225 F. 211 | D.N.J. | 1915
(specially presiding). This is a hill in equity whereby the plaintiff seeks such a construction of the will of Wesley E. Whittaker, deceased, as will result in a decree that said testator died intestate as to a large portion of his estate; that the plaintiff and others are proper persons to whom such portion should be ultimately distributed; and that the Mercer Hospital, which is named as residuary legatee in such will, should be excluded in such distribution. The parties defendant are numerous. Most of them will be directly benefited if the plaintiff has a decree in her favor. Some of them have permitted the bill to be taken pro confesso. Others have appeared and filed brief answers admitting the allegations of the bill. Answers at length to the merits of the bill were filed by Mary A. Whittaker, personally and as executrix of the will of Wesley E. Whittaker, deceased, by Gardner H. Cain, executor of the will of John Henry Whit-taker, and by the Mercer Hospital. The case came on for hearing upon bill and answers.
Because of the views of the court upon the main questions involved, it is unnecessary to determine the exact relationship of all the parties to the testator, Wesley E. Whittaker, deceased. The facts material to a determination of the questions involved are as follows :
Wesley K. Whittaker died unmarried and without issue December 6, 1897, having first made his last will and testament and a certain codicil thereto, which will and codicil were subsequently duly admitted to probate by the proper court, which issued letters testamentary to the executors therein named. Said will and codicil are in language following:
•Tn the name of God, Amen.
“I, "Wesley E. Whittaker, of the city of Trenton, in the county of Mercer and state of New Jersey, being of sound mind, memory and understanding, do hereby make, publish and declare this present writing to be my last will and testament, and I do hereby revoke all former wills by me at any time before made.
"First. I do hereby order my executors hereinafter named to pay all my just debts and funeral expenses as soon as practicable after my decease.
"Second. I give and bequeath unto my friend Charles H. Hall, of the city of Trenton, my diamond stud.
“Third. I give and bequeath unto Frank E. Ellison, of Jersey City, my gold watch and chain.
"Fourth. I give and bequeath unto John W. Ellison, of Jersey City, the gold watch left to me by my father, John Whittaker.
“Fifth. I give and bequeath unto by sister-in-law Mary A. Whittaker (wife of John Henry Whittaker) all of my household goods and furniture, all my wearing apparel, books, silver ware, pictures, engravings, also all my jewelry of all kinds (not hereinbefore disposed of). Also the sum of three thousand dollars.
“Sixth. I give unto the liiverview Cemetery at Trenton the sum of three hundred dollars as permanent fund to invest securely and to apply and use the interest or income therefrom from time to time toward keeping in repair and proper condition my burial lot in said cemetery.
“Seventh. I give and bequeath unto my sister, Anna W. Ellison, of Jersey Oily, the sum of five thousand dollars, and in case she shall not be living, 1 give and bequeath the said sum of five thousand dollars to her daughter, Anna M. B. Creveling.
“1 give and bequeath unto the said Anna M. E. Creveling the further sum of two thousand dollars.
*214 “I give ánd bequeath unto John W. Ellison the sum of one thousand dollars.
“I give and bequeath unto Frank E'. Ellison, Harry B. Ellison, Percy Ellison and Roy Ellison (children oí John W. Ellison) the sum of one thousand dollars to be divided equally among them, and in case of the decease of any of them, his share shall be equally divided among his surviving brothers.
“I give and bequeath unto my brother, John Henry Whittaker, the sum of one thousand dollars, also the library of mine now in his possession, also the case of minerals and the autograph letters formerly belonging to my brother, Albert J. Whittaker, also such other cases and books of mine now in his possession.
“I give and bequeath unto my brother, George R. Whittaker, the sum of one thousand dollars.
“Eighth. I give and bequeath unto my sister-in-law Attie E. Williams (wife of John H. Williams) the sum of one thousand dollars as a token of my regard for her.
