Carroll v. KrauseCarroll v. Krause
- Reporters:
- , ,
- Before:
- Wolfe
delivered the opinion of the court.
This is an action to recover damages for the death of Gregory Carroll resulting from a collision of an automobile (in which he was riding as a guest) and the defendant’s truck on State Highway No. 4, a short distance south of Joliet, between the hours of 12:00 and 1:00 o ’clock a. m., on August 1,1929. In a former trial there was a verdict and judgment. for the plaintiff, which judgment was reversed and a new trial ordered by this court for errors in the evidence. (Carroll v. Krause, 280 Ill. App. 52.) A second trial resulted in a verdict and judgment for the plaintiff, and the defendant appealed to this court. Both trials were in the circuit court of Peoria county.
In our former opinion we held that the transcript of testimony, taken before the coroner at the inquest, was inadmissible as evidence for the purpose of impeachment, because the certificate to the transcript did not show that the testimony was reduced to writing as required by the terms of section 18 of ch. 31, Cahill’s Ill. St. 1933, ¶ 19. Before the second trial, the plaintiff, by oral examination, took the depositions of Dr. A. A. Kingston, the coroner, and Mrs. Grace Thomas, the stenographer, to prove that the testimony given at the inquest was taken in shorthand and transcribed by a competent person. The attorney for the defendant was present when the depositions were taken and took part in the examination of the deponents.
At the trial the depositions were opened in the presence of counsel. A hearing was had before the judge (in the absence of the jury) on the question of the admissibility of
Dr. Kingston stated in substance, that he presided at the inquest on the body of Gregory Carroll; that a stenographer, Mrs. Grace Thomas, wrote down the testimony of each witness at the inquest; that he thereafter certified to the correctness of the transcript of the testimony in a form not in conformity with the statute; that he had with him an amended coroner’s certificate and an amended certificate of the stenographer, both of which he intended to attach to the original transcript of the testimony.
Mrs. Thomas (whose qualifications as a competent person to take the testimony of the witnesses at the inquest in shorthand and transcribe them as required by statute, is not questioned) stated that she took the testimony of the witnesses and transcribed the same, and that she had with her an amended certificate made by her which was to be attached to the original transcript.
The testimony given before the coroner was admitted on the taking of the deposition of Dr. Kingston as Exhibit 1, and it forms a part of his deposition. When the deposition of Mrs. Thomas was taken, the plaintiff’s attorney had before him the transcript of the testimony taken at the inquest. The testimony of Wehnes at the inquest was embodied in the Thomas deposition by the attorney’s direct interrogatories, seriatim, whether Wehnes, at the inquest, had been asked and answered the questions as they appeared in the trqngcript. To each question Mrs, Thomas answered, “Yes,
At the hearing before the trial judge, the amended certificates to the transcript and both depositions were admitted before the court, as containing competent evidence to be used at the trial before the jury for impeachment purposes. The plaintiff offered to introduce the entire depositions of Dr. Kingston and Mrs. Thomas before the jury, to which the defendant objected. The plaintiff then offered certain parts of Mrs. Thomas’ deposition before the jury as impeachment of defendant’s witness Wehnes. The court held that the offer was proper. The deposition of Dr. Kingston was not offered in evidence before the jury. Exhibit No. 1 was not offered as evidence on the trial. It is clear from a reading of the discussion and rulings heard and made before the court, that the judge understood that the deponent Thomas in her deposition, testified that Wehnes had made the answers as they appear in Exhibit No. 1 and in her deposition.
After considerable discussion as to what part of the depositions should be offered, the trial was resumed. Mr. Eyan read questions and answers to the jury from the deposition, in the same form as they were read before the judge at the hearing. It is contended that the impeaching evidence so brought before the jury consists of self-serving questions and answers of the attorney who examined Mrs. Thomas when her deposition was taken, and there was no proof before the jury that Wehnes had testified at the inquest as shown by the questions and answers read from the deposition. It is also contended that if that part of the deposition which states that Wehnes had been asked and had answered the questions at the inquest, that had been read to the jury, the defendant would have offered in evidence the cross-examination of Mrs. Thomas, as it appears in the deposition, for the purpose of discrediting or weakening her affirmative statement that the questions and answers were part of Wehnes’ testimony before the coroner.
