Commonwealth v. an UnnamedCommonwealth v. an Unnamed
- Reporters:
- , ,
- Before:
- Cutter
This is an appeal by the Commonwealth from the dismissal of two complaints because of discriminatory enforcement of the applicable statutes. The first complaint charged (see
There she filed a motion to dismiss the complaints alleging discriminatory enforcement of the relevant statutes (see notes 1 and 2, supra). This motion was accompanied by an affidavit of the defendant and also by an affidavit of the defendant’s counsel. The defendant’s affidavit asserted that, when she was arrested, no male person was arrested with her on either charge, and that “the practice of the Brockton [pjolice [department is to arrest female prostitutes and to decline to arrest male customers and male prostitutes.” Attached to her affidavit were four pages of lists of arrests by the Brockton police for prostitution, for soliciting prostitution, and for being a common nightwalker, showing the results set out in the margin, for a period of about one year. 3
One Brockton police detective, called by the defendant, testified 4 about the department’s typical methods of surveillance of female suspects on certain streets in Brockton. These methods involve observation of (a) males in motor vehicles being waved at by females on the street, (b) the female entering the vehicle and driving off with the male, and (c) both returning after an interval, and then (d) a repetition of the process with a different male. The detective testified that, in such circumstances, “ordinarily” the police do not arrest the driver of the vehicle, or “radio ahead to another unit” to make an arrest. In cases where the vehicle is followed, and a “sexual act is [found] going on,” only the female is arrested. This defendant, when the detective arrested her on February 4, 1985, was performing fellatio on the male then in the vehicle. The male was not arrested.
Defense counsel in an attempt further to show discrimination inquired about a later arrest of another alleged female night-walker. Upon objection the judge praised the “candid and forthright” testimony of the detective, and said that the officer has “indicated that they’re searching for female nightwalkers.” In answer to an inquiry by the judge whether it was department policy not to arrest the male on prostitution related charges, the detective replied, “There hasn’t been a male arrested . . . since we’ve been working on the prostitution area.”
As to the offense of being a nightwalker charged as taking place on February 21, 1985, the detective testified that they saw “several males leaving with” the defendant “at different
On cross-examination, the prosecutor received one answer that when the detective made an arrest on “a soliciting charge and there’s a male present . . . it’s . . . general policy that you don’t arrest the male.” The detective stated the basic reason for the policy was that complaints from area citizens related “mainly [to] the girls,” and that the women arrested are known to the police, whereas the males are not “familiar” to the police. 5
1. In
Commonwealth
v.
King, 374
Mass. 5,15,19-22 (1977), decided, of course, prior to the enactment of
The opinion (at 16) then stated that the term “prostitution” did not “include the conduct of persons who hire . . . another to engage in sexual activity.” It, on that account, did not accept the contention (by the female defendants in the cases then considered) that § 53 as thus defined “unconstitutionally criminalizes female conduct but not male conduct” in violation of art. 106 of the Amendments to the Constitution of the Com
After further discussion of art. 106 of the Amendments, the opinion concluded (at 19), “[A] female charged with prostitution or night walking would be entitled to a dismissal of the charges with prejudice on an appropriate showing that the police department or the prosecutor’s office followed an unjustifiable policy of selective enforcement against female prostitutes and not male prostitutes” (subject to n.ll which pointed out that prosecution of males need not charge prostitution, but may charge related crimes).
The author of the King opinion (in a separate opinion) pointed out (at 23) that he would broaden the opinion to assert, citing State v. Johnson, 74 Wis. 2d 169 (1976), “that unlawful discrimination in enforcement can be proved by a showing that the police department or prosecutor’s office followed an unjustifiable policy of prosecuting prostitutes and not their customers,” which could be treated as sex-based on “a showing that most prostitutes are women and most customers are males.” 6
2. After the
King
case, 374 Mass. 5, was decided, the views expressed in the separate opinion in that case were given support by the 1983 statute, now found in c. 272,
3. We are of opinion that the judge correctly concluded that the proof made before him warranted dismissal of the complaints because they were the product of an “arbitrary or unequal application of impartial laws.” Commonwealth v. Franklin, 376 Mass. 885, 894 (1978). There it was said (at 894, citations omitted): “Because we presume that criminal prosecutions are undertaken in good faith, without intent to discriminate, the defendant bears the initial burden of demonstrating selective enforcement.... [T]o meet this burden, the defendant must present evidence which raises at least a reasonable inference of impermissible discrimination .... The defendant must show [1] that a broader class of persons than those prosecuted has violated the law . . . [2] that failure to prosecute was either consistent or deliberate . . . and [3] that the decision not to prosecute was based on an impermissible classification such as race, religion, or sex” (emphasis supplied). We think each of the three mentioned requisites of the defendant’s proof was satisfied by the material before the trial judge. See the requirement of “strict judicial scrutiny” under the State ERA mentioned in Lowell v. Kowalski, 380 Mass. 663, 666 (1980).
The opinion (in the Franklin case) then continued (at 895); “We stated as dictum in [the] King [case] and now we hold that once a defendant has raised a reasonable inference of selective prosecution, the Commonwealth must rebut that inference or suffer dismissal of the underlying complaint. At that point, and where it appears that the government is in ready possession of the facts, it is not unreasonable to require the
Order dismissing complaints affirmed.
Notes
Arrests by Brockton police for prostitution and related offenses June 6, 1984, to May 10, 1985, were compiled (by a process described in the affidavit of the defendant’s attorney) from police department computer records. These records, in summary, showed the following arrests:
Prostitution Solicit Prostitution Common nightwalker
Female 36 23 104
Male 1 2 2
Total 37 25 106
The records also showed seventeen arrests for open and gross behavior — mostly for offenses such as indecent exposure. Only one of these arrests was of a female. There were no arrests for adultery or fornication and one arrest of a male for “unnatural acts.”
The transcript of the hearing furnished to this court was faint and illegible. In the future, counsel should expect such transcripts to be rejected by the clerk. The panel expresses thanks to defense appellate counsel for attaching to her brief a readable copy of this transcript.
Defense counsel’s offer to put on another officer to corroborate the first detective’s testimony was not accepted. The judge directed the discussion to whether there was a difference in the effect of the assertions of discrimination (based upon the sex of the participants) between (a) the charge of soliciting, and (b) the charge of being a nightwalker.
Later in the.separate opinion (at 24) it was said, “If a police custom exists of invariably, and regardless of the circumstances, sending the male customer on his way while at the same time escorting the accused female prostitute into the police car or patrol wagon, this in my view departs from the purpose of the equal rights amendment, and may not even conform to the expressed legislative intention to control prostitution through the processes of the criminal law.”
A recent case dealing with § 53 is Commonwealth v. Sefranka, 382 Mass. 108, 117-118 (1980), interpreting one of its numerous provisions narrowly in order to preserve its validity from a charge of vagueness, but without (see n.10, at 118) limiting the offense of prostitution. See Commonwealth v. Hackett, 383 Mass. 888, 889 (1981), for an instance of inadequate proof of selective enforcement.