Coles v. . Lumber Co.Coles v. . Lumber Co.
- Reporters:
- , ,
- Before:
- Connor
Lead Opinion
PLAINTIFF‘S APPEAL Plaintiff, on 17 December, 1906, entered into a contract with defendant, the material parts whereof are:
“This agreement, made this 17 December, 1906, by and between C. I. DeBruhl and Milton Prescott, trading as the Standard Lumber Company (not incorporated), New Bern, N.C. parties of the first part, and C. B. Coles Sons Co., a corporation duly created and existing under the laws of the State of New Jersey, Camden, N. J., party of the second part, witnesses: That the said party of the first part, in consideration of the promises hereinafter made by the party of the second part, promises and agrees to and with said party of the second part that they will bargain, sell and deliver to said party of the second part the output of North Carolina pine lumber, not to exceed 100,000 feet per month, board measure, manufactured by said parties of the first part at their mill situated in New Bern, N.C. from the date of this agreement until 1 April, 1907; the same to be properly manufactured, kiln-dried and delivered to the barge rail at the wharf of the party of the first part at New Bern, N.C. at the following prices, subject to two per cent discount, and as further provided: . . . And the said party of the first part agrees that he will deliver to the said party of the second part 100,000 feet of the said lumber within thirty days from the date of this contract, and that he will, each thirty days during the existence of this contract, deliver to the aforesaid party of the second part 100,000 feet of the said lumber in accordance with the terms hereof; and the said party of the first part agrees to provide shelter for all the lumber herein contracted for, and store the said grades of lumber thereunder, so as to deliver all of the said lumber in good condition; and the said party of the first part agrees to sort out, pile separately and have the same loaded separately in the barge as follows: . . . And the party of the second part, in consideration of the premises, promises and agrees to and with the party of the first part that it will buy from the party of the first part all the lumber hereinbefore mentioned, and receive, measure and pay for the same in accordance with the prices, terms and conditions herein set out; and the said party of the second part agrees to advance to the said party of the first part the sum of $10 for each 1,000 feet, board measure, of the lumber of the grade of 3‘s and better, and the sum of $6 for each 1,000 feet, board measure, of the lumber of the box grades, and shall be manufactured and stored and ready for delivery and shipment. It is mutually agreed by the parties hereto that the advances hereinbefore mentioned shall be made every two weeks, and all payments of advances shall be based on the estimate or measurement of the lumber by the party of the second part or its agent. It is further agreed that no advances are to be made each two weeks on any larger amount of lumber than 50,000 feet, and the balance of the purchase money shall be paid to the party of the first part by the party of the second part when the lumber shall have been delivered to the wharf of the party of the second part at Camden, N. J., and inspected by the said party of the second part.”
Plaintiff, on 7 May, 1907, brought this action, alleging that, pursuant to the terms of this contract, it was the owner and entitled to the possession of certain lumber described in the complaint. At the institution of the action plaintiff obtained a requisition from the clerk for the immediate possession of the lumber, and defendant replevied. Defendant denied that plaintiff was the owner of the lumber, and, by way of counterclaim, alleged that plaintiff failed to perform its part of the contract, whereby it sustained damages, all of which is set out in full in the answer. Plaintiff replied to the counterclaim, denying each allegation thereof.
The following issues were submitted to the jury, to which they responded, as set out in the record:
1. “Is the plaintiff the owner and entitled to the possession of the property described in the complaint?” Answer: “No.”
2. “Does the defendant wrongfully detain the possession of the same from the plaintiff?” Answer: ___________.
3. “What was the value of the property at the time of the seizure?” Answer: “Two thousand dollars.”
4. “Is the plaintiff indebted to the defendant upon counterclaim by reason of a breach of contract?” Answer: “Yes.”
5. “If so, what is the defendant entitled to recover thereon?” Answer: “One thousand eight hundred and fifteen dollars and sixty-five cents.”
6. “What amount, if any, has plaintiff advanced to defendant on account of unshipped lumber?” Answer: “Seven hundred and thirty-five dollars.”