The transcript of the testimony taken at the inquest was the best evidence of Wehnes’ testimony at the inquest. (Overtoom v. Chicago & E. I. R. Co., 181 Ill. 323, cited in Carroll v. Krause, supra. See also Briggs v. People, 219 Ill. 330; Goldstein v. Chicago City Ry. Co., 210 Ill. App. 48.) No objection was made that Mrs. Thomas had no independent recollection of Wehnes’ testimony before the coroner. It is not shown that the amended certificates to the transcript are irregular or not in conformity to the statute, nor that the amendments were improperly made. There was no objection that the part of the deposition of Mrs. Thomas offeréd and received in evidence, was not the best evidence. The defendant had the right to offer the whole or
It is also contended that the evidence toward which the impeaching testimony is directed was brought out on cross-examination of Wehnes at the trial, and therefore not subject to impeachment by the plaintiff. Reference is made to our former opinion after the first trial of this case. (280 Ill. App. 52.) It is clear from that opinion that the position of the truck on the highway and if the rear lamp on the truck was lighted at the time of the collision, were material issues in the case. In his direct evidence on the second trial, Wehnes testified fully on the question of whether the lamp was lighted; of the width of the macadam; that the truck, after its rear tire blew out, was stopped on the east side of the macadam, the right wheels of the truck then being on the right side of the road; that the right wheels of the truck were on the east edge of the macadam; that he went to the rear of the truck while it was standing in that place, stayed there a few minutes and then returned to the cab of the truck; that about 18 feet of space of the macadam was open for travel west of the truck. He testified, “I would say 15 or 20 cars passed in both directions on the west side of the truck; I remember a car and a truck passed abreast. The deputies asked me to move the truck and I told them that I could not move it, and about eight men got
The following questions and answers were read from the deposition of Mrs. Thomas as impeaching evidence of Wehnes testimony at the trial: Q. And how close were you to the right-hand side of the road, the east side of the road, when your car came to a stop? A. Do you mean to the edge of the macadam? Q. Yes. A. Couple of feet. Q. When you looked out you were riding on the right-hand side? A. Yes. Q. Do you mean a couple of feet from the running board? A. The wheel was about two feet from the edge though. Q. Were there any cars going by you, north, passing in the same direction you were going while he was there with you? A. 1 judge a half a dozen. Q. Was there any officer of the law who came there at the time ? A. Yes. Q. Who was it? A. I could not say. Q. What occurred? A. They come back and looked at the taillight and had me pull off the road, asked me if I could drive and I told them I could, and they told me to pull off. I said I could not for fear it would upset, and so five or six fellows got on one side and said they would hold it up and I should yell when ready, so I did. Q. How far did you pull it off? A. Twenty feet. Q. Why did you get out in the rear of the truck and stay there for 15 minutes? A. I was standing there smoking a cigarette. Q. Were any cars approaching? A. Yes. Q. Isn’t it true that as these cars approached, you warned them of this truck being parked on the side? A. I stood back there and smoked. They all swung around and went by. Did not pay attention to me. Q. You were standing there warning them how far south of the truck? A. Seventy-five feet.
The question of the place of the truck on the highway at the time of the collision, as has been stated, was pertinent to the issues in the case, and its location was
The following questions and answers were also read from the deposition for the purpose of impeaching Wehnes. Q. What kind of car was it? A. Essex. Q. Coach? A. Yes. Q. How many in it? A. Three. Q. Where were they when you first saw them after the accident? A. Two in front and one in the rear. Q. Sitting in the car? A. Yes.
On his direct examination at the trial, Wehnes testified :1 ‘ There was a rear view mirror located on the left side and extended out far enough so that you could see past the body of the truck. I sat there (in the cab of the truck) a few minutes and I heard a car coming down the road. I looked up at the mirror and saw this car coming down the road and what attracted my attention was the noise it made; that is what made me look back to see what it was, and I saw it was a car coming. It seemed to be coming at a high rate of speed and I watched the car through the mirror. . . . I found out later it was an Essex coach.” Q. “What else did not notice, if anything, about the Essex car — the car you later found out to be the Essex — as it came up the road prior to the time of the crash?” A. “It only had one headlight, I noticed that.” Wehnes did not testify at the inquest that the Essex car had only one headlight as it approached the stalled truck.
