Charbarneau v. UtterCharbarneau v. Utter
- Reporters:
ORDER
Plaintiff Shelby C. Charbarneau, an inmate confined at Green Bay Correctional Institution (“GBCI“), filed a pro se complaint under
1. MOTION FOR LEAVE TO PROCEED WITHOUT PREPAYING THE FILING FEE
The Prison Litigation Reform Act (“PLRA“) applies to this case because Plaintiff was a prisoner when he filed his complaint. See
On May 26, 2026, the Court ordered Plaintiff to pay an initial partial filing fee of $0.00. ECF No. 7. The Court will grant Plaintiff‘s motion for
2. SCREENING THE COMPLAINT
2.1 Federal Screening Standard
Under the PLRA, the Court must screen complaints brought by prisoners seeking relief from a governmental entity or an officer or employee of a governmental entity.
In determining whether the complaint states a claim, the Court applies the same standard that applies to dismissals under
To state a claim for relief under
2.2 Plaintiff‘s Allegations
Plaintiff names Defendants H. Utter (“Utter“), C. Baier (“Baier“), G. Trzebiatowski (“Trzebiatowski“), J. Koehler (“Koehler“), Swiekatowski, J. Pertru (“Pertru“), R. Hoffmann (“Hoffmann“), and M. Prebeg (“Prebeg“). ECF No. 1 at 1. Plaintiff‘s allegations stem from the staff at GBCI denying him a bottom-bunk restriction. Id. at 2. Plaintiff suffers from back and sciatic nerve problems. Id. GBCI bunk beds do not have ladders or safety guards on them. Id. Due to Plaintiff‘s medical condition, he was having a hard time getting down from his bunk bed and therefore requested a bottom-bunk restriction. Id. Each named defendant denied Plaintiff‘s request for a bottom-bunk restriction despite knowledge of his medical issues. Id. Afterwards and because of the denial, Plaintiff fell from his bunk bed and hit his head. Id. Plaintiff‘s injuries included a large laceration on his head that required nine staples to close. Id.
2.3 Analysis
The Court will allow Plaintiff to proceed on an Eighth Amendment claim against all defendants for their deliberate indifference to Plaintiff‘s serious medical need. A prison official violates the Eighth Amendment where he is deliberately indifferent “to serious medical needs of prisoners.” Estelle v. Gamble, 429 U.S. 97, 104 (1976). To state a claim, Skiff must allege facts from which the Court can infer that: (1) he had an objectively serious
The Court will allow Plaintiff to proceed against Defendants for their failure to provide Plaintiff with a medically necessary low-bunk restriction. Plaintiff alleges that he required a low-bunk restriction based on his medical condition. He further alleges that he told Defendants about his condition, and they denied him a low bunk-restriction. As a result of the denial, Plaintiff fell from his bunk bed and was physically injured. At the pleading stage, the Court finds Plaintiff‘s allegations sufficient to proceed against Utter, Baier, Trzebiatowski, Koehler, Swiekatowski, Pertru, Hoffmann, and Prebeg.
The Court will also allow Plaintiff to proceed against Utter, Baier, Trzebiatowski, Koehler, Swiekatowski, Pertru, Hoffmann, and Prebeg on a state law claim for negligence. At this early stage, the Court will exercise its supplemental jurisdiction under
3. CONCLUSION
In light of the foregoing, the Court finds that Plaintiff may proceed on the following claims pursuant to
Claim One: Eighth Amendment claim against Utter, Baier, Trzebiatowski, Koehler, Swiekatowski, Pertru, Hoffmann, and Prebeg for deliberate indifference to Plaintiff‘s serious medical need to have a low-bunk restriction.
Claim Two: State law negligence claim against Utter, Baier, Trzebiatowski, Koehler, Swiekatowski, Pertru, Hoffmann, and Prebeg.