“I give and bequeath unto my housekeeper, Annie Hart, the sum of one thousand dollars in remembrance of her long and faithful services in my family.
“Ninth. I give and bequeath unto ‘The Union Industrial Home Association for 'Destitute Children of Trenton, New Jersey,’ located on Chestnut avenue, near Greenwood avenue, the sum of one thousand dollars. And also I give and bequeath unto the ‘Saint Francis Hospital,’ located on Chambers street, near Hamilton avenue, in said city of Trenton, the sum of one thousand dollars.
“Tenth. I hereby authorize and empower my executors (and the survivor of, them) to sell and convey all my real estate at either public or private sale and to execute good and lawful conveyances for the same.
“Eleventh. All the rest, residue and remainder of my estate, X do hereby give unto my brother, George R. Whittaker, and my sister-in-law, Mary A. Whit-taker (wife of my brother John Henry Whittaker), and to the survivor of them, to have and to hold as trustees, to rent, invest and reinvest the same, and to pay the income and interest arising therefrom (first deducting all taxes, insurances, repairs and all other costs, assessments and impositions whatsoever) to the board of directors of ‘The Mercer Hospital’ at Trenton, to be used by said board of directors for the uses and purposes mentioned as the object for which said hospital was incorporated in the certificate of incorporation now on record in the Mercer county clerk’s office for the term of nine years from the date of their accounting as such executors in yearly payments: Provided, however, that if at any time within said term my said trustees (or the survivor of them) shall decide that said income is not being properly applied (of which fact I hereby direct my said trustees, or the survivor of them shall be the sole and only judge, and whose judgment and decision shall be final and conclusive) I hereby direct, require and empower them (or the survivor of them) to withhold all further payments of said income, without any notices to said board of trustees or to said ‘The Mercer Hospital’ and therefrom and thereafter to divide the whole of the principal sum of said trust estate and all unused accumulations of interest or income thereon (less all costs, charges and expenses incident to the final settlement of my estate) equally among any, and as many charitable institutions and hospitals located in the state of New Jersey as they (or the survivor of them) may choose and select: Provided further, if however my said trustees (or the survivor of them) shall continue to pay said income to the board of directors of the said ‘The Mercer Hospital’ for the entire term above stated, then in that ease, it is my will, and I do hereby order, that at the expiration of the said term, my said trustees (or the survivor of them) shall pay the whole of the principal sum of said trust, estate and all unused accumulations of interest or income thereon (less all costs, charges and expenses incident to the final settlement of my estate) to the said ‘The Mercer Hospital’ absolutely for its use and benefit forever.
“Dastly, I do hereby nominate, constitute and appoint my brother, George R. Whittaker, and my said sister-in-law, Mary A. Whittaker (and the survivor of them) the executors of this my last will and testament.
*215 “In witness whereof, I have hereunto sot my hand and seal this twenty-seventh day of February, eighteen hundred and ninety five.
“Wesley E. Whittaker. [L. S.]
“Signed, scaled, published and declared by the above named testator to be Ms Iasi, will and testament in our presence and we, in his presence, at his request-, and in the presence of each other, have hereunto set our hands and seals this twenty seventh day of February, eighten hundred and ninety five as attesting witnesses. 3. Jutlson Hue, 111 E. State St.
“John M. Grouch, 111 E. State St.
“I, Wesley 13. Whittaker, of the city of Trenton in the county of Mercer and sti-ex; <>£ Xew Jersey, being of sound mind, memory and understanding, do hereby make this a codicil to my last will and testament,, dated February the LWc'ity-sew'n.fn, A. D. eighteen hundred and ninety-ii\e, and 1 hereby revoke will so fur as this codicil símil «fleet the same.
“lir&r,. I do hereby revoke the fourth clause In my said will and testament and hereby give mid bequeath an to my nephew, John T. Whittaker, the gold 'vietch aft to me by my father, John Whittaker.
