Caldwell v. DeeseCaldwell v. Deese
- Reporters:
- , ,
- Before:
- Huskins
A party moving for summary judgment under Rule 56 has the burden of “clearly establishing the lack of any triable issue of fact by the record properly before the court. His papers are carefully scrutinized; and those of the opposing party are on the whole indulgently regarded.” 6 Moore’s Federal Practice (2d ed. 1971) § 56.15 [8], at 2439-40; Singleton v. Stewart, 280 N.C. 460, 186 2d 400 (1972). The movant must show (1) that there is no genuine issue as to any material fact, and (2) that the moving party is entitled to a judgment as a matter of law. Rule 56(c); Kessing v. Mortgage Corp., 278 N.C. 523, 180 S.E. 2d 823 (1971).
The movant is held by most courts to a strict standard, and “all inferences of fact from the proofs proffered at the hearing must be drawn against the movant and in favor of the party opposing the motion.” 6 Moore’s Federal Practice (2d ed. 1971) § 56.15 [3], at 2337; accord, United States v. Diebold, Inc., 369 U.S. 654, 8 L.Ed. 2d 176, 82 S.Ct. 993 (1962).
Rule 56 does not authorize the court to decide an issue of fact, but rather to determine whether a genuine issue of fact exists. The rule “is for the disposition of cases where there is no genuine issue of fact and its purpose is to eliminate formal trials where only questions of law are involved.”
Kessing v. Mortgage Corp., supra.
The rule is designed to permit penetration of an unfounded claim or defense in advance of trial and to allow summary disposition for either party when a fatal weakness in the claim or defense is exposed. “The device used
We now apply these legal principles to the record properly before us to determine the propriety of summary judgment for defendant in this case.
Was plaintiff injured and her property (dog) damaged by the negligence of the defendant? This is the paramount overriding issue of fact which plaintiff must establish at trial before any other issue can be reached. To support his motion for summary judgment and establish the nonexistence of negligence on his part, defendant offered plaintiff’s sworn testimony contained in her deposition taken on 19 July 1974. In that deposition plaintiff described the occurrence when her dog was struck as follows:
“Q. If you would, then, go ahead and tell us what occurred as you remember it when you were in the yard there this afternoon ?
“A. Well, when the children had come through the house and ran out into the yard and let the dog out and ran to the back of the car where Mrs. Laurent was standing and I was standing. The bus was coming up the hill, well, it’s not, say, a hill, it’s a grade. So when the children stopped the bus was right on the edge of the road and there was no other traffic there and so it hit the dog and he didn’t make no attempt to stop. I ran between the dog and the children, because he was biting at just midair and when I reached down to grab my baby and my grandbaby to push them back, she caught me in the other hand.
“. . . Stratford Drive ... is a paved street ... inside the city limits ... a little over two cars wide. . . . Two trucks can go down it.”
The rescue doctrine, pleaded in plaintiff’s unverified reply, is accurately expressed in the following excerpt from Alford v. Washington, 238 N.C. 694, 78 S.E. 2d 915 (1953) : “The rule is well settled that one who sees a person in imminent and serious peril caused by the negligence of another cannot be charged with contributory negligence, as a matter of law, in risking his own life or serious injury in. attempting to effect a rescue, provided the attempt is not recklessly or rashly made.” Although plaintiff’s deposition shows that she “ran between the dog and the children, because he was biting at just midair,” and was bitten when she attempted to rescue the children from danger, the rescue doctrine does not’ apply unless it be shown that the peril was caused by the negligence of another, i.e., in this case, the negligence of defendant.
We are not unmindful of the general proposition “that issues of negligence . . . are ordinarily not susceptible of summary adjudication either for or against claimant, but should be resolved by trial in the ordinary manner.” 6 Moore’s Federal Practice (2d ed. 1971) § 56.17 [42] at 2583; 3 Barron and Holtzolff, Federal Practice and Procedure (Wright ed. 1958) § 1232.1 at 106. We said in
Page v. Sloan,
281 N.C. 697, 190 S.E. 2d 189 (1972) : “It is only in exceptional negligence cases
For the reasons stated the decision of the Court of Appeals reversing the entry of summary judgment in favor of defendant is
Reversed.