It is contended by the defendant that the questions and answers were inadmissible as impeaching evidence
It is also contended by the defendant that the court erred in admitting the photographs in evidence which this court held improperly admitted at the former trial. (280 Ill. App. 52.) At the second trial there was no testimony that the brick which appears on the highway in the pictures, marked the place where the truck stood on the highway according to the opinion of one of plaintiff’s witnesses. The pictures were introduced in evidence with the statement of plaintiff’s counsel and the admonition of the court, that the jury should disregard the location of any movable objects, which appear in the pictures. It is not contended that the pictures do not otherwise show the condition of the highway as it was at the time of the collision. The defendant introduced photographs taken by the same photographer who took the pictures introduced in evidence by the plaintiff. All the pictures were taken on the same day. The preliminary proof, as to the conditions not being changed on the highway during the time between the accident and the date (August 3, 1929) when the pictures were taken, is substantially the same. This evidence was competent and properly admitted.
It is also contended by the defendant that the verdict on the material issues as to whether the plaintiff was guilty of actionable negligence and the defendant free
It is clear from the testimony of the witnesses, both for the plaintiff and the defendant, that the defendant left the truck standing on a traveled part of macadam, after the tire blew out. Whether or not it was left there, owing to an emergency, it was the duty of the defendant to display a light on the rear of the truck or to take other reasonable precautions to warn travelers on the highway of the presence of the truck. The gravamen, therefore, of the charge of negligence against the defendant is the lack of ordinary care exercised by him in that respect. Specifically, on the charge of actionable negligence, the contention between the parties is the question of whether the lamp oh the rear of the truck was lighted at the time of the collision.
In our former opinion (280 Ill. App. 52) we stated some of the general facts as follows: “The evidence discloses that on the evening of July 31,1929, appellant (defendant) accompanied by Ralph Wehnes was driving his Reo two-ton truck, which was loaded with tomatoes and sweet corn destined for the Chicago market, along Route No. 4. He had proceeded to within approximately a mile south of Joliet when the right rear tire on his truck blew out. There was a gap in the pavement extending several hundred feet and it was just about the time the truck left the concrete pavement and entered the macadam that he had his tire trouble. Appellant proceeded to stop his truck and when it came to a stop the right wheels thereof were near the edge of the macadam and the left wheels not far from the center thereof. The truck was jacked up and the tire and rim taken off and it was in that position when Gerald Staab, a brother-in-law of appellant, came along in another truck and a part of the load from appellant’s truck was transferred to the truck being-driven by Staab. An unsuccessful effort was made to use a spare tire
Before the collision occurred, two groups of persons had attended separate social affairs a few miles south of Joliet and they were returning to Joliet on Highway No. 4 at the time of the accident. One group had been at a supper in a summer cabin, while the other group had attended a dance. Those persons, five in number, who were at the supper were riding in three automobiles. The others who were at the dance, three young men with their girl friends, were riding in a car driven by one of the young men. Some of those persons who were at the supper were the first to arrive at the place of the accident and all of them arrived there very shortly after the collision. Those who arrived first were witnesses for the plaintiff and testified that the rear lamp on the truck was not lighted when they arrived where the collision occurred. Two of these witnesses for the plaintiff testified that they went to the rear of the truck and examined the lamp and that it was not lighted. The young men also arrived very shortly after the accident. They were witnesses for the defendant. All testified that the car they were in stopped back of the truck; that they saw the rear lamp on the truck lighted and it shone red. Other witnesses testified that no rear light was burning and others that it was.
The direct evidence as to whether the rear lamp was burning at the time of the accident, is in conflict. The
It is also contended by the defendant that the plaintiff’s intestate was guilty of contributory negligence because the Essex coach had only one headlight before and at the time of the accident and that the driver of the coach at the time of the accident was driving the car with the headlights (or headlight, as the case may be) not burning brightly, but dimmed. It is contended by defendant that the question of whether the decedent was guilty of contributory negligence involves the point as to whether the decedent was negligent, as a matter of law, in riding with the driver of the Essex coach for some time before the accident, with the headlights of the coach dimmed.
