Commonwealth v. CalcagnoCommonwealth v. Calcagno
- Reporters:
- , ,
- Before:
- Warner
The defendant was convicted after trial before a District Court jury of six of indecent assault and battery on a child over the age of fourteen. On appeal, he argues that (1) the court erroneously admitted evidence of
The Commonwealth produced evidence of the following. The defendant, the victim’s mother’s boyfriend, had been a daily visitor to the victim’s home since she was six or seven years old. He was charged with a single act of sexual abuse, which occurred in November, 1986, when the victim was seventeen years old. At that time, he entered the victim’s bedroom while she was sleeping and fondled her pubic area. She told him that she was tired and wanted to go to sleep. He continued for several minutes before stopping. The Commonwealth’s case was based on the victim’s testimony and the testimony of four fresh complaint witnesses.
The defendant did not call any witnesses. He relied on cross-examination to show that the victim had a poor relationship with her mother and to argue that for this reason she had fabricated the accusations of sexual abuse.
1. Over the defendant’s objection, the victim was permitted to testify that the defendant had sexually abused her in the past. She testified in detail about two specific instances, one occurring in the defendant’s car when she was sixteen years old and the other occurring in her home approximately four months before the incident at issue. She further testified that the defendant had been sexually abusing her since she was nine years old and that he had “always” told her not to tell anyone about it or they would both get into trouble.
“It is well settled that the prosecution may not introduce evidence that a defendant previously has misbehaved, indict-ably or not, for the purposes of showing his bad character or propensity to commit the crime charged, but such evidence may be admissible if relevant for some other purpose.”
Commonwealth
v.
Helfant,
398 Mass. 214, 224 (1986), and cases cited. Among the purposes for which the evidence may be introduced are to show a pattern of conduct, intent, and the relationship between a defendant and a victim.
Id.
at 224-225. See
Commonwealth
v.
Mamay,
407 Mass. 412, 417-418 (1990). Evidence of other acts of illicit sexual activity be
The defendant argues that the undue prejudice of the testimony concerning acts that occurred when the victim was nine years old outweighed its probative value, especially because these events were too remote in time. “There is no bright-line test for determining temporal remoteness of evidence of prior misconduct. Where the prior misconduct is merely one instance in a continuing course of related events, the allowable time period is greater. Where the logical relationship between the charged and uncharged offenses is more attenuated, a time span of fifteen minutes may be too much.”
Commonwealth
v.
Helfant, supra
at 228 n.13, and cases cited (citations omitted). In
Helfant,
testimony concerning sexual acts between the defendant and other victims which occurred three years apart was held admissible to show the defendant’s plan, scheme, or state of mind because the conduct was nearly identical to the offense charged.
Id.
at 224-229. See
Commonwealth
v.
Machado,
339 Mass. 713, 714-715 (1959) (evidence that the defendant and victim had sexual relations six months after the date of the statutory rape charged was admissible as a “later event[] of a like nature”).
2. During closing argument, the prosecutor commented on the defendant’s failure to call the victim’s mother as a witness.
1
The defendant objected, and the judge immediately ordered the comment struck. After closing arguments were
The remark was improper. “[T]he rule of law relevant here runs thus. Where a party has knowledge of a person who can be located and brought forward, who is friendly to, or at least not hostilely disposed toward, the party, and who can be expected to give testimony of distinct importance to the case, the party would naturally offer that person as a witness. If, then, without explanation, he does not do so, the jury may, if they think reasonable in the circumstances, infer that that person, had he been called, would have given testimony unfavorable to the party.” Commonwealth v. Schatvet, 23 Mass. App. Ct. 130, 134 (1986). Commonwealth v. Resendes, 30 Mass. App. Ct. 430, 432 (1991). “[Bjefore any comment is made, the trial judge must rule, as matter of law, that there is a sufficient foundation for such inference in the record. Therefore, if counsel plans to argue to the jury that an inference may be drawn against the opposing party for failure to call a witness, the proper practice is first to obtain the permission of the trial judge to do so. . . .” Commonwealth v. Vasquez, 27 Mass. App. Ct. 655, 658 (1989) (citations omitted). See Commonwealth v. Schatvet, supra at 135; Commonwealth v. Sena, 29 Mass. App. Ct. 463, 467 (1990).
The prosecutor did not lay an adequate foundation, nor did she obtain permission from the judge, for her reference to the defendant’s failure to call the the victim’s mother as a witness. In fact, the record gives no indication that her testimony would have been other than cumulative of the testimony presented, which showed that she and her daughter did not get along well. The victim, along with other prosecution witnesses, testified that she and her mother had a tense relationship, and that they argued about curfews, the victim’s association with girlfriends and boys, and chores. The victim testified that she moved to her father’s home for several months in early 1986 because she had a fight with her mother. She again left home after the incident charged because, having informed her mother about the abuse, she felt
In the circumstances, however, the prosecutor’s improper comment could not have harmed the defendant. It implied only that the victim’s mother might have testified that the victim was not the discipline problem the defendant had attempted to portray: “If that young woman was nearly as bad at dating boys, and terrible discipline problems, and all that stuff, why didn’t they call her.” See note 1, supra. Had the jury been influenced by the remark, it would not have undermined the defendant’s strategy. The defendant relied on evidence of the tense relationship between the victim and her mother to argue that the victim had fabricated her accusations. Whether she was actually a discipline problem was irrelevant to the success of that strategy. Furthermore, the judge immediately had the prosecutor’s reference to the absent witness struck. He carefully instructed the jury that closing arguments are not evidence, that the defendant is presumed innocent, that he need not testify or call witnesses, and that the burden of proof never shifts from the Commonwealth. “The jury are presumed to follow the judge’s instruction[s].” Commonwealth v. Pope, 406 Mass. 581, 588 (1990).
For the first time on appeal,-the defendant argues that the prosecutor’s statement that the victim’s mother was “staring her daughter down” and that she was nearly sitting in the defendant’s lap, attempting to convey her belief in his innocence, see note 1, supra, was based on facts not in evidence
Finally, the defendant objected to the prosecutor’s reference, in closing argument, to the victim’s difficulty in testifying about sexual abuse, and the consequent likelihood that her testimony was not a fabrication. The remark was made in the context of a lengthy argument concerning the credibility of the victim and was based on facts in evidence. The prosecutor referred to the victim’s statement that it had been difficult for her to discuss the subject with a male police officer, adverted to her demeanor as she gave that testimony, and asked the jury to infer that she had no motivation to lie. “It is not improper to make a factually based argument that, due to the demeanor, disclosed circumstances, and appearance of a witness, a particular witness should be believed or disbelieved.” Commonwealth v. Kozec, supra at 521. Compare Commonwealth v. McLeod, 30 Mass. App. Ct. 536 (1991). There was no error.
Judgment affirmed.
Notes
The prosecutor stated: “If that young woman [the victim] was nearly as bad at dating boys, and terrible discipline problems, and all that stuff, why didn’t they call her [the mother]. She’s sitting there through this whole trial and every word, staring her daughter down. Sitting in his [the defendant’s] lap, practically, throughout this trial, hoping that you would (inaudible) a message that if she believes him, and she’s sitting with him, then you (inaudible).”
In her opening statement, the prosecutor noted that the victim’s mother was present in the courtroom. During direct examination of the victim, the prosecutor again established that the victim’s mother was present.