Christian v. MurrayChristian v. Murray
- Reporters:
- ,
- Before:
- See Justice., Nabers, Harwood, Stuart, Bolin
Marie Roberts Christian died on December 24, 2001. On January 28, 2002, AmSouth Bank petitioned the Tuscaloosa Probate Court to probate what it believed to be Ms. Christian‘s last will; that will was dated May 24, 1988 (“the May will“).1 On March 11, 2002, the May will was admitted to probate and letters testamentary were issued appointing AmSouth Bank the executor of Ms. Christian‘s estate. After the expiration of the statutory six-month nonclaims period,
“Except to the extent the law may impute possession to an executor prior to its appointment as such, the executor [AmSouth] did not have custody or possession of the [t]runk prior to the filing of the petition to probate the Former Will or the granting of letters testamentary under the [May 1988] Will. After letters testamentary were granted and prior to distribution of the personal effects, the executor had custody or possession of Ms. Christian‘s personal effects, including the [t]runk.”
On November 4, 2002, the beneficiary to whom the trunk was distributed found inside the trunk another will of Marie Roberts Christian dated August 5, 1988 (“the August will“), and a codicil to that will dated June 20, 1996.2 The distributions under the August will and 1996 codicil differ from the distributions under the May will. The parties have stipulated that “[t]here is presently no evidence existing indicating that the executor [AmSouth]
AmSouth Bank filed a complaint in the Tuscaloosa Circuit Court for a judgment declaring which will should control the distribution of Ms. Christian‘s estate (case no. CV-03-62). AmSouth also petitioned the probate court to transfer the proceedings relating to the estate to the Tuscaloosa Circuit Court (case no. CV-03-343). Mallory H. Murray and John R. Humphrey then sued AmSouth Bank and potential beneficiaries of Ms. Christian‘s estate, including Thomas Richard Christian, a beneficiary under the May will, seeking an order setting aside the order of the probate court admitting the May will to probate (case no. CV-03-296). The probate proceedings were transferred to the Tuscaloosa Circuit Court, which consolidated the three cases, allowed AmSouth to opt out of the proceedings,3 and invited the parties to realign themselves according to which will they favored. Mallory H. Murray and other proponents of the August will and 1996 codicil aligned as plaintiffs (“the Murray plaintiffs“). Thomas Richard Christian and other proponents of the May will aligned as defendants (“the Christian defendants“).
The Murray plaintiffs moved for a summary judgment on all claims. The Christian defendants also moved for a summary judgment, arguing that all claims asserted by the Murray plaintiffs were, in legal effect, will contests and that they were, therefore, barred by the statutory six-month period within which to file a will contest. See
The Christian defendants argue that the trial court erred in entering a partial summary judgment in favor of the Murray plaintiffs because, they argue, the Murray plaintiffs were not entitled to a judgment as a matter of law. Specifically, the Christian defendants argue that the Murray plaintiffs’ action challenging the admission of the May will to probate is barred by the time limitations of
Where the facts are not in dispute and we are presented with a pure question of law, as here, this Court‘s review is de novo. See State v. American Tobacco Co., 772 So.2d 417, 419 (Ala. 2000); Ex parte Graham, 702 So.2d 1215, 1221 (Ala. 1997); Beavers v. County of Walker, 645 So.2d 1365, 1372 (Ala. 1994).
The Murray plaintiffs argued that their action was not only a will contest but that they were also seeking relief under
The Christian defendants argue that the Murray plaintiffs’ will contest was time-barred.
“Any person interested in any will who has not contested the same under the provisions of this article, may, at any time within the six months after the admission of such will to probate in this state, contest the validity of the same by filing a complaint in the circuit court in the county in which such will was probated.”
The statute allows a will contest to be brought in the circuit court after a will has been admitted to probate. This statutory right has existed in this State since 1806, “having undergone a change in phraseology, but not in meaning, in passing through our various Codes enacted since that time.”5 Watson, 89 Ala. at 224-25, 8 So. at 20. Prior to the enactment of the statute, the probate courts had inherent jurisdiction “to set aside the probate of a will at any time upon the discovery of a posterior will of the testator, and upon proper proof of its execution by the testator.” Watson, 89 Ala. at 225, 8 So. at 20.
