Bush v. BarksdaleBush v. Barksdale
- Reporters:
- , ,
This is an appeal from an order of the circuit -court granting appellee’s motion for1 a new trial. Appellant filed a stipulation, in accordance -with the terms of the statute, containing “an assent on the part of the -appellant that, if the order be ‘affirmed, judgment absolute shall be rendered against the appellant. ’ ’ Kirby’s Digest, § 1188.
(1-2) The decision of that question calls for a construction of the statute on the subjeét. It provides, as before indicated, that no appeal from an order granting a new tri-al “shall be effectual for any purpose, unless the notice of appeal contains an assent on the part of the appellant that, if the order be -affirmed, judgment absolute shall be -rendered against the -appellant.” It is further provided by statute that on ‘appeal from an order granting a new trial, “ if the Supreme ‘Court shall determine that no error was committed in granting the new trial, they shall render judgment absolute upon the right of the appellant; -and after the proceedings are remitted to the court from which the appeal was taken, an assessment of damages
(3-6) But, as before stated, an order granting a new trial is by the statute made final upon the filing of a stipulation that it may be so treated, as a decision either way as to the correctness of the order settles the rights of the parties. The stipulation constitutes an election not to submit to a new trial, and it is irrevocable. It deprives the trial court of jurisdiction to proceed with another trial except “for an assessment of damages or other proceedings to render the judgment effectual” in case this -court “shall determine that no error was committed in granting the new trial.” The order granting a new trial is necessarily self-executing and can not be superseded except by an appeal taken in the manner prescribed by the statute, and when the appeal is taken the force of the order can not be reinstated by an -abandonment of the appeal. If the appeal be not prosecuted, the appellee has the right under the statute (Kirby’s Digest, section 1195), to file a transcript of the record, and ask for -an affirmance, which operates -as -a final adjudication of the rights of the parties in the subject-matter of the litigation. The principle that an election of remedies is irrevocable seems too plain for argument to the contrary, and its application
The motion of appellant to dismiss the appeal is therefore overruled, and judgment absolute will be entered to the effect that appellee is entitled to recover in accordance with the prayer of his complaint, .and the cause will be remanded for an assessment of damages and for other proceedings not inconsistent with this opinion. It is so ordered.