COMMANDEUR LLC v. Howard Hartry, Inc.COMMANDEUR LLC v. Howard Hartry, Inc.
- Reporters:
- , ,
- Before:
- Anderson
OPINION
ANDERSON, RUSSELL A., Chief Justice.In this case, we consider whether the court of appeals properly dismissed an appeal as untimely under the Rules of Civil Appellate Procedure, which extend an appeal period when the last day of the period falls on a legal holiday. The narrow issue before us is whether Columbus Day is a legal holiday for purposes of computing the last day of an appeal period. We conclude that it is and reverse the order of the court of appeals dismissing the appeal.
We recite only those facts necessary to decide the narrow issue before us. The district court granted summary judgment dismissing the claims of Commandeur LLC and ACRO Business Finance Corp. (appellants) against Howard Hartry, Inc. (respondent), and judgment was entered on August 10, 2005. Generally, an appeal may be taken within 60 days after entry of judgment. Minn. R. Civ.App. P. 104.01. The method for computing the 60-day period is specified in
We are called upon in this case to interpret the term “legal holiday” in
“In construing procedural rules, we first look to the plain language of the rule and its purpose.”
Id.
Under
Minnesota Statutes § 645.44, subd. 5 (2004), defines the term “holiday.” Unlike other holidays, the treatment of Columbus Day varies under the statute. Although section 645.44, subd. 5, generally defines “holiday” to include Columbus Day, the statute also provides that Columbus Day is not a holiday for the executive branch, and that other branches of state government have the option of determining whether Columbus Day is a holiday:
“Holiday” includes * * * Christopher Columbus Day, the second Monday in October * * *. No public business shall be transacted on any holiday, except in cases of necessity and except in cases of public business transacted by the legislature, nor shall any civil process be served thereon. However, for the executive branch of the state of Minnesota, “holiday” also includes the Friday after Thanksgiving but does not include Christopher Columbus Day. Other branches of state government and political subdivisions shall have the option of determining whether Christopher Columbus Day and the Friday after Thanksgiving shall be holidays. Where it is determined that Columbus Day or the Friday after Thanksgiving is not a holiday, public business may be conducted thereon.
Respondent argues that Columbus Day is not a legal holiday under
Appellants argue that the court of appeals’ conclusion that Columbus Day is not a legal holiday under
Procedural rules are “construed and administered to secure the just, speedy, and inexpensive determination of every action,”
Our holding is consistent with the broad language of the rule, which defines “legal holiday” as
“any
holiday defined or designated by statute.”
Our holding that Columbus Day is a legal holiday also fosters certainty because the definition of legal holiday in
Our holding that Columbus Day is a legal holiday under
“As every practitioner is keenly aware, the importance of an accurate calculation of time allowed for appeal is critical and an error can be fatal to further review.” State v. Hugger, 640 N.W.2d 619, 625 (Minn.2002). The Rules of Civil Procedure “reflect a preference that actions be determined on the merits,” Patterson v. Wu Family Corp., 608 N.W.2d 863, 867 (Minn.2000), and “the rules are to be liberally construed so as to serve the interests of justice,” Larson v. Indep. Seh. Dist. No. 314, 305 Minn. 358, 362, 233 N.W.2d 744, 747 (1975). Accordingly, we grant appellants the benefit of the doubt in their efforts to comply with the time restrictions set forth in the rule.
Because Columbus Day is a legal holiday under
Reversed and remanded; appeal reinstated.
Notes
.
See, e.g.,
Minn. R. Juv. Delinq. P. 31.01 (specifically stating that “legal holiday” includes Columbus Day);
. If the terms “deposited in the mail” and “on mailing” require appellants to have their notice of appeal postmarked on the last day of an appeal period, that would be impossible on Columbus Day. Even if a postmark on the last day of an appeal period is not required, parties easily could be confused by the fact that the United States Postal Service does not operate on Columbus Day, potentially leading them to forfeit their rights inadvertently. Columbus Day is the only day of the year on which this conundrum occurs.
As an additional reason to reject a narrow interpretation of legal holiday that excludes Columbus Day, we note that civil process may be prohibited on Columbus Day even if the judicial branch does not recognize Columbus Day as a holiday.
See