Commonwealth ex rel. Watson v. MontoneCommonwealth ex rel. Watson v. Montone
- Reporters:
- , ,
- Before:
- Spaeth
Opinion by
Spaeth, J.,Two appeals are before the court, each by a juvenile, and each from the denial of a petition for writ of ha-beas corpus. They must be quashed.
Under the Juvenile Act, Act of December 6, 1972, P. L. 1464, No. 333, § 1 et seq.,
Appellants, having been kept in custody, were brought before The Honorable Harvey N. Schmidt for an adjudicatory hearing on March 30, 1973. This was within ten days of their informal detention hearing. The Commonwealth, however, requested and was granted a continuance. Since the continuance delayed the adjudicatory hearing beyond the ten day period specified by § 18(a),
“The existence of an actual controversy is an essential to appellate jurisdiction.” Commonwealth ex rel. Ogden v. Gains, 48 Pa. Superior Ct. 265, 266 (1911). For this reason, “if pending an appeal an event occurs which renders it impossible for the appellate court to grant any relief the appeal will be dismissed.” Eei-chard’s License, 45 Pa. Superior Ct. 606, 607 (1911). In the present case such an event has occurred. Appellants assert that under § 18(a),
It is true that our Supreme Court has on occasion departed from the practice of refusing to decide a moot question, but only in one of two situations.*
The first situation in which the Supreme Court has decided a moot question is in those “very rare cases where exceptional circumstances exist or where matters or questions of great public importance are involved.” Wortex Mills v. Textile Workers Union, 369 Pac. 359, 370, 85 A. 2d 851, 857 (1952). The court has, however, *545added a caveat instructing that its decision in such a case “must not be regarded as a precedent for the determination of such questions in the future.” Brown v. Leib, 267 Pa. 24, 26, 110 A. 463, 464 (1920). Here, the only reason to reach the question argued by appellants would be to affect the cases of other young people who may he detained in violation of the ten day rule provided by § 18(a) of the Juvenile Act,
The second situation in which the Supreme Court has decided a moot question is when the question raised is a necessarily recurring one. Werner v. King, 310 Pa. 120, 164 A. 918 (1933) (issue concerned duty that public official had to perform every year). The record does not disclose such a question in the present case.*
Apart from the question of what has been the Supreme Court’s practice, this court- has consistently declined to render decisions where the issue raised is moot. See, e.g., In re Miller, 209 Pa. Superior Ct. 47, 224 A. 2d 89 (1966) (appeal held moot in test litigation involving important question of release procedures for mental defectives) ; distinguish Commonwealth v. Guardiani, 226 Pa. Superior Ct. 435, 310 A. 2d 422 (1973) (refusal to quash appeal as moot on petition, of appellant where question had been briefed and argued).
Appellants have argued nevertheless that we should depart from our past practice because this case involves an issue “capable of repetition, yet evading review.” Roe *546v. Wade, 410 U.S. 113, 125 (1973). However, wMle it may be granted that given the speed with which juvenile cases are usually handled, the issue may never be properly before us on appeal, it does not follow that we shall never be able to decide it. This court has original jurisdiction “in actions of mandamus and prohibition to courts of inferior jurisdiction where such actions are ancillary to matters within [our] appellate jurisdiction . . . Appellate Jurisdiction Act of 1970, July 31, 1970, P. L. 673, No. 223, Art. Ill, § 301,
The appeals are quashed.
Cercone, J., concurs in the result.
Notes
A special third situation may arise in criminal appeals. In Commonwealth v. Walker, 447 Pa. 146, 288 A. 2d 741 (1972), the court affirmed the murder conviction of a man who died while his appeal was pending. In denying the requests of the petitioner’s attorney and of the Commonwealth that the appeal be dismissed, the court said: “We today reject both motions, believing instead that it is in the interest of both a defendant’s estate and society that any challenge initiated by a defendant to the regularity or constitutionality of a criminal proceeding be fully reviewed and decided by the appellate process.” lit. at 147-148 n.l, 288 A. 2d at 742. The court neither stated nor suggested that “exceptional circumstances” or a question of “public importance” required it to decide the ease. See also Commonwealth v. Culpepper, 221 Pa. Superior Ct. 472, 293 A. 2d 122 (1972) (following Walker). In Commonwealth v. Palmer, 221 Pa. Superior Ct. 439, 292 A. 2d 428 (1972), this court distinguished Walker as applicable where an appellant challenges his conviction but not where he attacks his sentence. Assuming that Walker states a rule applicable beyond situations where an appellant in a criminal case has died, nevertheless, since the present appeals deal with proceedings prior to a final determination, they are closer to the situation in Palmer than to that in Walker.
By letter of July 24, 1973, appellants’ counsel has written this court regarding other juvenile detention cases, which counsel characterizes as “three examples of a continuing pattern of the disregard of the ten day rule [provided by § 18(a)] of the Juvenile Act.” We cannot consider such a statement, for the facts of the cases described are not properly before us. In any event, the letter is insufficient to demonstrate the existence of a necessarily recurring question.