Christians v. Young
4:20-cv-04083
| D.S.D. | Nov 17, 2025
            .          UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT 
                        DISTRICT OF SOUTH DAKOTA 
|                                  SOUTHERN DIVISION 

MARK CHRISTIANS,                                 4:20-CV-04083-LLP 
                        Plaintiff, 
            vs.                            ORDER DENYING PLAINTIFF’S MOTION 
                                              TO COMPEL PRODUCTION OF 
DARIN YOUNG, in his individual capacity;          FINANCIAL INFORMATION FOR 
TROY PONTO, Deputy Warden SDSP,           PRISONER TRUST ACCOUNT REPORT 
individual capacity; JESSICA COOK, Associate  | AND DIRECTING PLAINTIFF TO FILE A 
Warden SDSP/Jameson, individual capacity;           CERTIFIED PRISONER TRUST 
BRENT FLUKE, Former Warden MDSP,                   ACCOUNT FORM 
individual capacity; REBECCA SCHIEFFER, 
Associate Warden MDSP, individual capacity; 
ALEX REYES, Associate Warden MDSP, 
individual capacity; SETH HUGHES, Unit 
Manager Jameson, individual capacity, NANCY 
CHRISTENSEN, Unit Manager MDSP, 
individual capacity; DEB EILERS, Unit 
Coordinator MDSP, individual capacity; 
LAURIE STRATMAN, Unit Coordinator 
MDSP, individual capacity; JULIE STEVENS, 
Case Manager MDSP, individual capacity;                    
ANGELA PECHOUS,  Unit Coordinator, 
individual capacity, GREASMAN, a/k/a ADAM 
SIMS, Correctional Officer, individual capacity; 
BRYAN MARJAMA, Correctional Officer,                                          □ 
individual capacity, KENDRICK WINTERS, 
Correctional Officer, individual capacity; 
ANGEL PADILLA, Correctional Officer, 
individual capacity, MATTHEW HULSCHER, 
Correctional Officer, individual capacity; 
JENNIFER DREISKE, Former Deputy Warden, 
individual capacity;  JORDAN BECKER, 
Lieutenant, individual capacity; PRESTON 
PERRET, Lieutenant, individual capacity, 
                        Defendants. 

 Plaintiff, Mark Christians, filed a pro se notice of appeal to the United States Court of 
Appeals for the Eighth Circuit. Doc. 589. Christians appeals from the July 24, 2025 judgment,! 
Doc. 535, as well as a number of other orders entered prior to the judgment, see Doc. 589. 
Christians filed a motion for leave to proceed in forma pauperis on appeal, Doc. 590, but the 
Prisoner Trust Account Report he filed, Doc. 591, is not complete. Christians contends that he 
“4s having difficulty working with staff to obtain the proper signatures with six months worth of 
statements.” Doc. 592 at 1 (capitalization in original omitted). Christians moves for an order 
compelling the South Dakota Department of Corrections (SDDOC) to provide the necessary 
financial information to complete his Prisoner Trust Account. Jd. In his motion, Christians notes 
that the Court has previously ordered the SDDOC to provide to him a  certified prisoner trust 
account report form and copies of his last six months of financial statements or demonstrate good 
cause for their failure to do so. Doc. 405 at 3; Christians v. Christensen, 4:22-CV-04072-LLP, 
Doc. 121 at 2-3 (D.S.D. May 15, 2025). But Christians does not acknowledge that this Court 
ordered the SDDOC to provide a complete, certified prisoner trust account form and copies of 
the last six months of financial information because Christian had provided specific evidence 
detailing his unsuccessful efforts to obtain a certified prisoner trust account form and supporting 
financial statements without Court intervention. See Docs. 402, 402-1, 403; Christians v. 
Christensen, 4:22-CV-04072-LLP, at Docs. 117, 117-2, 118. In support of his pending motion, 
Christians provides no evidence that he has attempted without success to obtain a certified 
prisoner trust account form and supporting financial statements without Court intervention. See 
Does. 592, 593. Christians alleges that he has been subjected to retaliation since 2018, which, if 

 1 Defendants’ Motion for Judgment as a Matter of Law under Rule 50(b), Doc. 551, and 
Motion to Amend/Correct Judgment to Set Aside Punitive Damage Award under Rule 59, Doc. 
  remain pending.

true, is a serious allegation. See Doc. 592. But because Christians has provided no supporting 
evidence that he has attempted without success to obtain a certified prisoner trust account form 
and supporting financial statements, Christians’ motion to compel production of financial 
information for prisoner trust account report, Doc. 592, is denied. Christians’ assertion that he is 
currently in the segregated housing unit due to attempts to have documents notarized and to 
submit a prisoner trust account report, in the absence of specific, detailed evidence like he 
provided in support of his previous motions, is speculative and insufficient to warrant Court 
intervention. 
 Under the Prison Litigation Reform Act (PLRA), a prisoner who “brings a  civil action or 
files an appeal in forma pauperis . . . shall be required to pay the full amount of a filing fee.”
28 U.S.C. § 1915
(b)(1). “[T]he assessment of appellate filing fees occurs upon the filing of a notice 
of appeal . . . and fixes responsibility for payment sooner rather than later of the fees in full.” 
Henderson v. Norris,
129 F.3d 481, 484
 (8th Cir. 1997) (per curiam). “Irrespective of the court’s 
approach to the merits of the appeal, the prisoner’s liability for the full payment of the appellate     - 
filing fees under the PLRA continues until full payment has been made which may be long after . 

. . dispos[al] of the appeal.” /d. Pursuant to
28 U.S.C. § 1915
(b)(2), a prisoner may pay the full 
amount of the filing fee in installments. If Christians seeks to pay the appellate filing fee in           

installments, he must submit a certified prisoner trust account report for the last six months onor 
before December 12, 2025. Accordingly, it is 
 ORDERED that Christians’ motion to compel production of financial information for 
prisoner trust account report, Doc. 592, is denied. It is further 
 ORDERED that Christians must pay the full $605 appellate filing fee. It is finally

 ORDERED that if Christians seeks to pay the appellate filing fee in installments, he must 
submit a  certified prisoner trust account for the last six months on or before December 12, 2025. 
If Christians does not timely comply with this Order, the Court will calculate the initial appellate 
partial filing fee at $35 or such other reasonable amount warranted by available information. 
After calculating the initial appellate partial filing fee, the Court will order payment of the full 
appellate filing fee pursuant to the installment payment provisions of
28 U.S.C. § 1915
(b)(2). 
 DATED this   _||“day of November, 2025. 

                               BY THE utd 
                               Ln L. PIERSOL 
                               United States District Judge