“¡écunul. I give and bequeath unto my brother. George E. Whittaker, the sum of four (-3) Ihousaud doll; rs out of th» residiré of my óslate in addition to the se.m of one thousand dollars given to him in clause seventh of my said wl’l mid test;-merit.
“Third. I give and bequeath unto iny housekeeper, Annie Hart, out of the residuo oí my estote, the sum of one thousand dollars in addition to the one thousand dollars given to her iu cluure eigblh of my said will and testament.
“Lastly, I hereby confirm my said last will and testament in all respects except- so far as this codicil shall alter the same. And I direct my said executors named therein to carry out the provisions of this codicil thereto.
“in vitnosn whereof, I have hereunto sot my hand and seal this first dav of December, A. D., eighteen hundred and ninety-seven.
“Wesley E. Whittaker. [L. 5.1
“Signed, sea led,, pronounced and delivered and declared by the said Wesley F. Whittaker, as a codicil to his last will and testament, and to be taken as onrt thereof in our presence, and we in his presence find at his request, and in the presence of each other, have hereunto subscribed our names as witnesses.
“Margaret A. Whittaker.
“John.M. Grouch.”
The executors assumed the trusts imposed upon them by said will, settled the estate, according- to its provisions and according to law, and exercised the discretion given to them in the residuary clause in favor of “The Mercer Hospital-’ in all respects. Immediately after the- death of the testator there came into the hands of the executors certain real estate and personal estate of the value of $34,841.01. The balance of corpus and net accumulations of interest which were distributed to the Mercer Hospital at the end of the nine-year period together amounted to $27,947.46, for which the said residuary legatee then gave to said executors and trustees an absolute release and discharge in writing, under date of January 17, 1908.
Shortly after July 28, 1914, there came into the hands of Mary A. Whittaker, as surviving executor of Wesley E. Whittaker, deceased, $123,801.45. This sum is claimed by the Mercer Hospital in reliance upon the provisions of the residuary clause in the will above mentioned. To restrain the said surviving- executor from acceding to said claim this bill is tiled; it being the contention of the plaintiff that said sum was not intended to come within the operation of said residuary clause, and that with respect to said sum said Wesley E. Whittaker died intestate.
“First. I give to my wife, Margaret A. Whittaker, the use and possession of my residence'during her natural life, all the taxes, insurance and repairs thereof to be paid out of my estate. 1 give to my said wife all my furniture, pictures, silverware, piano, and all other articles of use or ornament in said residence. I further give and bequeath to my said wife in lieu of dower, for and during the term of her natural life, without any power to sell or transfer the same, six hundred shares of the capital stock of the United New Jersey Railroad and Canal Company now standing in my name, with full power and authority to collect and receive to and for her own use and benefit all dividends and interest declared thereon after my death, and I do hereby order and direct that said stock shall not be sold, transferred or exchanged by my executors, or by any other person or persons whatever, during the life of my said wife, but shall be left and remain standing in my name on the company’s books, and the dividends thereon paid to my wife alone, or her order, and not. to my executors. Out of said dividends and interest I request my said wife to pay to her niece, Emma Chambers, for and during the natural life of the said Emma Chambers, six hundred dollars per annum.
“In ease of the decease of my said wife before that of Emma Chambers, I direct and require my executors to retain sixty shares of the said stock and to pay the interest thereon to said Emma Chambers during her natural life.
“Second. I give to my oldest brother who may survive me the gold watch which I now carry, and to my brother, Wesley E. Whittaker, my oifice safe and furniture, and tire coins, autographs, etc., etc., in said oifice.
“Third. I give to Albert Whittaker Moore, son of Randolph H. Moore, one thousand dollars and to Albert J. Whittaker McGuire, son of James H. McGuire, one thousand dollars.
“Fourth. I give to my brother Wesley E. Whittaker, fifteen thousand dollars; to my brother John H. Whittaker, fifteen thousand dollars; to my sister Ann W. Ellison, fifteen thousand dollars, and to my brother George R. Whittaker, twenty thousand dollars because he has a large family to support, the lawful child or children of them who may have died to take the share of the deceased parent.