This Court stated in Hardy v. Hardy‘s Heirs, 26 Ala. 524 (1855), that the will-contest statute (1) conferred upon courts of equity the exclusive jurisdiction to entertain will contests; (2) stripped the probate court of its ancient jurisdiction to set aside the probate of a former will and to permit the probate of a later one; and (3) barred any will contest in either forum after five years (now six months). Because a circuit court‘s jurisdiction over a will contest is statutorily conferred and limited, a proceeding initiated under
The May will was admitted to probate on March 11, 2002. Thus, when the August will and 1996 codicil were discovered in November 2002, the six-month period for contesting the May will provided for by
The Murray plaintiffs argued to the trial court, and the trial court agreed, that the time to file the will contest was tolled by the application of the fraud provision found in
“Whenever fraud has been perpetrated in connection with any proceeding or in any statement filed under this chapter [the Probate Code] or if fraud is used to avoid or circumvent the provisions of purposes of this chapter [the Probate Code], any person injured thereby may obtain appropriate relief against the perpetrator of the fraud or restitution from any person (other than a bona fide purchaser) benefitting from the fraud, whether innocent or not.”
The Court of Civil Appeals has held that appropriate relief for one injured by the fraud contemplated by
Section
The Murray plaintiffs argue that, because Alabama law recognizes a cause of action for innocent fraud, AmSouth‘s conduct should toll the time within which they could file a will contest.
“The key factor in analyzing this case is not simply that a subsequently executed New Will existed, but that the subsequent Will was in the possession or control of the petitioner of the previously admitted Will during the contest period. Because of the possession, I find that the petitioner had sufficient constructive `knowledge’ of the New Will for suppression to have occurred. Conversely, there could be no finding of innocent suppression (legal fraud) if the New Will had not been in AmSouth‘s possession during the contest period, as there would be no `knowledge.‘”
Although Alabama does recognize a cause of action for innocent fraud, there is no indication in the Probate Code that innocent fraud will toll the time for filing a will contest. Section
“This Court has defined `fraud upon the court’ as that species of fraud that defiles or attempts to defile the court itself or that is a fraud perpetrated by an officer of the court, and it does not include fraud among the parties, without more.” Waters v. Jolly, 582 So.2d 1048, 1055 (Ala. 1991) (citing Brown v. Kingsberry Mortgage Co., 349 So.2d 564 (Ala. 1977), and Spindlow v. Spindlow, 512 So.2d 918 (Ala.Civ.App. 1987)). Black‘s Law Dictionary 686 (8th ed. 2004) defines “fraud on the court” as follows: “In a judicial proceeding, a lawyer‘s or party‘s misconduct so serious that it undermines or is intended to undermine the integrity of the proceeding.” See Ex parte Free, 910 So.2d 753 (Ala. 2005). The cases in which fraud on the court has been found, for the most part, have been cases in which there was “the most egregious conduct involving a corruption of the judicial process itself,” such as the bribery of a judge or the employment of counsel to improperly influence the court. 11 Charles A. Wright et al., Federal Practice Procedure Civ.2d § 2870 (1995).
As noted earlier, the parties stipulated to the following facts regarding AmSouth‘s conduct:
“Except to the extent the law may impute possession to an executor prior to its appointment as such, the executor [AmSouth] did not have custody or possession of the [t]runk prior to the filing of the petition to probate the Former Will or the granting of letters testamentary under the [May] Will. After letters testamentary were granted and prior to distribution of the personal effects, the executor had custody or possession of Ms. Christian‘s personal effects, including the [t]runk.”
In addition, the parties stipulated that “[t]here is presently no evidence existing indicating that the executor [AmSouth] had actual knowledge of the existence of the [August will and 1996 codicil] prior to approximately November 4, 2002.”
AmSouth‘s conduct does not fit within the definition of fraud on the court. The facts to which the parties have stipulated indicate that AmSouth had no intent to defile the probate court or to corrupt the
Courts are to weigh the interest of justice against the need for finality of judgments in examining a claim of fraud on the court. Waters, 582 So.2d at 1055. The resulting injustice is that the true last wishes of Marie Roberts Christian, although conceded by all the parties to be stated in the August will and the 1996 codicil, will not now be honored. However, the interest in finality of the probate court‘s judgment admitting the May will to probate is also great, as expressed by the act of the Legislature to limit the time for filing a will contest and to limit it to six months. See
REVERSED AND REMANDED.
NABERS, C.J., and HARWOOD, STUART, and BOLIN, JJ., concur.
Notes
Code of Alabama 1886, § 2000. See Watson v. Turner, 89 Ala. at 225, 8 So. at 20.“Any person interested in any will, who has not contested the same under the provisions of this article, may, at any time within five years after the admission of such will to probate in this state, contest the validity of the same by bill in chancery, in the district in which such will was probated, or in the district in which a material defendant resides.”
“After the death of a testator and on request of any interested person, any person having custody of a will of the testator shall deliver it with reasonable promptness to a person able to secure its probate and if none is known, to an appropriate