Cohn v. PeopleCohn v. People
- Reporters:
- , , ,
- Before:
- Shope
delivered the opinion of the Court:
This was a prosecution of the plaintiff in error for the violation of section 2 of an act entitled “An act to protect associations, unions of workingmen and persons in their labels, trade-marks and forms of advertising,” in force July 1, 1891. Before a justice of the peace he was found guilty and a fine imposed. On appeal to the Criminal Court by the defendant a trial was had by jury, resulting in a verdict of guilty, and a judgment for $100 fine, and costs, rendered.
Section 1 of the act under consideration provides: “Whenever any person, association or union of workingmen have adopted, or shall hereafter adopt, for their protection, any label, trade-mark or form of advertisement announcing that goods to which such label, trade-mark or form of advertisement shall be attached, were manufactured by such person or by a member or members of such association or union, it shall be unlawful for any person or corporation to counterfeit or imitate
The plaintiff in error was a dealer in cigars, and it is shown that certain witnesses produced, applied to him for the purchase of cigars by the box; that they objected to purchasing unless there were upon the boxes what were known as the-“Union Labelsthat there were no such labels upon the boxes produced by the plaintiff in error and offered to be sold. The plaintiff in error thereupon took these boxes of cigars, went into the back part of his store, and returned with boxes having labels on them. The witnesses then paid for them and took them away. The boxes were produced and identified as being those sold to the witnesses by plaintiff in error, and upon each of which was a label purporting to be the label of the Cigar Makers’ International Union of America. This label is a small blue paster, on which is printed the following;
“This certifies that the cigars contained in this box have been made by a first-class workman, a member of the Cigar Makers’ International Union of America, an organization opposed to inferior, rat-shop, coolie, prison or filthy tenement-house workmanship. Therefore we recommend these cigars to all smokers throughout the world. All infringements upon this label will be punished according to law.
A. Strasser, Pres. C. M. I. U. of America.”
It is objected that the evidence was insufficient to warrant the verdict. It need only be said that there was evidence sufficient to justify the jury in finding the defendant guilty of using a counterfeit or imitation label,-within the meaning of section 2 of the act before quoted.
stantially the rule, that in consistency with that provision there may be included in an act means which are reasonably adapted to secure the objects indicated by the title.” (See cases there cited.) When the general purpose is declared in the title, the means for its accomplishment provided by the act will be presumed to be intended as a necessary incident. (O’Leary v. Cook County, 28 Ill. 534; People ex rel. v. Hazelwood, 116 id. 319; McGurn v. Board of Education, 110 id. 123.) The penalties for the counterfeiting and for the use of imitations and counterfeits, while intended as punishment for the violation of public law, are imposed to protect, in the language of the title, associations and others entitled to use labels, trade-marks and forms of advertisement, in the use thereof. The objection is not well taken.
It is next said by counsel that “the statute is wholly‘void, because it is obnoxious to the constitutional inhibition (art. 4, sec. 22,) which provides that the General Assembly shall not pass local or special laws granting any incorporation, association or individual any special privilege, immunity or franchise whatever.” It is urged, that while “persons” are protected in their labels, etc., without regard to their avocations, “associations or
Formerly, when the titles of acts were no necessary part of legislation, the title was not to be considered in construing the statute. (Plummer v. People, 74 Ill. 361; Wills v. Wilkins, 6 Mod. 62; Endlich on Interpretation of Statutes, sec. 58, and note.) It is, however, otherwise, where, by virtue of constitutional provision, the legislature must prepare and adopt the title, to the end that it shall express the general purposes of the act. It can not be resorted to to extend or restrain any positive provision in the body of the law itself. (Hadden v. Collector, etc. 5 Wall. 107; Williams v. Williams, 8 N. Y. 535; Meyer v. Western Car Co. 102 U. S. 1; Eby’s Appeal, 70 Pa. St. 311; Halderman‘s Appeal, 104 id. 251.) It is one of the cardinal principles of construction that the intention of the law-makers is to be found and given effect, and where there is otherwise doubt or obscurity iti the act, or its meaning is doubtful, resort may be had to the title of the act to enable the court to discover the intent, and remove what otherwise might be uncertain or ambiguous. (United States v. Palmer, 3 Wheat. 631; cases supra.) The term “unions,” as thus applied, has come to have a definite and well understood meaning, and it is to be presumed that the legislature,
It is next objected that the label, an imitation and counterfeit of which is alleged to have been unlawfully used by plaintiff in error, could not have been rightfully adopted either as a label, trade-mark or form of advertisement. It is said that it transgresses the rules of morality and public policy. We are referred to the rule in respect of trade-marks, that “to be a lawful trade-mark the emblem must avoid transgressing the rules of morality and «public policy,” (Brown on Trademarks, sec. 602,) and also to the case of McVey v. Brendel, 144 Pa. St. 235, decided by the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania, which was a proceeding in equity to restrain the use of imitations of the label adopted by the Cigar Makers’ International Union of America. It is conceded there is no statute in that State protecting labels adopted by dealers, etc. The case is cited mainly for the purpose of showing the construction placed upon the blue label by that court, the case having been decided upon other grotinds. With all due deference, we are unable to concur in the views of the learned judge who delivered the opinion of the court. By reference to the label heretofore set out, it will be seen that it is a certificate, signed by the president of the Cigar Makers’ International Union of America, certifying that the cigars contained in the box upon which it is placed were “made by a first-class workman, a member of the Cigar Makers’
We need not extend this discussion. We are of opinion that the label adopted by the Cigar Makers’ International
Other errors are assigned which have been carefully considered, but are not deemed of sufficient importance to merit discussion.
The judgment of the Criminal Court of Cook county will be affirmed.
Judgment affirmed.