“Fifth. I authorize and empower my executors to sell and convey my real estate, at their discretion, except my residence, which said residence I authorize them to sell after the decease of my wife.
“Sixth. After the decease of my said wife and niece, I give my estate to my lawful heirs, to be divided equally among them, share and share alike, the lawful child or children of any of them who may have died to take the share of their deceased parent.
“Lastly. I nominate, constitute and appoint my said brothers, Wesley Ei Whittaker and George R. Whittaker, executors of this my will, and hereby revoking all wills by me heretofore made, I declare this alone to he my last will and testament.
“In witness whereof, I have hereunto set my hand and seal this seventeenth day of July, in the year of our Lord eighteen hundred and eighty-two.
“Albert J. Whittaker. [L. S.]”
Of the foregoing will, the second paragraph, creating the life estate for his widow and her niece, the sixth paragraph, providing for distribution subject to the rights of such widow and niece, and the last' paragraph, appointing his brother, AVesley E. AVhittaker, as one of his executors, are the most important parts.
"It follows that the persons who, at his death, were his heirs at law or next of kin, are not entitled to take now, as their properly, that part of the estate which is not needed for the purpose of paying debts and legacies and proriding for the widow and her niece, according to the will.”
No appeal was taken from that decree, which therefore remained the law of the case and governed the construction of said will for some years, during which Wesley E. Whittaker made his will and died. At the date of said decree, the widow, Margaret A. Whittaker, was 52 years of age, and her niece, Emma Chambers, was 25 years old. Margaret A. Whittaker died in 1908. On May 25, 1912, after the death of both the executors of Albert J. Whittaker, deceased, and the substitution of their successor, the plaintiff in this case and others filed their bill in the Court of Chancery of New Jersey, praying that the trust created and existing under the will of Albert J. Whittaker, deceased, should be terminated, and such proceedings were had that, although the Court of Chancery followed the decree of that court entered June 16, 1885, hereinabove referred to, yet upon appeal to the Court of Errors and Appeals of the state of New Jersey the appellate court reversed the decree of the lower court and remitted the proceedings, with the result that a final decree was encored adjudging that the residuary estate of said Albert J. Whit-taker, deceased, be distributed (except as to stock necessary to protect the righfs of said Emma Chambers) to persons named, including Mary A. Whittaker, executrix of Wesley E. Whittaker, deceased, whose share was the aforementioned sum of $123,801.45. The opinion of the Court oí Errors and Appeals is found in Clement v. Creveling, 83 N. J. Eq. 318, 9L Atl. 89.
Discussion.
Doe v. Considine, 6 Wall. 458-475 et seq., 18 L. Ed. 869, is a good example of the extent to which courts had gone in determining the character of remainders, and is conclusive that no new principle was pronounced by the decision of the Court of Errors and Appeals in holding that Wesley Ei Whittaker’s interest in the estate of his brother was vested. Indeed, there seems to be nothing to justify the inference that Wesley E. Whittaker at the time of his death believed that he had no interest in his brother Albert’s estate. On the contrary, it is fair to assume that he knew he had an interest therein of which the right to possession was merely postponed.
It would be of little value to comment on all the cases cited by counsel in support of their contentions. Few will cases are of value as precedents in controversies such as the one now decided.
Hooking at the plaintiff’s case from every point of view, the result must be a finding that it is without merit. The court therefore reaches the following conclusions of law:
1. That by the terms of the will of Wesley K. Whittaker, deceased, the residuary estate included his interest in the .estate of his brother, Albert J. Whittaker, deceased.
2. That the plaintiff has no interest in that portion of the estate, of Wesley E. Whittaker, deceased, which was derived from the estate of Albert J. Whittaker, deceased.
3. That the bill must be dismissed, at plaintiff’s costs.