Judgment was rendered for defendant for the sum of $1,080.65, being the amount of damages assessed for breach of contract, less the amount advanced by plaintiff. Both parties, having noted exceptions, appealed. The controversy, in regard to plaintiff‘s right to recover the lumber on the yard, is dependent upon the construction of the contract and the conduct of plaintiff respecting its performance of the stipulation thereof. The evidence upon this last question was conflicting. The contract is executory, and until all of the stipulations contained in it were performed, or, at least, performance with readiness and ability tendered and refused, no title vested in plaintiff. These aspects of the case were fully explained to the jury by his Honor, followed by the instruction that if the defendant had cut, graded and set apart this lumber, and plaintiff had paid for it or stood ready to pay for it, and nothing was to be done but to take charge of it, and defendant refused to permit them to do so, they should answer the first issue in the affirmative. To this instruction plaintiff excepted.
We find no error in the instructions. They are in accordance with the principles and authorities announced in Hughes v. Knott, 138 N.C. 105. It is true that the contract, being in writing, was to be construed by the court, but the plaintiff‘s right to demand the possession of the lumber was dependent upon the establishment of its compliance with the terms of the contract, and this was properly submitted to the jury. The first issue having been answered adversely to plaintiff, the second and third were immaterial. This brings us to an examination of plaintiff‘s exceptions to his Honor‘s instructions upon the character and measure of damages which defendant was entitled to recover.
Defendant claimed that it was entitled to deliver and plaintiff compelled to receive 100,000 feet a month from the date of the agreement to 1 April, 1907, and that it had a profit of $3 per thousand feet in the lumber. It appears that 61,098 feet were delivered, and plaintiff advanced on account thereof $700, and paid for insurance $35; that by reason of plaintiff‘s failure to accept and remove the quantity of lumber for which it had contracted, its yards were blocked, whereby it sustained damage; that by reason of plaintiff‘s failure to make advancements,
It will be convenient to dispose of the several elements of damage in the same order as given by his Honor. He told the jury that defendant was entitled to damages by reason of his yard being “blocked.” It appears from the testimony that plaintiff was under a contract obligation to take 100,000 feet of lumber per month. This lumber was to be piled on defendant‘s yard until delivered to plaintiff or loaded on barge or
His Honor further told the jury that “If defendant had lumber on his yard, and by reason of plaintiff not taking it off when he could have reasonably done so, and defendant suffered loss by reason of that, you will give him whatever you find to be a reasonable allowance.” If defendant, as we have said, is entitled to recover for the use and occupation of his yard by reason of plaintiff‘s failure to remove according to his contract, he can not recover double damages by charging plaintiff with possible losses sustained by reason of its failure to take the lumber away. The only amount which it would seem he could sustain by plaintiff‘s failure to remove the lumber was the value of the use of the yard. Again, if liable at all, some measure of damages should have been given the jury for their guidance. It should not have been left to them to give whatever “they found to be a reasonable allowance.” For a breach of a business contract, in the absence of any element entitling the plaintiff to vindictive or exemplary damages, he is entitled to compensation for the loss sustained by the breach. The measure or rule by which such compensation is fixed by the jury is certain and to be given them by the court as their guide. The law seeks to confine the damages to such as reasonably flow from the breach and were in the contemplation of the parties. The recovery of profits, while in some cases allowed, is confined to “such as may fairly be supposed to have entered into the contemplation of the parties when they made the contract — that is, must be such as might naturally be expected to follow its violation; and they must be certain, both in their nature and in respect to the cause from which they proceed.” Hale on Damages, 73, citing Griffin v. Colver, 16 N. Y., 489. Eliminating all other elements of damage, we have this case: Plaintiff contracted to take from defendant, at a stipulated price, subject to inspection, etc., 100,000 feet of lumber a month. The lumber was to be cut, graded and piled on defendant‘s yard. The jury find that plaintiff failed to comply with his contract. If defendant had the lumber on
New Trial.
DEFENDANT‘S APPEAL.
Addendum
Without further pursuing an interesting but elusive subject, we have no hesitation in affirming his Honor‘s ruling.
Affirmed.
Cited: Elks v. Ins. Co., 159 N.C. 628.