapon, and one indictment charging unlawfully carrying a firearm. No action 1 was taken to appeal from the convictions until August, 1985, when the defendant filed a pro se motion in the Supreme Judicial Court for the county of Suffolk seeking to have his appellate rights reinstated. The defendant alleged that, despite his desire to appeal from his convictions, no appeal was taken because of ineffective assistance of trial counsel.
The trial judge received a copy of the defendant’s pro se motion and purported to enlarge the time period for prosecuting an appeal. Although the judge lacked authority to enlarge the filing period,
2
the defendant now represented by counsel filed a notice of appeal which was entered in the Appeals Court. The defendant then moved to stay the action in the Appeals Court until a single justice of this court decided the defendant’s pro se motion. The defendant also filed a petition under
The single justice denied relief noting that the defendant had available the postconviction remedies contained in
The defendant then filed in the Superior Court a motion pursuant to rule 30 (a), requesting “an order vacating, and then reimposing, his sentences” in order to “allow [the defendant] to file a timely notice of appeal.” The defendant alleged that his trial counsel failed to perfect his appeal, even though requested to do so, and thus deprived him of due process of law and effective assistance of counsel.
The trial judge denied the motion under rule 30 (a) on the ground that the original sentences were not illegal; it is the denial of this motion that forms the basis of this appeal.
4
The judge offered to entertain a motion for new trial pursuant to
In Evitts v. Lucey, 469 U.S. 387, 391-392 (1985), the United States Supreme Court addressed the issue whether a dismissal of a defendant’s appeal for noncompliance with a procedural rule due to counsel’s ineffective assistance violated the due process clause of the Fourteenth Amendment to the United States Constitution. 7 The Court held that in these circumstances due process required that the defendant either be retried or his appeal be reinstated. Id. at 390-391, 396-397. The Court noted, however, there would be no violation of due process if the State provided an adequate remedy for the loss of a direct appeal. 8 Id. at 396-397.
Therefore, postconviction attack on the judgment through a motion under rule 30 (b) fully accords with due process as a
The order denying the defendant’s motion under
So ordered.
Notes
On February 29, 1984, the defendant filed a motion to revoke and revise his sentences, which was denied on April 20, 1984. Also, the Appellate Division of the Superior Court denied the defendant’s appeal from his sentences on June 27, 1984.
See Mass. R. A. P. 4 (b) and (c), as appearing in 378 Mass. 924 (1979); Commonwealth v. Lopes, 21 Mass. App. Ct. 11, 16 (1985); Commonwealth v. Boutwell, 21 Mass. App. Ct. 201, 205 (1985).
The judge denied the defendant’s request for a finding of fact and ruling of law on the question whether the defendant had been afforded effective assistance of counsel and denied the defendant’s motion for reconsideration.
Because we find the defendant is not without an adequate remedy we need not reach the propriety of the denial of the defendant’s motion under rule 30 (a) nor the merits of his appeal.
Although the defendant refers to art. 12, he does not develop an independent argument on that provision nor do the cases cited rest on the Massachusetts Declaration of Rights. Therefore, we do not reach that question. Mass. R. A. P. 16 (a) (4), as amended, 367 Mass. 919 (1975). Commonwealth v. McDonough, 400 Mass. 639, 647 n.12 (1987).
In Evitts, there was no dispute that the defendant received ineffective assistance of counsel. Evitts v. Lucey, supra at 392. Here, the parties’ stipulation simply covers what the defense counsel’s testimony would be. The Commonwealth has not stipulated that the trial counsel’s actions constituted ineffective assistance. We express no opinion on whether there was in fact ineffective assistance here. See Commonwealth v. Porter, 9 Mass. App. Ct. 908 (1980).
Under Mass. R. A. P. 4 (b), the defendant must file a notice of appeal within thirty days of the verdict or imposition of sentence. Upon a showing of “excusable neglect” the lower court may extend the time for filing for an additional thirty days. Mass. R. A. P. 4 (c). Under Mass. R. A. P. 14 (b), as appearing in 378 Mass. 924 (1979), an appellate court or a single justice thereof may for good cause enlarge the time for filing for up to one year, but not beyond one year from the date of verdict or sentence. See Miranda v. Commonwealth, 392 Mass. 420, 421-422 (1984). These rules which impose a limitation on the time allowable for pursuing an appeal are unquestionably reasonable in light of the Commonwealth’s legitimate interest in having judgments become final. Commonwealth v. Deeran, 397 Mass. 136, 142 (1986). Reddick v. Commonwealth, 381 Mass. 398, 403 (1980).
As we have noted in reviewing a judge’s exercise of discretion in ruling on a rule 30 (b) motion, if “the original trial was infected with prejudicial constitutional error the judge has no discretion to deny a new trial.” Commonwealth v. Doherty, 394 Mass. 341, 346 (1985), quoting Earl v. Commonwealth, 356 Mass. 181, 184 (1969). See Commonwealth v. Sullivan, 385 Mass. 497, 503 (1982); Commonwealth v. Stewart, 383 Mass. 253, 257 (1981). But see Commonwealth v. Miranda, 22 Mass. App. Ct. 10, 15-19 (1986).