City of Missoula v. J. WilliamsCity of Missoula v. J. Williams
- Reporters:
- , , ,
- Before:
- McKinnon
Lead Opinion
delivered the Opinion of the Court.
¶1 Justin Williams (Williams) appeals from an order entered by the Fourth Judicial District Court, Missoula County, affirming the Municipal Court of the City of Missoula’s denial of his motion to suppress blood evidence in a DUI proceeding against him. We affirm.
¶2 Williams presents the following issues for our review:
1. Whether the District Court erred in affirming a telephonic search warrant issued pursuant to§ 61-8-402(5), MCA , to draw Williams’s blood.
2. Whether the District Court erred in failing to consider the merits of Williams’s contention that he did not receive the implied consent advisory prior to his blood draw.
FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
¶3 On January 24, 2016, at 2:48 a.m., Missoula Police Deputy Jenna Volinkaty (Volinkaty) observed Williams speeding in a rental truck, lose control of the vehicle, collide with a utility pole and tree, and attempt to leave the scene. Using a radar device before the collision, Volinkaty measured Williams traveling between 50 and 55 miles per hour and another officer measured him traveling at 70 miles per hour and accelerating. The speed limit in the area is 30 miles per hour. Volinkaty smelled alcohol on Williams’s breath, saw that his eyes were glassy, watery, and bloodshot, his clothing was soiled, that he could not maintain his balance, and heard Williams slur his words. Volinkaty arrested Williams for suspected DUI. Williams admitted he had consumed alcohol, but refused to take an Intoxilyzer breath test. Volinkaty learned that in 2008, Williams was convicted of an alcohol-related driving offense under Arizona Revised Statute § 28-1381.
¶4 Volinkaty contacted Judge Marie Anderson to obtain a telephonic search warrant to draw Williams’s blood. In her affidavit, Volinkaty described seeing Williams speeding, travelling 50-55 miles per hour, losing control, and crashing into a utility pole at 2:48 a.m.; Williams being taken into custody after he attempted to flee; observing symptoms of his impairment including watery, bloodshot eyes, slurred speech, staggering movements, soiled clothing, and mood swings. Volinkaty also notified Judge Anderson that “the suspect has a prior conviction
¶5 The City of Missoula (the City) charged Williams with aggravated DUI pursuant to
¶6 Williams appealed the Municipal Court’s order denying his motion to suppress to Montana’s Fourth Judicial District Court, Missoula County, and made an additional argument that “Officer Volinkaty failed to include in her Affidavit of Probable Cause that she had read to [Williams] the Implied Consent Advisory and therefore information about his refusal is called into question.” The District Court affirmed the Municipal Court’s order denying Williams’s motion to suppress on the same grounds as the Municipal Court, concluding that the Arizona statute is “similar” to Montana’s DUI statute “for the purposes of being able to seek a telephonic search warrant under the auspices of
¶7 Williams appeals.
STANDARDS OF REVIEW
¶8 On appeal from a municipal court, the district court functions as an intermediate appellate court. Sections 3-5-303, 3-6-110, MCA; City of Bozeman v. Cantu, 2013 MT 40, ¶ 10, 369 Mont. 81, 296 P.3d 461. When a district court acts as an intermediate appellate court, “[t]he appeal is confined to review of the record and questions of law, subject to the supreme court’s rulemaking and supervisory authority.”
