68 N.Y.S. 600 | N.Y. App. Div. | 1901
It appears from the affidavits that the money' sought to be recovered in this action was collected by the defendant from various, persons who were debtors of the Memphis Appeal Company, and at different times after the 28th of February, 1896. Heither the names and residences of these persons nor the amount collected from each one of them, nor the times when the several collections, were made, áre known to the plaintiff, but these facts are within the personal knowledge of the defendant. It is evident that with the testimony of the defendant upon all these questions the plaintiff will be able to make out a good cause of action, and that without his testimony it is difficult if not practically impossible for it tO' prove what is alleged in the complaint. The evidence of the defendant, therefore, is material and necessary for the plaintiff to
Present — Yak Brunt, P. J.,. Bumsey, O’Brien, Ingraham and Hatch, JJ.
Order reversed, with ten dollars costs and disbursements, and motion denied, with ten dollars costs.