68 Mass. 232 | Mass. | 1854
We doubt very much whether, if the petitioner were right in matter of law, Ms remedy would be by mandamus. When a court of special jurisdiction decline acting at all, they may be required by a writ of mandamus to entertain a case within their jurisdiction; to consider it, exercise their jurisdiction, and render some judgment. But in general, this court will not direct them by mandamus what judgment to render, or to reverse a final judgment already entered. That is to be done on an appeal, or some proceeding in the nature of an appeal or writ of error. In a case like this, certiorari would seem to be the proper process to bring the doings of the county commissioners before this court, to determine whether they are erroneous or correct in matters of law. But this point was not argued, and therefore we do not express any opimon upon it.
But the question is, whether the petitioner was too late in making Ms claim for damages. TMs depends upon the act giving the remedy, the charter of the Essex Company, § 8 of which provides that “ any person who shall be damaged in his property, by said corporation, in cutting or making canals through Ms lands, or by flowing the same, or in any other way
The petitioner is precisely within the words of the act of incorporation; he is a person who, as he alleges, would sustain damage in his property, by said corporation, by flowing his lands. He therefore claims to have the remedy given to those whose lands are damaged by railroad corporations, by the works which they are authorized to lay down and construct on the lands of others. The damage done by railroads is seldom, if ever, done by flowing, but ordinarily by taking and appropriating the land. The same remedy then is given against this corporation for damage by flowing, which is given by the Rev. Sts. against railroad corporations for land taken. We think therefore that the limitation of time, within which the remedy is to be sought in the one case, applies to the other.
The term “ flowing lands,” has acquired a definite and specific meaning in our law. It commonly imports raising and setting
Petition for writ of mandamus dismissed.