DISCUSSION
¶9 1. Whether the District Court erred in affirming a telephonic search warrant issued pursuant to
¶10 Williams challenges the legality of the search warrant application that allowed his blood to be drawn. Williams contends on appeal that, under McNally, Arizona and Montana’s DUI statutes are not “similar” and, without similarity, there was insufficient evidence to authorize a blood draw under
¶11 The City responds that McNally is distinguishable because it addressed “similarity”
¶12 While we ultimately conclude that McNally is not dispositive of the issue before us, some discussion of McNally and its progeny are necessary to understand the legal inquiry required in assessing the similarity of another state’s statutes with ours and whether such an inquiry is appropriate in deciding if a search warrant should issue. The statute at issue in McNally was a sentencing enhancement statute,
¶13 This Court conducted a careful review and comparison of the statutory scheme pertaining to alcohol-related offenses for both Colorado and Montana, which required consideration of the elements and degree of impairment for each state’s respective offenses. We agreed with McNally, differentiating between Colorado’s scheme of alcohol-related driving offenses, which provided for three offenses, DUI, DUI per se, and DWAI, and Montana’s, which only provided for two, DUI and DUI per se. McNally, ¶¶ 7-10. Reasoning that the standard of impairment contained in Colorado’s DWAI statute, which required impairment only to the “slightest degree,” was lower than the standard of impairment in Montana’s DUI statute requiring the driver’s ability be “diminished,” we determined “McNally’s prior convictions in Colorado do not constitute ‘convictionfs] for a violation of a similar statute . . . in another state,’ as required under
¶14 The Montana Legislature has also utilized the language, “similar statute,” relative to requirements for obtaining blood or breath tests where probable cause exists to suspect impaired driving. We begin with Montana’s statutory presumption of implied consent that “[a] person who operates or is in actual physical control of a vehicle upon ways of this state open to the public is considered to have given consent to a test or tests of the person’s blood or breath for the purpose of determining any measured amount or detected presence of alcohol or drugs in the person’s body.”
If the arrested person has refused to provide a breath, blood, or urine sample under 61-8-409 or this section in a prior investigation in this state or under a substantially similar statute in another jurisdiction or the arrested person has a prior conviction or pending offense for a violation of45-5-104 [negligent homicide], 45-5-106 [vehicular homicide while under the influence], 45-5-205 [negligent vehicular assault], 61-8-401 [DUI], 61-8-406 [DUI per se], or 61-8-411 [operating a vehicle under the influence of THC] or a similar statute in another jurisdiction, the officer may apply for a search warrant to be issued pursuant to46-5-224 to collect a sample of the person’s blood for testing.
¶15 The Legislature added
The question is: What do you do with these people who have figured out the game? That is—“If I refuse, they don’t have the evidence.” And you notice that the committee amended the bill for the repeat offenders just for that reason. Because there was a general idea that we shouldn’t do it for the first refusal. And what we got here is a bill to try to compel the person that fits the profile of the repeater to give evidence .... When you tell them “You either give us a breath test or we go to the judge and get a warrant [for your blood,]” they’re going to give you a breath test and that is the object of the exercise.1
¶16 This Court addressed a challenge to
¶17 Here, Williams contends McNally is not limited to sentencing and asserts that “Itlhere is no meaningful distinction between the sentencing enhancement statute [
¶18 Probable cause is required for a judge to issue a search warrant.
A judge shall issue a search warrant to a person upon application . . . made under oath or affirmation, that:
(1) states facts sufficient to support probable cause to believe that an offense has been committed;
(2) states facts sufficient to support probable cause to believe that evidence, contraband, or persons connected with the offense may be found;
(3) particularly describes the place, object, or persons to be searched; and
(4) particularly describes who or what is to be seized.
¶19 Williams does not dispute that he was convicted under Arizona Revised Statute § 28-1381 or argue that there were insufficient facts to demonstrate probable cause he was driving while impaired. Nor does Williams dispute the validity of Volinkaty’s observations. Williams’s entire argument is based upon Volinkaty’s inclusion in the affidavit of his prior Arizona conviction, which he maintains is not similar to any statute in Montana. Williams thus presents a challenge to the validity of Volinkaty’s affidavit. We adopted the Franks procedure for challenging the validity of a warrant affidavit in State v. Sykes, 194 Mont. 14, 20, 663 P.2d 691, 695 (1983); overruled on other grounds by State v. Long, 216 Mont. 65, 69, 700 P.2d 153, 156 (1985). “[A] warrant affidavit must set forth particular facts and circumstances underlying the existence of probable cause, so as to allow the magistrate to make an independent evaluation of the matter.” Franks v. Delaware, 438 U.S. 154, 165, 98 S. Ct. 2674, 2681 (1978). “There is, of course, a presumption of validity with respect to the affidavit supporting the search warrant.” Franks, 438 U.S. at 171, 98 S. Ct. at 2684. A “judge or magistrate is required to evaluate only the facts asserted within the four corners of a search warrant application. If inaccurate or misleading information
¶20 Our review, and that of the issuing judge, is constrained to the facts within the four corners of the affidavit and we decline to conduct a legal inquiry into the similarity of Montana’s statutes with those of Arizona. At a minimum, such an inquiry would require consideration of information not within the application and beyond the requirements for establishing probable cause. See Reesman, ¶ 24;
¶21 Finally, we would be remiss if we failed to note that conducting such an analysis would place an impractical or impossible burden on police officers and issuing judges prior to applying for or issuing a search warrant. Such a requirement would be time consuming and DUI investigations are time-sensitive by nature because the evidence of the offense metabolizes out of the driver’s bloodstream simply by the passage of time. We are also confident that if the Legislature is dissatisfied with our interpretation made here, it will exercise its authority and determine otherwise.