As stated, it is contended by the defendant that the decedent was guilty as a matter of law of contributory negligence in riding in the Essex coach before and at the time of the accident, because the car was, before and at the time of the accident, being driven with dim. lights.
Ferry, the driver of the Essex car, testified that for some hours before, and at the time of the accident, he was driving the car with dimmers; that at the time of the collision he was driving the car at the speed of about 35 to 40 miles per hour.; that he did not see the truck before the collision until he was about’ 20 feet from it; that he could see ahead with the lights dimmed, .about 50 feet. Sexton, who was riding with Ferry, testified that the lights on the car threw‘a beam of light about 10 to 15 feet ahead of the car. The first witness to approach the stalled truck after the accident was driving a Ford car with bright headlights. She testified
At the time of the collision there was in force section 16 of the Motor Vehicle Act, in part as follows: “When upon any public highway of this State, during the period from one hour after sunset to sunrise, every motor bicycle shall carry one lighted lamp and every motor vehicle two lighted lamps showing white lights, or lights of yellow or amber tint, visible at least two hundred (200) feet in the direction toward which each motor vehicle . . . is proceeding.” Cahill’s Ill. St. 1931, ch. 95a, ¶ 17. It has been held that this statutory provision is for the benefit not only of those who are using the highway ahead of the motor vehicle, but also to enable those driving the car to avoid accidents. Miller
It is contended by the defendant that the court erred in giving plaintiff’s Instruction No. 10. This instruction informed the jury that the declaration consists of four counts and that it was not necessary for a recovery on the part of the plaintiff that she prove all of said counts, but that if she proved one or more of them by a preponderance of the evidence, then the jury should find for the plaintiff. The purpose of the instruction, as is plain from its terms, was to instruct the jury that the plaintiff did not have to prove all the charges of negligence contained in the separate counts of the declaration in order to recover damages of the defendant, but that proof of one of the charges was sufficient. This instruction sets forth the allegations of the counts and states that the declaration contains the allegation: “While said Gregory Carroll was in the exercise of
It is also contended by the defendant that the court erred by refusing to give Instruction No. 13 offered by the defendant. This instruction provides, among other things, that if the decedent at the time of the accident was riding in an automobile driven by Ferry in “a careless, negligent, and improper manner” and bad been riding in the automobile for a sufficient time prior to the accident, in the exercise of ordinary prudence, to become aware that the automobile was being driven in such ‘ ‘ a careless, negligent, and improper manner, ’ ’ and that decedent failed to protest or warn the driver against the manner in which he was driving the automobile, and that such failure of decedent caused or proximately contributed to the cause of the accident, the jury should find for the defendant. Where the court directs a particular verdict, if the jury find certain facts, the instruction must embrace all the facts and conditions essential to such verdict. Illinois Iron & Metal Co. v. Webber, 196 Ill. 526. The words of the instruction that if the car was being driven “in a careless, negligent and improper manner,” failed to inform the jury that such driving of the car must have been of such
It is contended by the defendant that the counsel for the plaintiff was guilty of misconduct during the examinations of witnesses and also in his argument before the jury, which was of such a character as to be prejudicial to the rights of the defendant for a fair trial and constituting ground for reversal of the judgment. The alleged misconduct during the examinations of witnesses concerned the admission of evidence, and we do not observe that counsel for plaintiff exceeded his rights to insist upon the admission of evidence which he thought was competent under his conception of the law. The alleged misconduct during his argument by counsel for the plaintiff was relative to whether a certain line of argument of plaintiff’s counsel was supported by the evidence. There had been a dispute between counsel on this point. The jury was instructed that statements of counsel in these arguments were not to be considered as evidence, but that their verdict as to the evidence in the case should be governed solely by the testimony.
Finding no reversible error in the case, the judgment of the circuit court of Peoria county is hereby affirmed.
Judgment affirmed.