The Court has enclosed with this Order guides prepared by court staff to address common questions that arise in cases filed by prisoners. These guides are entitled, “Answers to Prisoner Litigants’ Common Questions” and “Answers to Pro Se Litigants’ Common Questions.” They contain information that Plaintiff may find useful in prosecuting his case.
Defendants should take note that, within forty-five (45) days of service of this Order, they are to file a summary judgment motion that raises all exhaustion-related challenges. The Court will issue a scheduling order at a later date that embodies other relevant deadlines.
Accordingly,
IT IS ORDERED that Plaintiff‘s motion for leave to proceed without prepaying the filing fee, ECF No. 2, be and the same is hereby GRANTED;
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that under an informal service agreement between the Wisconsin Department of Justice and this Court, a copy of the complaint and this Order have been electronically transmitted
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that under the informal service agreement, those Defendants shall file a responsive pleading to the complaint within sixty (60) days;
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that Defendants raise any exhaustion-related challenges by filing a motion for summary judgment within forty-five (45) days of service;
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED if Defendants contemplate a motion to dismiss, the parties must meet and confer before the motion is filed. Defendants should take care to explain the reasons why they intend to move to dismiss the complaint, and Plaintiff should strongly consider filing an amended complaint. The Court expects this exercise in efficiency will obviate the need to file most motions to dismiss. Indeed, when the Court grants a motion to dismiss, it typically grants leave to amend unless it is “certain from the face of the complaint that any amendment would be futile or otherwise unwarranted.” Harris v. Meisner, No. 20-2650, 2021 WL 5563942, at *2 (7th Cir. Nov. 29, 2021) (quoting Runnion ex rel. Runnion v. Girl Scouts of Greater Chi. & Nw. Ind., 786 F.3d 510, 524 (7th Cir. 2015)). Therefore, it is in both parties’ interest to discuss the matter prior to motion submissions. Briefs in support of, or opposition to, motions to dismiss should cite no more than ten (10) cases per claim. No string citations will be accepted. If Defendant files a motion to dismiss, Plaintiff is hereby warned that he must file a response, in accordance with Civil Local Rule 7 (E.D. Wis.), or he may be deemed to have waived any argument against dismissal and face dismissal of this matter with prejudice;
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that the agency having custody of Plaintiff shall collect from his institution trust account the $350.00 balance of the filing fee by collecting monthly payments from Plaintiff‘s prison trust account in an amount equal to 20% of the preceding month‘s income credited to Plaintiff‘s trust account and forwarding payments to the Clerk of Court each time the amount in the account exceeds $10 in accordance with
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that a copy of this Order be sent to the officer in charge of the agency where Plaintiff is confined; and
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that the Clerk‘s Office mail Plaintiff a copy of the guides entitled “Answers to Prisoner Litigants’ Common Questions” and “Answers to Pro Se Litigants’ Common Questions,” along with this Order.
Dated at Milwaukee, Wisconsin, this 9th day of October, 2026.
BY THE COURT:
J. P. Stadtmueller
U.S. District Judge
Plaintiffs who are inmates at all other prison facilities, or who have been released from custody, will be required to submit all correspondence and legal material to:
Office of the Clerk
United States District Court
Eastern District of Wisconsin
362 United States Courthouse
517 E. Wisconsin Avenue
Milwaukee, Wisconsin 53202
DO NOT MAIL ANYTHING DIRECTLY TO THE COURT‘S CHAMBERS. If mail is received directly to the Court‘s chambers, IT WILL BE RETURNED TO SENDER AND WILL NOT BE FILED IN THE CASE.
Plaintiff is further advised that failure to timely file any brief, motion, response, or reply may result in the dismissal of this action for failure to prosecute. In addition, the parties must notify the Clerk of Court of any change of address. IF PLAINTIFF FAILS TO PROVIDE AN UPDATED ADDRESS TO THE COURT AND MAIL IS RETURNED TO THE COURT AS UNDELIVERABLE, THE COURT WILL DISMISS THIS ACTION WITHOUT PREJUDICE.