¶22 We conclude that conducting a “similarity” analysis of Arizona and Montana DUI statutes—a question purely of law—would go beyond the four corners of the affidavit. In the absence of inaccurate, misleading, or illegally obtained information, it was unnecessary to excise from the affidavit Volinkaty’s representations that Williams had a prior conviction in Arizona for DUI. The District Court did not err in denying Williams’s motion to suppress.
¶23 2. Whether the District Court erred in failing to consider the merits of Williams’s contention that he did not receive the implied consent advisory prior to his blood draw.
¶24 Williams argues generally that the warrant requirements were not met and that the City failed to demonstrate that they were met. Williams more specifically argues that Volinkaty failed to read the implied consent advisory. This failure, Williams argues, is fatal to the search warrant application’s validity. Williams also faults the District Court for failing to address this argument. The City responds that Williams failed to raise this issue in the Municipal Court and that issues raised for the first time on appeal are not addressed.
¶25 Those who operate a motor vehicle in the state of Montana have impliedly consented to submit to a blood or breath test for the purpose of determining the presence
¶26 “The rule is well established that this Court will not address an issue raised for the first time on appeal. The reason for the rule is that it is fundamentally unfair to fault the trial court for failing to rule on an issue it was never given the opportunity to consider.” State v. Gomez, 2007 MT 111, ¶ 21, 337 Mont. 219, 158 P.3d 442 (quotation and citations omitted). When the district court acted as an intermediate appellate court, we review the case as if the appeal was originally filed in this Court, examining the record independently of the district court’s decision. Stanley, ¶ 26.
¶27 Our review of the record reveals the only issue raised in the Municipal Court was whether “the blood evidence obtained pursuant to the search warrant should be suppressed because [Williams’s] previous conviction from Arizona does not qualify as a ‘similar’ offense under
CONCLUSION
¶28 The decision of the District Court affirming the Municipal Court’s denial of Williams’s motion to suppress is affirmed.
CHIEF JUSTICE McGRATH, JUSTICES SHEA and BAKER concur.Notes
Authorize Warrants to Obtain Blood or Breath Test in DUI Cases, Second Reading of Senate Bill 42, 62nd Leg., at 1:24:30-1:25:23 (2011) (statement of Sen. Larry Jent), available at https://perma.cc/D3BN-XH3X.
Notwithstanding the limitation on the issuing judge to the “four comers’ of the application, search warrants must be supported by probable cause—a different standard from preponderance of the evidence applicable to whether a conviction is valid for purposes of sentencing enhancement. State v. Maine, 2011 MT 90, ¶ 13, 360 Mont. 182, 255 P.3d 64; State v. Krebs, 2016 MT 288, ¶ 12, 385 Mont. 328, 384 P.3d 98. Probable cause, the standard upon which a search warrant may issue, is lower than a preponderance of the evidence, the standard required to establish the existence of prior convictions. Furthermore, probable cause is a less onerous standard than determining whether a prior conviction from a different state was pursuant to a “similar statute” for sentencing enhancement purposes. This Court will review a district court’s determinations of similarity to determine if its conclusions of law were correct as a matter of law. Our review under such circumstances is plenary. McNally, ¶ 5.
Concurrence Opinion
specially concurring.
¶29 I concur that the City’s application for a DUI search warrant stated sufficient probable cause to believe that Williams was driving under the influence of alcohol in violation of
¶30 Standing impassably in the path of affirming the Municipal Court’s search warrant under
¶31 As recognized by the Court, the mechanism for judicial review of the sufficiency of a search warrant application is our constitutionally-mandated Worrall standard of review requiring excise of inaccurate or misleading factual statements set forth in the original search warrant application and then reassessment of whether what remains is sufficient to establish probable cause for issuance of the warrant. Worrall, ¶¶ 32-33 (adopting Montana constitutional standard more stringent than federal Franks standard). If what remains in original application is not sufficient to establish the necessary probable cause, the reviewing court must void the warrant and suppress the fruits of the search. Worrall, ¶¶ 32-33.
