Byrd v. JonesByrd v. Jones
- Reporters:
- , ,
- Before:
- Smith
In Hewitt v. Gage, 257 Ark. 579, 519 S.W. 2d 749 (1975), we pointed out that there are two methods of appealing from a decision of the Alcoholic Beverage Control Commission. One method was created by the Thorn Liquor Law of 1935, which provides that the appeal is tried de novo in the circuit court.
The present appeal is from an order of the circuit court affirming the action of the ABC Commission in granting, over the appellant’s protest, the application of the appellee Betty Ruth Spires for permission to open a new retail liquor outlet in Union county. This appellant, in appealing to the circuit
For reversal it is now argued, solely, that the ABC Commission failed to make the findings of underlying facts that are required by the Administrative Procedure Act. § 5-710 (b); Ark. Sav. & Loan Assn. Bd. v. Central Ark. Sav. & Loan Assn., 256 Ark. 846, 510 S.W. 2d 872 (1974). If is certainly true that such findings should have been made, because the ABC Commission is not an agency excepted from the Administrative Procedure Act and is therefore subject to its provisions. § 5-701. But the appellant did not choose to seek a reversal in the circuit court for the insufficiency of the Commission’s findings. Instead, he expressly stated in his petition for review that the case should be tried de novo under
The distinction between the two methods of appeal is more than a mere matter of procedure. Under our decision in Ark. Sav. & Loan, supra, the ABC Commission’s failure to make specific findings of fact would have resulted, upon appeal to this court, in a remand to the Commission to give it an opportunity to make the necessary findings. The case might then have been again appealed to the circuit court, and to this court, for a determination of whether the Commission’s findings were supported by substantial evidence. That protracted procedure might well have consumed 18 months or more before a decision upon the merits was finally reached. The ultimate issue would probably have been whether the Commission’s decision, based on the testimony that it heard, was supported by substantial evidence.
Affirmed.
We agree.
Harris, C.J., and Fogleman and Holt, JJ.