Carney v. CarneyCarney v. Carney
- Reporters:
- ,
- Before:
- Shortess, Lanier, Crain
Alan Fishbein, Baton Rouge, for defendant Vaden Jackson Carney.
CRAIN, Judge.
Geri Vann Carney Heurtin (hereinafter Mrs. Heurtin) and Vaden Jackson Carney were divorced in January, 1983. Custody of Jackson, the minor child born of the marriage, was awarded to Mrs. Heurtin. In July, 1986, Mr. Carney petitioned for change of custody. Joint custody was awarded pursuant to a plan submitted by the parties. Subsequently, Jackson allegedly began to exhibit behavioral changes. Mrs. Heurtin suggested that Mr. Carney and his present wife, the Heurtins and Jackson participate in family counseling sessions to attempt to alleviate and deal with emotional problems, if any, suffered by Jackson. The Carneys refused to participate. The Heurtins and Jackson were counselled as a family unit by Dr. Karen R. Speier, psychologist. Jackson also underwent individual psychotherapy on a continuing basis.
In May, 1987, Mrs. Heurtin petitioned for sole custody. Mr. Carney answered, filed a rule for contempt and petitioned for modification of the joint custody plan. At the custody hearing, Mrs. Heurtin called Dr. Speier to testify. Mr. Carney asserted the physician-patient privilege on behalf of Jackson and sought to exclude Dr. Speier‘s testimony regarding her treatment of Jackson. The trial court ruled that Dr. Speier‘s testimony was admissible. Carney applied to this court for supervisory writs which we granted. The issue for review is whether the co-tutor or legal representative of a minor child can assert the physician-patient (or health care provider-patient) privilege on behalf of the minor child in a child custody proceeding.
PHYSICIAN-PATIENT PRIVILEGE
The legislature has statutorily provided a qualified privilege for communications between a patient and his health care provider in civil proceedings.
The best interest of the child is the primary consideration in a child custody proceeding.
The trial court determined that the testimony of Dr. Speier, the psychologist who treated Jackson for an extended period of time, is relevant in resolving this custody dispute. In such instances we hold that
AFFIRMED.