¶32 If, as the Court implies, the validity of the Municipal Court’s search warrant depends on
¶33 The Court’s analysis avoids application of our Worrall standard, and with it any meaningful review of the State’s compliance with
¶34 Neither the obvious public policy importance of effective DUI investigation and prosecution, nor the practical inconvenience of requiring law enforcement to comply with a legal requirement imposed by the Legislature, have any proper place in the construction of the clear and unambiguous similarity requirement of
¶35 Proper resolution of this case merely requires recognition of the independent availability of unrestricted DUI-related search warrants under
(1) voluntary consent of the person to the implied consent request of a law enforcement officer for a preliminary breath test in the field on reasonable suspicion of a DUI-related offense,§ 61-8-409(4), MCA , and/or a more precise breath or blood test following the person’s arrest on probable cause of a DUI-related offense,§ 61-8-402(4), MCA ; and
(2) involuntary seizure and scientific analysis (search) of a person’s blood upon a search warrant issued pursuant to§ 46-5-221, MCA , on probable cause of criminal activity, whether DUI or non-DUI-related, and the presence of particularly described related evidence or contraband at or in a particularly described location.
As to the latter, unrestricted search warrants have always been available to law enforcement “on probable cause to believe that an offense has been committed” and that “evidence . . . connected with the offense may be found.”
¶36 In various forms since original enactment in 1971, Montana’s primary implied consent statute has allowed DUI suspects to refuse to submit to warrantless implied consent BAC tests subject only to temporary loss of driving privileges upon refusal. See
¶37 Nonetheless, despite clear and unequivocal statutory language to the contrary, widespread misconception has long existed that the limiting language of
¶38 However, upon our first opportunity to squarely construe the meaning of the limiting language in
¶39 In a well-intentioned effort to enhance effective enforcement of Montana’s DUI laws by closing a misperceived loophole protecting DUI-related offenders, the 2011 Legislature revised Montana’s implied consent statutes to expressly make post-refusal search warrants available to law enforcement to obtain otherwise unavailable BAC evidence against repeat DUI offenders.
¶40 In the continuing absence of any statutory provision handcuffing law enforcement by clearly and unequivocally limiting the longstanding independent availability of unrestricted DUI-related search warrants under
See
The statute setting forth probable cause grounds for search warrants was enacted as part of the Montana Code of Criminal Procedure, and codified as § 95-704, R.C.M. 1947 (1967 Mont. Laws 372), and renumbered as
Formerly numbered § 32-2142.1, R.C.M. 1947.
Montana’s supplemental implied consent statute authorizing warrantless preliminary alcohol screening tests (PAST) has always similarly provided that, “if a person refuses to submit to a test under this section, a test will not be given.”
See Hearing on S.B. 42, before the Mont. Sen. Jud. Comm., 62nd Leg. Reg. Sess. 00:43:37-01:23:14 (Jan. 20, 2011) and Hearing on S.B. 42 before the Mont. House Jud. Comm., 62nd Leg. Reg. Sess. 00:58:22-01:25:59 (March 17, 2011).
Aside from Collins’ manifestly limited scope and farther undermining it as authority aiding in the construction of
Under the misconception that DUI-related search warrants were not then available under existing law, and consistent with the express limiting language in the proposed new section,
[R]ight now, the way that the statutes are written, you cannot get a warrant from a court to draw blood from a suspect who the officer believes is impaired by alcohol or drugs.... What this does provide is a constitutional way for law enforcement to conduct a search to gather evidence against a person believed to have committed a crime.... [But] there’s a mulligan. I don’t golf, but I understand that if you golf and you mess up the first shot . . . it doesn’t count. And that’s what this is, a mulligan. This bill does not apply, you can’t get a warrant, unless the person has refused to cooperate with law enforcement before, refused to either blow or give blood, or has a . . . previous DUI, or is awaiting trial on DUI. In other words, this is the second mistake.
Hearing on S.B. 42, House Jud. Comm., 62nd Leg. Reg. See . . . 00:58:58-1:00:37 (March 17, 2011).